Things New and Old

Ancient truths revealed in the Scriptures are often forgotten, disbelieved or distorted, and therefore lost in the passage of time. Such ancient truths when rediscovered and relearned are 'new' additions to the treasury of ancient truths.

Christ showed many new things to the disciples, things prophesied by the prophets of old but hijacked and perverted by the elders and their traditions, but which Christ reclaimed and returned to His people.

Many things taught by the Apostles of Christ have been perverted or substituted over the centuries. Such fundamental doctrines like salvation by grace and justification have been hijacked and perverted and repudiated by sincere Christians. These doctrines need to be reclaimed and restored to God's people.

There are things both new and old here. "Consider what I say; and the Lord give thee understanding in all things"
2Ti 2:7.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

The Popular 5 Solas, with one Fallacious Kink

The kinky one is an illusion, a figment of man's imagination.
Justification before God is NOT by faith, therefore much less by faith alone.
Justification is based solely on the righteousness of Christ alone.
This righteousness is applied to a condemned man by the free grace of God alone,
i.e. without the condemned meeting any condition.
Faith is indeed the ALONE instrument to experience the blessedness...
of one's justified state by the free grace of God.
The blessedness of one's justification by God's free grace
can ONLY be experienced through faith ALONE in the Lord Jesus Christ,
THAT IS, experiential justification is by faith alone.
Few rightly divide the word of truth.
=====


Wiebe posted this popular slogan known as 'The 5 Solas'.
"Scripture alone is the standard, by Christ alone are we saved, salvation is by grace alone, justification by faith alone, for the glory of God alone! ~5 solas.

The following exchanges took place"


McCall
Amen!

Berge
Amen! on that was the reformation built!

Sing F Lau
May I ask a simple question?
Was Abraham justified by God in Gen 12-14?
If he wasn't justified, then he would still be under the condemnation of sin and death, wouldn't he?

Please tell, when was Abraham justified by God?
And please tell, when was Abraham justified by his faith? Please remember that in justification by God, there is imputation and impartation of righteousness to the condemned that was justified. In the justification by faith, there is NO imputation or impartation of Christ's righteousness. There is imputation of the believer's act of believing unto the believing one to experience the blessedness of his justified state by God's free grace.

The sola of the 'justification by faith alone' - what kind of justification is meant - is it legal justification by God's free grace or is it experiential justification by faith?

Is the justification by God and freely by His grace, and the justification conditioned upon man's believing one and the same justification?

Please give me one passage of Scriptures that says justification (that involves the imputation of Christ's righteousness to the one to be justified) is by faith, man's act of believing.

Think a bit please. And no 'reformed' shibboleth please, thank .

Wiebe
How about some scripture, Sing? this should answer your question of when was Abraham justified.

Romans 4:9-16
9 Is this blessing then upon the circumcised, or upon the uncircumcised also? For we say, "Faith was reckoned to Abraham as righteousness." 10 How then was it reckoned? While he was circumcised, or uncircumcised? Not while circumcised, but while uncircumcised; 11 and he received the sign of circumcision, a seal of the righteousness of the faith which he had while uncircumcised, that he might be the father of all who believe without being circumcised, that righteousness might be reckoned to them, 12 and the father of circumcision to those who not only are of the circumcision, but who also follow in the steps of the faith of our father Abraham which he had while uncircumcised. 13 For the promise to Abraham or to his descendants that he would be heir of the world was not through the Law, but through the righteousness of faith. 14 For if those who are of the Law are heirs, faith is made void and the promise is nullified; 15 for the Law brings about wrath, but where there is no law, neither is there violation. 16 For this reason it is by faith, that it might be in accordance with grace, in order that the promise may be certain to all the descendants, not only to those who are of the Law, but also to those who are of the faith of Abraham, who is the father of us all."

Grega
Romans 4 was the passage I first thought of as well. I like the easy questions. And no one even had to include a 'reformed' shibboleth'.

Brown
Our justification is in the person and work of Jesus Christ the object of ones faith. One does not have faith in their justification nor faith in thier faith.

Rom 8:33 Who shall lay any thing to the charge of God's elect? It is God that justifieth.
Rom 8:34 Who is he that condemneth? It is Christ that died, yea rather, that is risen again, who is even at the right hand of God, who also maketh intercession for us.

Just a thought, Gill commentary is fairly actuate:

Rom 5:1 Therefore being justified by faith,.... Not that faith is at the first of our justification; for that is a sentence which passed in the mind of God from all eternity, and which passed on Christ, and on all the elect considered in him, when he rose from the dead; see Rom 4:25; nor is it the chief, or has it the chief place in justification; it is not the efficient cause of it, it is God that justifies, and not faith; it is not the moving cause of it, that is the free grace of God; it is not the matter of it, that is the righteousness of Christ: we are not justified by faith, either as God's work in us, for, as such, it is a part of sanctification; nor as our work or act, as exercised by us, for then we should be justified by works, by something of our own, and have whereof to glory; but we are justified by faith objectively and relatively, as that relates to the object Christ, and his righteousness; or as it is a means of our knowledge, and perception of our justification by Christ's righteousness, and of our enjoying the comfort of it; and so we come to have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. The apostle having set the doctrine of justification in a clear light, and fully proved that it is not by the works of men, but by the righteousness of God; and having mentioned the several causes of it, proceeds to consider its effects, among which, peace with God stands in the first place; and is so called, to distinguish it from peace with men, which persons, though justified by faith in Christ's righteousness, may not have; but are sure, having a sense of this, to find peace with God, even with him against whom they have sinned, whose law they have transgressed, and whose justice they have affronted; reconciliation for sin being made, and a justifying righteousness brought in, and this imputed and applied to them, they have that "peace of God", that tranquillity and serenity of mind, the same with "peace with God" here, "which passes all understanding", Phi_4:7; and is better experienced than expressed: and this is all through our Lord Jesus Christ; it springs from his atoning sacrifice, and precious blood, by which he has made peace; and is communicated through the imputation of his righteousness, and the application of his blood; and is only felt and enjoyed in a way of believing, by looking to him as the Lord our righteousness.

Sing F Lau
Elmer, Scriptures ALONE is the way. Amen.
So, according to your understanding of the Scriptures quoted, Abraham was justified by God at Gen 15:1-6, and therefore he was an UN-JUSTIFIED man before that? Are you saying this?

Then you MUST necessarily concluded that Abraham was an UN-JUSTIFIED man, STILL in his native state of condemnation and death EVEN in Gen12-14? Yes or no?

Now a man is either still under the condemnation of death (the state he is in by nature) OR he is a justified by God, through the imputation of Christ's righteousness to him. Do we agree?

Let me remind ourselves some basics:
Condemnation and Death came by sins. EVEN SO
Justification and Life must come by righteousness - either your own or that of a substitute.

'No righteousness, no justification or life' is the Bible's teaching. Righteousness is the ONE and ONLY indispensable requirement for justification and life, the 'justification of life' in the passage below.

" 18 Therefore as by the offence of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation; even so by the righteousness of one the free gift came upon all men unto justification of life.
19 For as by one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous."

But so many 'reformed' as well as the 'arminians' bring man's faith into the equation of their legal justification by God.

Both believe the devil's lie - that their faith has any instrumental role in their before God.

Faith is the result of justification by God; a fruit and effect of justification can't possibly be the instrumental cause of the same justification. Your rule of non-contradiction applies here as well.

It is 'the just shall live by faith' - it is only the justified that shall live by faith. BUT so many, calvinists as well as arminians, believe, 'the condemned, by their faith, shall be justified by God, and live'! What is perverse twisting!

Faith is fruit and evidence of a justified state by God's free grace. Faith is the instrument to evidence the justification that has taken place!

Abraham was justified by God in the Ur of the Chaldeans when God's effectually called him out of the state of sin and death, to righteousness and life. All of Abraham's life in Gen 12-14 shows that of a justified man walking humbly before God.

And you said he was NOT not justified by God until Gen 15:1-6. There was NO imputation of righteousness, which is at the heart of justification before God, in Gen 15. There is imputation of Abraham's act of faith to him to experience the blessedness of his justified state by God's free grace.

The two are world apart.

Distinction is the essence of sound theology.

I did say, no reformed shibboleth! No offence intended! Just a gentle reminder to stick to Scripture ALONE.

Belgium
AMEN ! (to the 5 solas)

Grega
Sing wrote: "I did say, no reformed shibboleth! No offence intended! Just a gentle reminder to stick to Scripture ALONE. "
You would do well to heed your own advice. In the Romans 4 passage the apostle Paul is contrasting justification by the works of the law with justification by faith. Your long post above does not even mention the law one time. You have absolutely no Scriptural basis for what you're saying because you've gone outside of Scriptural parameters to define your own view. You said "Distinction is the essence of sound theology". Your view is so distinct it's not even in the Bible.

Dekker
Faith is not the result of justification by God. It is the result of regeneration. Ephesains 2:8 says "For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— not by works, so that no one can boast." Justification comes when we exercise this gift. This is the biblical position which is why it is also the reformed position.

Hartman
Paul told Timothy, "...charge some that they teach no other doctrine, neither give heed to fables and [aimless] genealogies, which minister questions, rather than godly edifying which is in faith: so do. Now the [goal] of the commandment is charity out of a pure heart, and of a good conscience, and of faith unfeigned: from which some having swerved have turned aside unto vain jangling; desiring to be teachers of the law; understanding neither what they say, nor whereof they affirm." (1Tim.1:3-7).

Difficulty lies in that the vain janglers always seem to think that the jangling is coming from someone else-- too proud and too blind to even entertain the thought that they themselves might be erring [1Cor.2:7-16].
---------------------------------
Re: the OT saints, the question of "when?" is misplaced. E.g., when was the Lamb of God slain? "...from the foundation of the world." (Rev.8). Why, then was Jesus born and why did He have to die? "That the Scripture might be fulfilled." This was the implementation of the foreordained truth. (Luke 24:25-27).

So it is with those things that were predestined to befall God's people through the ages. As Heb.11 tells us, "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. <> For by it [faith] the elders obtained a good report" (vv.1-2), and in vv.39-40 (following 36 verses not-to-be-skipped) goes on to say, "And these all, having obtained a good report through faith, received NOT the promise: God having provided some better thing for US, that they without us should not be made perfect."

Paul beseeches us to "walk worthy of the vocation wherewith ye are called, with all lowliness and meekness, with longsuffering, forbearing one another in love; endeavoring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body, and one Spirit, even as ye bare called in one hope of your calling: one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of us all, who is above all, and through all, and in you all. But unto every one of us is given grace according to the measure of the gift of Christ." (Eph.4:1-7).

Wiebe
Scripture must interpret Scripture especially if it is a subject explained in another portion of it.

yes, Genesis 15:6 answers Abraham's justification. Abraham received the same Adamic nature that you and I did and therefore had the wrath of God abiding on him until he was declared righteous. John 3:36; Romans 5:9 and Ephesians 2:3

while I am not sure who would legitimately use "man's faith" for justification. Ephesians 2:8-9 is clear that "faith" is a gift of God, not of man.

once again, I am not sure who is saying the following
BUT so many, calvinists as well as arminians, believe, 'the condemned, by their faith, shall be justified by God, and live'! What is perverse twisting!

I am not sure what you are saying in your following comments. please explain "And you said he was NOT not justified by God until Gen 15:1-6. There was NO imputation of righteousness, which is at the heart of justification before God, in Gen 15. There is imputation of Abraham's act of faith to him to experience the blessedness of his justified state by God's free grace."

Sing F Lau
Grega@You would do well to heed your own advice. In the Romans 4 passage the apostle Paul is contrasting justification by the works of the law with justification by faith. Your long post above does not even mention the law one time.
===========

I hope you are aware that there are SEVERAL aspects of justifications. Read WCF 11.4 for a start - decretal, legal, vital/personal, experiential/evidential. (the same is found in the quote from John Gill above)

In legal justification, the contrast is between the righteousness of a condemned criminal or the substitute righteousness of someone else. Faith, man's act of believing play no role in his justification before God. "Being justified FREELY by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus." FREELY cannot be conditioned on faith at the same time. FREELY is FREELY, independent of everything in, and of man.

In experiential justification, the contrast is between a child of God observing ceremonial law or a child of God believing in God's promise concerning the Messiah. Experiential justification is conditioned on faith in the promised Messiah.

Apostle Paul marshaled Abraham to demonstrate the latter. His experiential justification was long before the ceremonial law was ever instituted. That was the point of his demonstration. Therefore Abrahm's justification was without the observation of the ceremonial law, of which circumcision was one.

His experiential justification, conditioned on faith, took place in Gen 15:1-6.

His vital/personal justification, by the FREE grace of God through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, took place in the Us of the Chaldeans when God had called him out of the state of sin and death to that of grace and salvation.

I hope you understand the above, otherwise we are not on the same page.

Wiebe
while it does not appear that he was, it may have been just before that, I am not 100% sure. Joshua gives a little history lesson in Terah and Abraham served other gods:

Joshua 24:2-3
2 And Joshua said to all the people, "Thus says the Lord, the God of Israel, 'From ancient times your fathers lived beyond the River, namely, Terah, the father of Abraham and the father of Nahor, and they served other gods. 3 'Then I took your father Abraham from beyond the River, and led him through all the land of Canaan, and multiplied his descendants and gave him Isaac.

Sing F Lau
Elmer, yes, Genesis 15:6 answers Abraham's justification. Abraham received the same Adamic nature that you and I did and therefore had the wrath of God abiding on him until he was declared righteous. John 3:36; Romans 5:9 and Ephesians 2:3
============

Elmer, can I conclude that in your understanding, Abraham was an UNJUSTIFIED man, i.e. in his state of condemnation and death, which he was in by nature, prior to Gen 15:1-6? Are you saying that Abraham in Gen 12-14 was still an UNGODLY unjustified man, still the the state of condemnation and death?

Grega
Sing wrote: "I did say, no reformed shibboleth! No offence intended! Just a gentle reminder to stick to Scripture ALONE."

You preach to us to stick with the Scripture, and not to give the typical reformed response, and then you respond with the Westminster Confession of Faith??? Is this some kind of a joke?

Sing wrote: "I hope you understand the above, otherwise we are not on the same page".

I guess we're not on the same page. I just read what the apostle Paul wrote in his Epistle to the Romans and believe that. I don't need the WCF to define what the apostle Paul meant. What is it with you people who try to foster confusion among God's people by trying to set yourselves up as some kind of authority of Scripture? The true sheep of the Shepherd hear His voice. Yours makes a strange, incoherent sound.

Sing F Lau
Dekker@Faith is not the result of justification by God. It is the result of regeneration.
==========
Double error here. Take this correction to heart.

Faith is only possible because a man has been justified by God. It is the JUST (the justified ones) who are able to live by faith! An unjustified man, still under condemnation of death does not have faith, much less live by faith.

If faith is the fruit of regeneration, and justification is conditioned on faith, then you have this order: regeneration, faith, justification.

You are saying that regeneration, the giving of eternal life PRECEDES the removal of condemnation of death in justification. If you think that is a biblical truth, you can continue to keep it. No, the Father's work of justification in removing condemnation provides the divine warrant for the Spirit's work of regeneration in giving eternal life. Anything else is IMMORAL.

The common problem here is that you don't distinguish the legal justification which is by the free grace of God, and the experiential justification which is conditioned on faith. The former is God's free and sovereign act is removing condemnation through the imputation of Christ's righteousness. It is LEGAL justification applied to individual elect personally. The latter is conditioned on the faith of a child of God through the imputation of the believing act of God's child. Gen 15:1-6 is speaking of the latter. Very many are confused, and equate it with the former.

It was universally believed by the old school theologians that:
"The reason why any are justified IS NOT because they have faith; but the reason why they have faith IS because they are justified."

Sing F Lau
Diane @ Justification comes when we exercise this gift. This is the biblical position which is why it is also the reformed position."
=====
Reformed position is stated here: WCF 11:4
"God did from all eternity decree to justify all the elect, (11) and Christ did in the fullness of time die for their sins, and rise again for their justification;(12) nevertheless, they are not justified personally, until the Holy Spirit doth in time due actually apply Christ unto them.(13)"

ONLY after that they been justified personally FREELY (i.e. without the condition of faith!) by the grace of God - when the Holy Spirit has in due time actually apply Christ unto them (when they were in the state of death and condemnation, of course!) that they have the grace of faith worked in them to enable them to believe the gospel truth that is already true of them.

"Faith thus receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness, is the alone instrument of justification;(6) yet it is not alone in the person justified, but ever accompanied with all other saving graces, and is no dead faith, but worketh by love.(7)" WCF 11:2.

Please note carefully the reformed position summarized here: faith is NOT alone in the person justified, faith is one of the saving grace found in a justified person, as mentioned in 11:4.
Faith is a fruit of the legal justification applied personally. This is distinct from the experiential justification by faith that follows!

Faith in Christ is the alone INSTRUMENT to experience and to evidence the justified state by the FREE grace of God.

Don't equate one's idea of 'reformed' as 'biblical' too quickly! Too many are already doing it. Don't add another one to the huge crowd

Sing F Lau
Grega@"You preach to us to stick with the Scripture, and not to give the typical reformed response, and then you respond with the Westminster Confession of Faith??? Is this some kind of a joke?"
=====
That's because some equate the two... so I try to show that what they think is the reformed position is not something I find in a reformed confession!

Yes, it is a big joke... everyone calling their idea reformed! It is trendy I think!

Wiebe
@ Sing I believe I have already answered your question so I am not sure why you have to rephrase the same question. let me know what your real question is and maybe then we can proceed from there. you need to articulate your point with much less words. imho

Grega
Sing, I think I know where you're coming from now. But I had to read your blog to find it out. I actually liked some of the things I read there. Don't come on so strong, next time. It's puts people on the defensive. even if what you're saying is worthy of consideration. You have to consider your motivation. Are you seeking to win others to your way of thinking, or are you seeking to win a debate, and condemn everyone who differs with you in the process? Too many people to the latter. You seem to be a person who can be above that sort of thing.

Sing F Lau
Wiebe, if, as so many insist that Abraham's justification BY - BY - BY God took place in Gen15:1-6, then one must necessarily conclude that Abraham was still an UN-JUSTIFIED man before that, i.e.still in his native state of condemnation and death.

Does that idea fit what we read of Abraham in Gen 12-14? That's the question.

Isn't there a massive theological blunder involved by saying that Gen 15:1-6 speak of Abraham justification by God? Oh yes, Gen 15:1-6 does speak of Abraham's justification by his faith!

Ungodly Abram justified by God through His free and sovereign grace is A WORLD APART from godly Abraham being justified by his faith... is it not?

SORRY, I failed to express things better. English is not my native language... I think with a Chinese mind, and express it in English!

An Englishman taught me, when there is contradiction, that exegesis is OFF, eisegesis is IN.

Sing F Lau
Grega, I am just attempting to show that there is a consistent way of understanding the Scriptures. So many aren't aware that their position necessarily involves contradictions and deficiencies while they pontificate about the reformed shibboleth with such presumptuous confidence!

No desire to debate at all... passed that stage already. Just prompting people to see that there is massive inconsistencies and contradictions in their supposed 'reformed' view. That's all.

Wiebe
Sing, who is suggesting that Abram was a godly man before God justified him by grace through faith? as I pointed out earlier, him and his father Terah were worshiping other gods.

Sing F Lau
Wiebe, read Gen 12-14 again, and tell us whether you see an UNGODLY man, still under his native state of condemnation and death, or whether you see an godly man walking with the Lord?

Please tell us, is Abraham in Gen 12-14 a justified man or is he not. It seems to me that you see Abraham as a UNGODLY man, still in his native state of condemnation and death - something so contrary to the plain and straight forward narrative in those three chapters! Do you see the point?

I am stating, and not suggesting, that Abram in Gen 12-14 is a godly man, having been LEGALLY justified by THE FREE GRACE OF GOD when God effectually called him out of his state of sin and death to that of righteousness and eternal life. Faith is not involved here... it is FREELY - FREELY - FREELY by God's grace through the righteousness of Christ.

I am also stating that Gen 15:1-6 speaks of Abraham's EXPERIENTIAL justification by HIS FAITH. By his faith, he experienced the blessedness of his justified state that occurred long ago in the Ur of the Chaldeans when grace was FREELY - FREELY - FREELY first applied to Abram personally.

Legal Justification by the FREE GRACE of God, and the Experiential Justification by Abraham's faith are TWO VERY DIFFERENT aspects of justification.

The old school theologians kept this distinction so clearly... their children still do... their step children have not only lost it all, they repudiate it.

Grega
Sing, what's with the sarcastic grin thing? You talk some much about "experiential justification". How about some "experiential SANCTIFICATION'. It's too bad. You have some good points to make, but you're blowing it with your attitude.

Sing F Lau
Grega@ the grin is not sarcastic. It expresses something which is funny to me.

I have come across this common attitude many times, "I like what you said, but I don't like the way you say it." Instead of dealing with the issue under discussion, they get sidetracked with subjective feelings. Quite common.

Attitude problem indeed - got sidetracked by a 'grin' thing!

Sing F Lau
Brother Steve, thank you quoting Gill on Rom 5:1.

Did anyone read it carefully, and noticed that Gill, (very many 'refromed' folks HATE Gill... and slander him as hyper!) in common with the old school theologians of his period, ENUMERATED the FOUR DISTINCT aspects of justification:
- decretal justification of all elect before time.
- legal justification of all elect at the cross... See More
- vital/personal justification of individual elect at effectual calling out of the state of sin and death to that of righteousness and eternal life
- experiential justification as the effect.

I paste the initial part of the quote here: read and think over it:

Rom 5:1 Therefore being justified by faith,.... Not that faith is at the first of our justification; for that is a sentence which passed in the mind of God from all eternity, and which passed on Christ, and on all the elect considered in him, when he rose from the dead; see Rom_4:25; nor is it the chief, or has it the chief place in justification; it is not the efficient cause of it, it is God that justifies, and not faith; it is not the moving cause of it, that is the free grace of God; it is not the matter of it, that is the righteousness of Christ: we are not justified by faith, either as God's work in us, for, as such, it is a part of sanctification; nor as our work or act, as exercised by us, for then we should be justified by works, by something of our own, and have whereof to glory; but we are justified by faith objectively and relatively, as that relates to the object Christ, and his righteousness; or as it is a means of our knowledge, and perception of our justification by Christ's righteousness, and of our enjoying the comfort of it;
======

Notes:
- 'THE FIRST OF OUR JUSTIFICATION... a sentence which passed in the mind of God from all eternity.

- The JUSTIFICATION that took place through Christ, and ON - ON - ON all the elect considered in Him, WHEN He rose from the dead.

- The JUSTIFICATION that took place by the free grace of God as God's work -IN - IN - IN each individual elect.

- The JUSTIFICATION that took place by faith, faith as a means our knowledge, and perception of our justification by Christ's righteousness, and of our enjoying the comfort of it.

"
We are not justified by faith, either as God's work in us, for, as such, it is a part of sanctification, nor as our work or act, as exercised by us, for then we should be justified by works."

All there... and the common understanding of all the old school theologians... these understanding have been summarized in both WCF and 1689 (more precise, being issued later).

Friday, May 28, 2010

Monergism and Synergism Confused and Confounded

Keep monergism and synergism distinct and separate.
Otherwise the confusion 'zonkey' will inevitably show!


This quote was posted... and an exchange followed.

"This is the single issue that separates the supernatural religion of Christianity from the man-centered religions that surround us. Whether the work of salvation is perfectly accomplished by God for His own glory or is dependent upon man's cooperation and assistance is the watershed issue that separates Biblical Christianity from everything else." James White
=====

Sing F Lau
Men may mouth MONERGISM (i.e. salvation by free and sovereign grace alone) but they always inevitably end up with SYNERGISM because they are UNABLE or REFUSE to differentiate the ETERNAL salvation that is completely and wholly and solely by God's free and sovereign grace alone, and the temporal salvation (relation to the life here and now) that is conditioned upon the obedient response of God's children to the divine grace working, i.e. God's children, saved with eternal salvation by God's free and sovereign grace alone, must work out THEIR OWN salvation for the life here.

Sing F Lau
Eternal salvation is by free grace alone... that means NO CONDITION whatsoever for our eternal salvation. God saved us by His free and sovereign grace, then we are called to believe the truth of our salvation by grace. Only those that are saved are able to believe spiritual things... some believe more, others believe less.

Sing F Lau
Stephen@ "Christ died for all sin, but not all men are saved for their rejection of Him."

If Christ died for all sin, then all sin of all men have been atoned for, payment for all sin of all men has been made. Is this what you are saying?

Their rejection of Him is because they are not among those for whom He died. They are not among the sheep, and Christ did not die for them. "But ye believe not, because ye are not of my sheep, as I said unto you. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me."

Jesus gave His life for the sheep ONLY, and none others. God the Father gave sheep to Jesus Christ... but they were LOST sheep... and Jesus came to seek and save the sheep ONLY... He lay down His life for the sheep.

Sing F Lau
Do you mean by 'the whole world' as embracing every man of the world exhaustively, OR all sort of men distributively, i.e, not just the Jews, but men and women of every nation, tongue, tribe and people?

If Christ did die for all the sins of all men, then on what basis were those in hell find themselves there? Was it just that they find themselves... there? Was it their sin of unbelief? If it is, then Christ did not die for their sin of unbelief... then Christ did not die for ALL the sin of ALL men! If Christ did die for their sin of unbelief, then why are they still condemned for that sin? Isn't it utter immoral and injustice to demand for double payment of a crime? Let us be careful lest God's name be maligned!

Wiebe
@ Stephen. would you say that the one that becomes a Christian does it through a process of human choice and in cooperation with God with acceptance, completing the salvation gift? the one rejecting would be lost by their own choice?

Sing F Lau
Elmer@ "would you say that the one that becomes a Christian does it through a process of human choice and in cooperation with God with acceptance, completing the salvation gift? the one rejecting would be lost by their own choice?"
======================

There is a salvation that is entirely by God's free grace on the one hand... MONERGISTIC i.e... . purposed by God, accomplished by Christ, and applied to each individual elect in his state of death and condemnation... thus turning a condemned dead alien into a justified, regenerated and adopted son, indwelt by the Spirit of God, completely fitting him for eternal glory. His ETERNAL SALVATION is complete, ALL by God's free grace. This child of God, destined for eternal glory needs to be saved by the gospel ministry. But the gospel ministry deal with timely or temporal salvation... salvation pertaining to the life here and now. The gospel ministry saves a child of God from ignorance, lies and untruth, warns and weans him from worldliness, trains him in righteousness, etc... all having NOTHING to do with ETERNAL SALVATION.

And it seems there is ANOTHER way of salvation proposed above by Elmer: a salvation that is SYNERGISTIC... 'through a process of human choice and in cooperation with God with acceptance, completing the salvation gift." This salvation requires the ACTIVE participation of man TO COMPLETE.

If Elmer is speaking of the timely or temporal salvation, then he would be right. In the timely or temporal salvation, God's children (and they become God's children all by the free grace of God) must WORK OUT THEIR OWN SALVATION with FEAR and trembling.

The ETERNAL SALVATION is entirely by the free and sovereign will of God. This is pure MONERGISM.

The TEMPORAL SALVATION is by the obedient responses of God's children to the commands of God to them. This is real SYNERGISM.

There must be a clear and sharp distinction between the two... else there will be confusion.

Distinction is the essence of sound theology. Paul reminded Timothy "Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth."

Harvell Jr
I do believe Sing F Lau that Elmer would hold to what Reformed Theology believes concerning monergism and synergism. This is how Reformed distinguishes between the two:

The Reformed faith teaches that the initial first step or the act that causes a sinner to come from death unto life is God's resurrecting power. In other words regeneration is ... monergistic. It is an alone working of God, whereby he works alone to bring the sinner from death to life. But after the sinner is regenerated or made alive, then the life the believer lives is a synergistic work. The sinner works with God in working out his salvation with fear and trembling.

Wiebe
@ Sing it seems my question of the way of salvation was not understood the way I intended it to be. Make no mistake, I testify to the synergistic work of God in my regeneration. the Glory goes to Him alone!

I proposed it because most people including myself learn more by asking questions. it is not about me, but about the Truth.

the Bible does NOT violate the law of non-contradiction so my question to you, Sing. how can salvation be temporal and eternal? I am not sure how 2 Timothy 2:15 answers your assertion. is this splitting hairs? this is something new to me.

Wiebe
thanks Hershel for coming to my defense clarifying the I am reformed in my soteriology in that God is the one who regenerates His sheep as His Elect as His vessels of honor via the Potter's redemptive hand.

Sing F Lau
Elmer@ "the Bible does... NOT violate the law of non-contradiction so my question to you, Sing. how can salvation be temporal and eternal? I am not sure how 2 Timothy 2:15 answers your assertion. is this splitting hairs? this is something new to me."

The ancients have used adjectives 'eternal' and 'temporal' with regard to ... salvation, to clearly distinguish the distinction between the two. They are two distinct entity. They understood the Scriptures more completely than many of us today.

Eternal salvation is God's monergistic work of saving His elect from their just and deserved eternal condemnation. These deals with eternal realities. This deals solely with their eternal well being. This aspect of salvation is absolutely and exactly the same for every child of God - all equally justified, regenerated, adopted, and glorified. In all these, God's elect are absolutely PASSIVE... i.e. no synergism involved at all.

Temporal salvation is the synergistic work of God's children, in cooperation with, and response to the work of the Spirit within them, to save themselves from this perverse and wicked generation. This deals with their well being in their temporal life here and now on earth. In temporal salvation, there is a WIDE range and degree... conditioned upon the obedient response of each child of God in working out his OWN salvation with fear and trembling!

Sing F Lau
Elmer, is there any typo in this declarative statement of yours? - "I testify to the SYNERGISTIC [emphasis mine] work of God in my regeneration. the Glory goes to Him alone!"

What role did your play in your regeneration - since you see it as synergistic? Trying to understand you!

Sing F Lau
Elmer@ "the Bible does violate the law of non-contradiction so my question to you, Sing. how can salvation be temporal and eternal? I am not sure how 2 Timothy 2:15 answers your assertion. is this splitting hairs? this is something new to me."

NO law of non-contradiction is violated at all. This is because we are NOT saying that ONE salvation is BOTH eternal and temporal. If that is the case, then it is indeed irrational and nonsensical. A cannot be non-A at the same time.

However we are speaking of two distinct salvation, just as the Bible presents so clearly - one that is purposed, accomplished and applied to them personally by free and sovereign grace alone, and one that God's children must be actively involved to work it out from themselves.

There is a salvation which the Lord God Himself has worked out for us... He himself purposed it, accomplished it, and effectively applied it to individual elect, fitting him for eternal glory, without him meeting any condition!

Rom 8:29 "For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren. 30 Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified." In all these, the objects are absolutely passive.

The salvation which the Lord MONERGISTICALLY purposed, accomplished and effectually applied to each individual is TOTALLY distinct and separate from the salvation which God's children are commanded to work out for themselves. "Wherefore, my beloved, as ye have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out YOUR WON SALVATION with fear and trembling."

Another passage, Pastor Timothy must work out his own salvation, and that of those under his charge... "Meditate upon these things; give thyself wholly to them; that thy profiting may appear to all. 16 Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both SAVE THYSELF, and them that hear thee."

The (temporal) salvation that involves the active work and obedience of God's children is very different from the (eternal) salvation that God alone, by His own power, purposed, accomplished, and applied to each elect individually by His free and sovereign grace.

I hope I make some sense.


Wiebe
@ Saul too much multi-tasking on my part. I am sorry, Sing. thanks for pointing that out, brother. I saw what I posted and yes it is a typo (misspeak). one of the things of getting older. My apologies everyone. I got my mix talked up. :(

Wiebe
this 2 salvation type theory still troubles me, though. while our state in heaven will be different in heaven as glorified bodies than here on earth, but to compare them as two different salvations suggests in-continuity between the two. we are God's workmanship start to finish, Author and Perfecter. we are not the author and perfecter of our faith, faith is a divine gift!

Harvell Jr
The idea of concurrence or confluence whereby two personages work together towards the same goal would still apply after we are regenerated. God begins a work in us to bring us to an ordained decreed end of perfection. Hence the scripture states Work out your own salvation withj fear and trembling. For it is God which worketh in you both to will ... and to do of his good pleasure. Therefore I would not make to broad of a distinction(if I made one at all) between temporal and eternal. The salvation that we enjoy in this life is the result of the same decree given by the Father when he chose us before the foundations of the world to be conformed to the image of Christ.

Sing F Lau
Hershel@ 'The salvation that we enjoy in this life is the result of the SAME DECREE given by the Father when he chose us before the foundations of the world to be conformed to the image of Christ."
=======

If that is indeed true, then we should expect EVERY ELECT to experience and enjoy the same salvation in this life... which is no true at all. There are Lots, and there are Abrahams; there are Paul who fought a good fight of faith, nd there are those who made a shipwreck of their faith!

There are God's children who enjoy and experience great measure and degree of temporal salvation in this life. Others experience very little... some do not even have the Holy Scriptures in their own language. Some enjoy faithful gospel ministry and biblical church fellowship... others virtually nil.

Are these vast differences in this life ALL ordained and decreed before the foundation of the world?

Some of God's children died without hearing the true gospel! They have been told half-truth and lies all their life! These do not enjoy the temporal salvation of hearing the true gospel? Are these decreed by God also?

Men may mouth MONERGISM but they always inevitably end up with SYNERGISM because they are UNABLE and REFUSE to differentiate the ETERNAL salvation that is completely and wholly and solely by God's free and sovereign grace, and the temporal (relation to the life here and now) salvation that conditioned upon the response of God's children to the divine grace working in them.

God's children working out THEIR OWN SALVATION is obviously different from the salvation that is worked out and applied by the free and sovereign grace the Lord's ALONE!

That which is divinely decreed would necessarily be true of every child of God in the same nature and degree... eternal blessings such as justification, regeneration, eternal life, adoption, the gift of the Holy Spirit to dwell within the heart, and glorification...

The temporal salvation a child of God will experience in this life is LARGELY conditioned upon his obedience to the will of the Father...

One is wholly MONERGISTIC, God ALONE is wholly active.
The other is wholly SYNERGISTIC, God's children actively working through the grace working in them.

Without distinguishing them clearly, salvation by grace ALONE is necessarily and inevitably adulterated and contaminated by man's part, and thus repudiated!

What is the point of shouting Grace ALONE so loud, when it is note alone at all?

It is still monergistic even though it requires man's active role in it!

Harvell Jr
Sing F Lau you are mixing up God's common grace with Special saving grace. One may not have the Bible written in their own language yet they had to have heard the word in their own language or they would not be children of God, for faith cometh by hearing and hearing by the word of God. All of God's elect, all of those who are born again and have ... come from death to life, enjoy the same salvation my friend. They all may not enjoy the same common grace such as you are speaking, but all enjoy the same salvation. God has not called us to a life of ease and relaxation. He has not called us to a life of making this world our home. All of God's elect have received the inward work of regeration and therefore take joy in what they will experience in the world to come and they all confess that they are strangers and pilgrims in this world. Yet not all have the same living conditions in this world nor the same amount of persecution. I want to add that you stated that some of God's children have had only have truths, yet they had to have had enough truth to save them or they would not be God's children. I also will add that ungodly men most of the time have more temporal blessings than the elect, yet are not saved. This my friend is common grace given to all men, but only saving grace is given to the elect. Do not confuse temporal blessings with spiritual blessings. All of God's redeemed elect have been translated into the kingdom of God's dear Son and are seated in the heavenly with Christ and have been blessed with spiritual blessings in the heavenlies in Christ.

Harvell Jr
Another point bugs me whereby you state that some of God's children have died not hearing the true gospel. My friend if this is the case then they were never God's children. One must hear in order to be saved.

I also want to reaffirm that you have totally confused natural blessings with spiritual ones. You have not been exposed to the word of faith movement have you?

Sing F Lau
Hershel@ you are mixing up God's common grace with Special saving grace.
=======
I read of NO - NO - NO grace that is common, and NO - NO - NO grace that is apart from and outside of, Jesus Christ. And grace in Jesus Christ is very specific and non-common.

Sir, you are confusing God's work of providence as Creator, and God's work of redemption as Redeemer. God the Creator is benevolent to His creatures - whether elect or not. God the Redeemer is gracious to His elect alone... through His Son Jesus Christ alone.

Sing F Lau
Hershel @ 'Another point bugs me whereby you state that some of God's children have died not hearing the true gospel. My friend if this is the case then they were never God's children. One must hear in order to be saved."

Sir, one must first be saved by God with ETERNAL salvation before he can ever hear to be saved from lies and errors, ... and be brought to know the truth of his eternal salvation ENTIRELY by God's free grace, and be taught to live godly, soberly and righteously... thus saving him from the evils and wickedness of this perverse generation.

One must FIRST be a made a child of God, all by the free and sovereign grace of God, BEFORE he can hear and receive the things of the Spirit... to save him from hell here on earth.

"Except a man be born again... except a man be given eternal salvation... HE CANNOT... CANNOT... CANNOT..." Do people take the declaration of Jesus Christ seriously?

I said before... though many shout MONERGISM, so much they say BETRAY that they are full of SYNERGISM!

God's children among the Arminians lived and died without hearing the true gospel. Perhaps you would accept Arminianism as teaching the true gospel. Of course many so called 'reformed' people would deny that Arminians are true children of God!

Why do people declare from one side of their mouth that salvation is entirely by the free and sovereign grace of God, and in the same breath from the other side of their one same mouth insist that this SAME salvation is conditioned on so many things... preaching of the gospel, hearing the true gospel, believing the right doctrines, etc?

If the clear and obvious distinction between the CAUSE of the eternal salvation is MONERGISTIC, and the effect and manifestation of that salvation is SYNERGISTIC, then all the confusion and contradiction disappeared!

Sing F Lau
Hershel@ "I also want to reaffirm that you have totally confused natural blessings with spiritual ones."
======

Would you classify that salvation that you have to work out for yourself with fear and trembling as natural blessing? Or are they spiritual blessings? I have said they are spiritual blessings.

I think you are confused as well as mistaken! I am talking about SPIRITUAL blessings... spiritual blessings that are ETERNAL in nature (i.e. that pertain unto eternity) secured for us by the free and sovereign grace of God, and spiritual blessings that are temporal in nature (i.e. that pertains to this brief life on earth only) that are worked out for ourselves through the grace of God working in us.

The former are eternal blessings by divine MONERGISM.
The latter are temporal blessing by SYNERGISM of human working in obedient to God's grace in them.

Hartman
The reason our working "out" of our salvation is monergistic and not synergistic is that it is the work of God in us, based upon the completed work of Christ, by which salvation was worked "in" to us.
Jesus said that apart from Him we can do nothing, but we are to abide in Him as branches of a vine. The branches exert no self-effort, and all the fruit is produced by the vine, through the branches.

Sing F Lau
Hmmmm, your working out your own salvation - is that salvation part of the same salvation that Christ has worked out for you?

The way you put it, monergism and synergism become synonymous, and the stark distinction between ceases. There is no more difference between the two!

We are put in union with Christ through the free and sovereign grace of God in the effectual calling out of our state of sin and death to that of grace and salvation - all monergistically, without any aid or help from us.

As God's children (by His free and sovereign grace alone), if we abide in Christ in our discipleship, we are able to work out our own salvation with fear and trembling. God's children who do not abide in Christ make shipwreck of their faith... like Lot messing up his life big time!

Our working out our own salvation, which is temporal in nature, is CONDITIONED upon our abiding in Christ. God's Spirit works in us to will and to do... but we are the ones who must DO and ACT, in obedient to the Father's will, to work out our own salvation... to save us from this crooked generation... not to save us from eternal condemnation. God alone has done that for His elect through Christ and His Spirit.

Working out our own salvation has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with delivering ourselves from eternal condemnation or securing for ourselves eternal salvation. That work of ETERNAL redemption is ABSOLUTELY by the free and sovereign grace of God ALONE, PLUS nothing.

Harvell Jr
Evidently you have never studied theology because Yes yes yes theologians distinguish between common grace and special saving grace The bible declares that God is good to all and his tender mercies are over all his works Psalms 145:9 and God blessed Ishmael and Esau with the natural things of life but only special grace was given to Isaac and Jacob.

Harvell Jr
I believe that I was accused of confusing natural blessings with spiritual blessings though I did accuse Sing F Lau of this about 3 post ago because Sing keeps arguing from the temporal to the spiritual and vis a versus. This much said I will reiterate that the same salvation of which I have a dear brother in Korea also possesses though our spiritual growth is not the same and our calling of where to grow in grace is not the same. I also reaffirm that ones initial regeneration is an act of God alone and that after we are born again we do work with God. Our salvation after we come to life is synergistic. The work we do after this is done in cooperation with God. Paul did not write his epistles to dead men, but to those who were brought out of death, therefore we cannot state that salvation is completely monergistic after the initial first working of God.

Sing F Lau
Harvell@ "Sing keeps arguing from the temporal to the spiritual and vis a versus."

Hello, you are very confused, and perhaps obtuse, too. Temporal is contrasted with eternal; and natural with spiritual. I didn't argue from temporal to spiritual... that's your imagination. I am distinguishing spiritual blessings that are ETERNAL from spiritual blessing that are TEMPORAL. Do you get the simple point?

Sing F Lau
Hershel@ "Our salvation after we come to life is synergistic. The work we do after this is done in cooperation with God. Paul did not write his epistles to dead men, but to those who were brought out of death, therefore we cannot state that salvation is completely monergistic after the initial first working of God"

You have used both adjectives - 'synergistic' and 'monergistic'. Well done! Can you now tell us exactly which part of salvation is synergistic and which part is monergistic? And how do you distinguish the two?

Can the one and the same salvation be at the same time monergistic as well as synergistic?

Or that which is monergistic and that which is synergistic are distinct and separate because one deals with eternal issues, and the other deal with temporal issues (things pertaining to this life only)?

And don't forget Elmer's reminder on the law of non-contradiction.

Harvell Jr
To James Gaylon: I understand that we were discussing whether Stephen needed to repent about not believing what Christ said. But he gave the challenge that he would repent if I could prove that the Bible teaches that he must believe in Calvinism. But here he is building a straw man and tearing it down. No Calvinist teaches this, but instead teaches... that one must believe in Christ, yet I told him that if I could give a scripture showing that Christ said his sacrifice was limited then he needs to repent for not believing what Christ said. I gave 3 scriptures of which he has yet to answer. I will also state that the Hebrews writer also gives a warning concerning Christ sacrifice of those who would trodden under foot the Son of God and count his blood as an unholy thing. The Greek word for unholy can be translated common. They trodden under foot the Son of God by counting the blood of the covenant as something that is common to all. Hebrews 10:29

Sing F Lau
Hershel @ " I will also state that the Hebrews writer also gives a warning concerning Christ sacrifice of those who would trodden under foot the Son of God and count his blood as an unholy thing. "

The book of Hebrews was written to God's children among the Jews, Hebrew believers in Jesus Christ. These were in danger of reverting back to the old covenant ways of worship... with all its sacrifices.

The author is warning these CHILDREN of God who are believers in Jesus Christ that to revert back to those old covenant sacrifices is equivalent to trampling underfoot and despising the sacrifice of Jesus Christ. And this evil has grave judgment here and now to them... It has NOTHING to do with their eternal salvation/condemnation That's a done thing, all by God's free and sovereign grace. It is about temporal condemnation.

" 27 But a certain fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour the adversaries. 28 He that despised Moses’ law died without mercy under two or three witnesses:
29 Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace?"

The punishment spoken here is God chastising His children for unbelief! Verse 27 speaks of the fiery destruction in 70AD!

Their eternal salvation is solely and completely by God's free and sovereign grace alone, absolutely independent of what they can or unable to do. Their obedience or disobedience will affect their temporal salvation... which they have to work out for themselves

Tilton
You both might be saying the same, yet maybe a little differently. I desire to radically work out my salvation because He started His work in me, which is a result of His perfect work at Calvary. He started the work and is working, that's why I work. I must be involved in the sanctification process. If I'm not, I could end up like Lot. Thanks for that comment about Lot, Sing! There are other examples of those who are truly Christ's, yet could end up like Lot for not working out their salvation. One example is David, who lived in his sin without confessing and repenting for quite awhile until Nathan came to him. Part of what happens in believers we know is clearly seen from God's side and not ours. I just know, I wouldn't be working out my salvation if it wasn't for His working in me, yet now with that knowledge, I better be radically working it out!

Sing F Lau
Tilton@ "Thanks for that comment about Lot, Sing! There are other examples of those who are truly Christ's, yet could end up like Lot for not working out their salvation."

May I ask, those who failed to work out their own salvation and ended up like Lot, is their eternal salvation by the free and sovereign grace of God any less than that of Abraham and Paul? Is the vast difference between the temporal salvation of Abraham and Lot attributed to God, or chiefly attributed the them, their negligence or vigilance in working out their own salvation?

Hartman
Richard, I think you've hit the nail on the head!
Sing has elaborated my point in a much clearer presentation than my brief statement made. The difference between us, as I see it, is a misunderstanding of terminology:
The salvation that is worked FOR us by Christ is also worked IN to us by God, to be worked OUT by us IN and By the power of God ... which works IN us to will and to do His good pleasure.
It is NOT synergy, for synergy is a partnership (a co-operation of elements which each depend upon the other's support). We are WHOLLY dependent upon God (unable in ourselves to do anything), whereas God needs nothing from us in order to achieve His ends.
Often the barrier to understanding one another owes as much to the way one listens as to the way the other speaks.

Sing F Lau
If God's children have to work out their own salvation, then they play an active role in the accomplishment of this salvation, do they not? They don't meet the condition, they don't get the salvation. And you still insist that that salvation is still monergistic, and not synergistic! Words have lost all its meaning.

Monergistic salvation is one ... which is completely dependent upon God's free and sovereign acts alone, absolutely independent of anything in, and of man.

A salvation that is conditioned upon God's children obedient responses to the grace working in them INVOLVES their ACTIVE and CONSCIOUS role. This salvation that requires the active role of God's children can only be temporal salvation... to do with their WELL BEING here and now. It has NOTHING to do with their BEING, children of God completely fitted for eternal glory by God's free and sovereign grace alone.

If you insist that this is still MONERGISTIC salvation, then reasonable communication has broken down.

To so many, monergistic is also synergistic, and synergistic is also monergistic!

They have become synonymous because they can't and refuse to recognize the biblical distinction between monergistic salvation by God's free and sovereign grace, and synergistic salvation by the active obedient response to the grace of God working in them.

Hartman
Brother Sing, monergism and synergism ARE distinctly different. You speak well, Brother, but you do not listen well. It would seem that you are so convinced you are right that you can hear nothing but your own voice. I mean no insult or disrespect in saying this, but I have spoken plainly and you respond as if I had not spoken at all. You are ... reading my comments eisegetically, assigning to my words meanings I do not intend, but you are not exegeting the meaning of what I say.
As monergism differs from synergism, so dialogue differs from monologue.
I ask you to objectively and prayerfully review my comments before responding again: ask God for wisdom to learn more than you presently know-- to stop growing is a living death.
Salvation is of [from] the Lord; not some salvation or a certain kind of salvation. The works that we perform in the flesh we are enabled to do by the grace of God given to us in Christ. To say that God needs our help to deliver us in this world is to deny His omnipotence and sovereignty.
Peace, Brother-- rest well. It is time here for sleep.

Wiebe
well said about the barrier of communication, Al. we have all been down that road a time or two.

Sing F Lau
Brother Hartman, I could also say the same of you! But it won't help in the discussion.

If there is ONLY ONE salvation, then it must be implied that the salvation of the Lord that was purposed, accomplished and worked in and applied to each of His children is quite different indeed.

The fact of this vast difference is plain and obvious to... See More all. There are Lots and there are Abraham, there are Paul who fought a good fight of faith, and there those who make shipwreck of their faith... YET they are equally saved with ETERNAL salvation by God's free and sovereign... though in temporal salvation, they were saved to vastly different degree.

But the eternal salvation from the Lord is exactly the same for each of his elect - see Rom 8:29-30.

However the temporal salvation of God experienced by each child of God varies VASTLY because this salvation is CONDITIONED upon God's children working SYNERGISTICALLY with the grace of God working in them. There is a direct HUMAN factor in it - thus synergistic.

The vast difference in the temporal salvation CANNOT be attributed to God working differently in each of His children. It must be attributed to the difference in the response of each child of God to the same grace working in them; the different degree to which God's children shoulder their responsibility in working out their OWN salvation.

You said, "To say that God needs our help to deliver us in this world is to deny His omnipotence and sovereignty."

To deny that temporal salvation is dependent and conditioned upon the conscious obedience of God children to His will for them is to deny and repudiate true human responsibility altogether.

No, God's does not need our help to deliver us in this world. He does not even ask for our help in order for Him to help us. The fact is, He commanded us to work out our own salvation. He DOES NOT do it for us. His children must do it themselves... and do it with FEAR and TREMBLING. If they don't do it, they don't get it... they shall suffer the temporal consequence of their disobedience in this life.

Have a good sleep brother! Shalom!

Hartman
When God destroyed the world by flood, Noah was not spared because he was righteous but because he found grace in the eyes of the LORD. If that grace was given as a reward for righteousness, it could no longer be called grace, for grace is unearned and unwarranted favor.

Sing F Lau
Hartman @"When God destroyed the world by flood, Noah was not spared because he was righteous but because he found grace in the eyes of the LORD. If that grace was given as a reward for righteousness, it could no longer be called grace, for grace is unearned and unwarranted favor."
========

Please tell, is saving from the flood the same as saving from the eternal consequences of sin? Is saving from the flood eternal salvation?

And do you think all those 8 that we saved from the flood were all saved with eternal salvation?

And do you think that among all that perished in the flood, all perished ETERNALLY, i.e. gone to hell?

Or is the deliverance from the flood a temporal salvation, in which Noah and his family was VERY actively involved. It was a salvation that Noah cooperated actively! That's not monergistic is it, if monergistic has any meaning at all .

Noah being shown grace, eternal salvation in Jesus Christ is monergistic. Noah being saved from the flood is entirely SYNERGISTIC, he cooperating actively with the grace of God shown.


Hartman
Brother Sing, you seem to see salvation as an "either/or" proposition: Either God is the sole agent of salvation OR man is responsible to act on his own behalf. Therefore you divide salvation into two separate classes, eternal and temporal. The Bible does not make such a distinction.

Sing F Lau
Hartman @Brother Sing, you seem to see salvation as an "either/or" proposition: Either God is the sole agent of salvation OR man is responsible to act on his own behalf. Therefore you divide salvation into two separate classes, eternal and temporal. The Bible does not make such a distinction.
=========

The Bible doesn't make such distinction??? Or is it because men fail or refuse to rightly divide the word of truth.

The Bible on the one hand declares of a salvation is of the Lord... by grace alone... the eternal redemption that Christ alone is the author and have accomplished for His people. The Bible ALSO and IN ADDITION to that declare that there is a salvation that God's children are to work out for themselves with fear and trembling... a salvation CONDITIONED upon their obedience!

One can choose to see them as one salvation and live with the contradiction and confusion, or one can rightly divide the word of truth... and see two distinct salvation spoken of... the former with the Triune God alone as the author, the latter God's children working actively in response to God's grace working in them.

And in light of these plain facts men pontificate that the Bible does not make the distinction! I stand amaze!


Hartman
Salvation is God's work alone. That is why Jesus is called Savior and we are not. But God certainly DOES hold us accountable to obey such commandments as to work out our own salvation. This may constitute paradox, but it is NOT contradiction. PLEASE NOTE: we are to work OUT our salvation, but NOT to work FOR or TOWARDS our salvation. God has worked salvation for us through Christ and worked it IN us by the Holy Spirit's administration of His Word. Now that it is IN us, we are responsible to work it OUT, i.e. to manifest it.

Sing F Lau
Hartman@Salvation is God's work alone. That is why Jesus is called Savior and we are not. But God certainly DOES hold us accountable to obey such commandments as to work out our own salvation. This may constitute paradox, but it is NOT contradiction. PLEASE NOTE: we are to work OUT our salvation, but NOT to work FOR or TOWARDS our salvation. God ... has worked salvation for us through Christ and worked it IN us by the Holy Spirit's administration of His Word. Now that it is IN us, we are responsible to work it OUT, i.e. to manifest it.
=====

'Salvation is God's works alone.' Please tell, what is this salvation that is God's works alone? So, I take it that anything that is not by God's work alone is no longer this same salvation spoken of... otherwise words cease to have specific meaning. FULL of contradiction, sir!

Is it the same with the salvation that God's children are commanded to work out for themselves?

How can the salvation that is by the work of God ALONE, and the salvation that is by the working of God's children in respond to God's grace working in them STILL be the one and the same salvation? FULL of contradiction, sir!

The salvation that is worked for us by Christ (legal) and worked in by the Spirit (applied personally) is the eternal salvation by God's free and sovereign grace... it is God's work alone in delivering from the eternal condemnation of our sins, and bringing us in the state of eternal salvation. The working of that ETERNAL salvation is a finished and done thing by God alone.

You are giving the impression that you must continue that same salvation that God has began and will complete Himself. So, you INDEED have some part to play in your eternal salvation! Then your eternal salvation is NOT longer the work of God alone, is it? It is more like God began it, and you conclude it by your work.

Brother, I am not saying that this is what you believe... but merely pointing the logical conclusion if you fail to distinguish the eternal salvation by free grace alone, and the temporal salvation by God's children working it out for themselves with fear and trembling!

Hartman
How is it possible for God to be utterly sovereign and omnipotent while at the same time holding us responsible for acts of our will? He hasn't given us the specifics, perhaps because we are as yet incapable of comprehending it, but most certainly because such full knowledge would make faith impossible. Faith IS the evidence of things not seen.

Sing F Lau
Hartman@ "How is it possible for God to be utterly sovereign and omnipotent while at the same time holding us responsible for acts of our will?"

God is sovereign and omnipotent in our eternal salvation. He alone is does it all... see Romans 8:29-30.

And He holds His children responsible for working out their own temporal salvation. God has given His children His will to observe to work out their own salvation.

All the acts of His children contributes NOTHING, ZILCH to the eternal salvation that Triune God has purposed, accomplished, applied personally, and will consummate.

Living soberly, godly and righteously save God's children from temporal consequences of their sins in this life, save them from this perverse and crooked generation.

Wyatt
Double salvation? Sounds awefully Wesleyan. And like John Wesley was then you are now, Sing, wrong. Might I suiggest you study hebrews 11 to better understand faith as a result of grace not as the producer of it. Might I also suggest a book my an very godly man named Dr. Louis Hill called "Faith Is...". I know it is available on Amazon. But worth the read and might help you in this issue even if you don't think you need the help.

Sing F Lau
Wyatt@Double salvation? Sounds awefully Wesleyan.
=====
Is the life that your parents gave you by their action, and the life you are busily making for your self the one and the same life, or are they distinct lives - the one that is undying, and the other temporary, the former of which you have nothing to do, and the latter which you are actively engaged; the one in which you can't alter anything, and the other which is to a very large extent is determined by your response to good parenting?

Get the point? Away with anything Wesleyan please!

Wiebe
unless someone else wants to step in, Sing you have been given plenty of time and space to make your case, but it seems that no one is buying it. you do not answer questions when asked but continue to type out data. just let it go.

Sing F Lau
Yes, brother, I will muzzle up. Thanks for the reminder. It is not about selling anyone anything.
It is discussing how best the Scriptures is understood.

Which question did I overlook? Post it on my wall, and I will take it up if I have any thought on the questions.

Thanks again.

Saturday, May 22, 2010

Were you a lost sheep or a goat?

A sheep... lost and all alone. Not found and gathered to the flock!

Sing F Lau
SHEEP & GOATS - There is this common and popular notion among so many Christians... that they were GOATS... and it was through the gospel ministry they were turned into SHEEP. I do wonder whether these sincere folks ever read the Bible? And when they do read, do they understand what they read, and believe what the Scriptures stated in such simple and plain term!

Sides
I was once lost now I'm found.

Sing F Lau
I wrote this note in another place on FB:
========
All the elect are SHEEP... ALWAYS SHEEP... but they were lost sheep by nature. Lost sheep were NO goats!

The LOST sheep were lost in that they are cut off from God because of their sins. Jesus came to seek and save them... by His life of perfect righteousness (for justification unto life) and sacrificial death (for the remission of sins).

Jesus' life and work DID FIND and SAVE all the sheep... each and every one of them were reconciled to God - OBJECTIVELY and LEGALLY - it is FINISHED!

This OBJECTIVE and LEGAL work [of eternal salvation] is applied to each individual sheep at God's approved and appointed time... in the effectual call... when each elect is called out of his state of sin an death, in which he is by nature, to that state of grace and salvation.

Those that have been called out of their state of sin and death into the state of grace and salvation are able to respond to the gospel call... evidencing the work of God's free grace in them.

Of course very many preachers think their ministry helps to turn goats into sheep! They think and act just like the popish priests who believe by their superstitious hocus-pocus could actually turn wafer and wine into the real body and blood of Jesus Christ!
What darkness!

"I am the good shepherd: the good shepherd giveth his life for the sheep." Jesus gave himself for the sheep. He did not give himself for to goats , in order to turn them into sheep! That's a devil's lie.

'My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me... My Father, which gave them me, is greater than all; and no man is able to pluck them out of my Father’s hand.'

What the Father gave to Christ are SHEEP, not goats! But those sheep were lost... separated from the Father because of sin...

Do people ever read, and believe what the Scriptures say so plainly??? Then why do they believe such weird notions and lies?
==========

The only biblical explanation:

3 For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they heap to themselves teachers, having itching ears;
4 And they shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be turned unto fables.

Fables are FICTIONS...

And the solution prescribed to combat this great evil?

I charge thee therefore before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall judge the quick and the dead at his appearing and his kingdom;
2 Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine.

Too many are just preaching lies! And how many despise sound bible doctrines!

God give them over to DELUSION such that they can't differentiate a lost sheep from a goat!


Now, this is a goat. A goat always remains a goat, even if it become a 3-legged goat!

Hodges
Matthew 25:33
And he shall set the sheep on his right hand, but the goats on the left.

Hart
Brother Sing, I do NOT think your belief is private interpretation.
Your explanations cannot be understood by lost sheep due to priestcraft deceptions.

Brother Sing, do you think Paul's epistle to the Roman Christians was about charitable giving > Romans 8:28 ?
There's a loved one who ignores verses 29 and 30 and says "dad" has a "personal feeling" and "view". Self justification is the way of lost sheep!

Hart
I have NOT observed priestcraft deceptions in any writings of Brother Sing or Daniel Hodges.
I'm troubled by my family trusting Arminian preachers and modern versions.

Hodges
Dear ones, remember that any of these modern or revised versions are really just reversed visions.

Hart
Agree!

Sides
Sing no one within the reformed camp believes they are out proclaiming the Gospel in order that God may elect them.Out of curiosity what are thoughts in regards to the preaching of George Whitefield.

Sing F Lau
Jason, if you have not come across EVERY so called reformed camp, and they are VERY diverse and many, it is logically and rationally IMPROPER to claim that 'no one within the reformed camp believes blah blah blah..." It would be more correct to say, "Of all those I have come across in the reformed camp, NO ONE... blah blah blah... " would sound more reasonable.

Also the issue is not about election... the issue is about the role of the gospel ministry in transforming GOATS into SHEEP.

Lost, and then found is so simple and plain.
Goats, then become sheep? Superstition and delusion of the worst kind!

Lost sheep were never goats. Period. The father of lies tell God's children otherwise.

Sides
Sing if the issue were not about election why then would you even mention it your feedback in response to your post seems to prove otherwise. I will hold you to the same standard since you do believe I'm wrong why not provide at least one person in any reformed camp who believes as you suggest they do? Secondly I asked about Whitefield and in other post if you ever evangelize and you seem to ignore the issue.

Sides
Richard if I may ask do you hold to what Spurgeon and Baxter taught?

Sing F Lau
Yes, I did mention about election... i.e. that the elect are referred to as sheep, even before they gospel ministry was ever brought to them. They were lost sheep, and not dead goats! That is very different from the issue you raised, I.E. election is conditioned on the proclamation of the gospel - why introduce this alien red herring into the discussion!

I will also state that I have not heard anyone from the reformed camp that believe that election is conditioned upon the gospel ministry. But I have not heard from EVERY reformed camp. I have most certainly heard some people from both the reformed AND deformed camps that insist that the gospel ministry is the instrument to turn goats into sheep! So, I won't declare like you did, "NO ONE from the reformed camp blah blah blah..."

Jason, what did I say that makes you assume that I am suggesting anything about the reformed camp?

What about the preaching of George Whitefield? Is it whether his preaching did turn goats into sheep? If that's the point, then I declare that he was most certainly deceived.

And what specifically that Spurgeon and Baxter taught that you have in mind? Be a little more specific... will help in the discussion.

Wells
Sing - Though you speak very confidently about your position, I must say that I am not so confident in your opinion. As far as I have read and studied, those who will be damned are only referred to as goats one time is scripture. One can hardly build their case on a single verse. Am I wrong on this, please enlightened me.

"Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new."
~ II Cor 5:17 So then, if one were already a sheep and he becomes a new creature, what is he?

Also, if unregenerate are already sheep, it should be very easy to spot them... after all there are visible differences between sheep and goats. There of course would be no reason to pray or preach to them for they would be found when Christ is ready. With this logic, there would be no need for evangelism. Of course if one did speak God's word, the sheep would hear, because they know the shepherd's voice... but wait... they are not yet regenerate and dead men can't hear the Gospel... so that cancels out the scripture that says my sheep hear my voice.

Hmmm... sounds awful shaky to me Sing.

Sheep that are sought and saved, and added to the flock

Sing F Lau
Wells@ "Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new." II Cor 5:17

So then, if one were already a sheep and he becomes a new creature, what is he?
=========
It matters very little to me whether you - for that matter, any man, great or small - are confident in anything I say. What matters to me is that I rightly divide the truth so that I not be ashamed, when shown in error by smart Brother like you! "Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth."

I have been shown to be wrong many times before, and taught the truth. You would do me a great favor by showing me the truth. You have not.

A LOST sheep is an elect in his natural state, in the state of sin and death... a creature in his natural and old state, therefore an OLD creature. He is NOT a goat, nor a lost goat.

A lost sheep that is found PERSONALLY (as opposed to found LEGALLY in the finished work of Christ) when the redemption is applied to him in effectual calling out of the state of sin and death to that of grace and salvation, is turned a NEW creature by the grace of God.

Isn't that a very simple answer to your rhetorical (but very misguided) question?

The UN-regenerate elect ARE sheep, but they ARE LOST - LOST - LOST sheep... in their natural state of sin and death. So, it is impossible to spot them... because the lost sheep "were by nature the children of wrath, even as other." They (UN-regenerate ELECT) are exactly like the goats in their spiritual state.

Did you notice, "EVEN AS OTHERS"?

Sing F Lau
Wells@ "Also, if unregenerate are already sheep, it should be very easy to spot them... after all there are visable differences between sheep and goats."

If you are thinking of LITERAL sheep and goats, then you are right! But if you are on that, then you and I are not communicating.

NO, NO, NO, there are NO difference between the LOST sheep (elect who are not regenerated) and goats (the rest of mankind).

There are visible and radical difference between found sheep (made new creatures through effectual by God's free grace) and goats.

Sing F Lau
Wells@ "There of course would be no reason to pray or preach to them for they would be found when Christ is ready. With this logic, there would be no need for evangelism. Of course if one did speak God's word, the sheep would hear, because they know the shepherd's voice... but wait... they are not yet regenerate and dead men can't hear the Gospel so that cancel's out the scripture that says my sheep hear my voice."

This reveals a whole loads of confusion and delusions.

First, only those sheep that are found, i.e the elect that are regenerated will ever hear and receive the preached gospel as God's power of saving them. All the others, i.e. LOST sheep, still in their state of sin and death, will not hear the gospel... the most eloquent and persuasive preaching of the gospel will come across as foolishness to them.

Second, 'my sheep hear my voice'. You are confusing the LIFE-GIVING voice of Christ in calling out those sheep dead in trespasses and sins to grace and salvation. Christ's sheep alone, those given to Christ in their lost condition - shall be summoned to life... i.e. they alone shall hear the life-giving voice of Christ. NONE others will, because the life-giving voice of Jesus Christ will not be spoken to them.

Please don't confuse the life giving voice of Christ in regeneration, and the preachers' voice as the instrument in CONVERTING God's children. Christ DOES NOT speak through preachers in quickening dead sinners.

Prayers and preaching are very important for their divinely ordained purpose... BUT most certainly not for the purpose conjured up by confused and deluded men! I don't want to repeat the same things over again. Let the wilfully ignorant be ignorant still, said the Apostle Paul.

Sides
Sing I trust you have read of Whitfields sermons so I am not being specific about a particular thought but rather what he taught in the open air as a whole.Your snide gestures against a person rather than the position held seems to put so many on the defensive.Have you written any articles on how to evangeize not just how not to if so and it is biblical would you kindly share it as it could prove to be a great benefit as we are called to redeem the time not waste it on what could be silly attempts of proclaiming the Good news.

Hart
"The Bible does not teach that belief in Christ is what saved us from hell: but rather, belief tells that we ARE saved from hell. Paul tells us that the gospel brings eternal life to light. It reveals what is already there, and it enlightens us to believe all the more." - David M.

Hart
Jason, I do NOT hold to the teachings of any man.
I am especially concerned that so many well-meaning believers align themselves with ministries named after men.

Jude 3,4 "Beloved, when I gave all diligence to write unto you of the common salvation, it was needful for me to write unto you, and exhort you that ye should earnestly contend for the faith which was once delivered unto the saints.
For the there are certain men crept in unawares, who were before of old ordained to this condemnation, ungodly men, turning the grace of our God into lascisviousness, and denying the only Lord God, and our Lord Jesus Christ.

I do believe in God's preservation of the saints. - FREE Grace
I do NOT believe in perseverance of the saints. -Works or self-justification.
Intrinsic faith is God's free gift.
Gospel faith is man's exercise of the gift, gospel obedience.
The Law only informs us of sins, but cannot eternally save us.
I believe in eternal salvation and time salvations contingent upon obeying and honoring our LORD.

Sing F Lau
Brother Jason, I have read lots of Whitefield's sermons, and his massive biography by Arnold Dallimore - that was in the early 80s.

The issue at hand is not to preach or not to preach. Preaching is ordained and commanded by Christ. So, it much be obeyed.

The issue is, what is the function and purpose for which the preaching ministry is ordained.

So much have been written on HOW to evangelize...

If you want to read some thoughts on WHY evangelize, read some thoughts in "Pruning Seven Deformed Branches" book, posted here: http://pruning-deformed-branches.blogspot.com/

Sing F Lau
Richard @ "I am especially concerned that so many well-meaning believers align themselves with ministries named after men."

This is the nauseating thing I see... so many 'friends' on Facebook quoting MEN, o yes, famous men, men with great names, puritans, reformers, ec., etc. ... and so many 'liking' the quotes even though there is much errors in the quote.

Few people quoting Scriptures, and promoting to study the Scriptures.

The days Apostle Paul warned have come...
3 For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they heap to themselves teachers, having itching ears;
4 And they shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be turned unto fables.
5 But watch thou in all things, endure afflictions, do the work of an evangelist, make full proof of thy ministry.

Sing F Lau
Wells@ "As far as I have read and studied, those who will be damned are only referred to as goats one time is scripture."
=======

But you choose to ignore the MANY occasions that the elect are called sheep, and they are lost sheep, and Jesus was sent to seek them and to save them, and not any others.

It is sufficient that the Scriptures give mention of the goats once. Any more than that would be more than is necessary, and a waste of precious space! The focus of the Scriptures is upon the sheep, those whom God gave to Christ, and for whom Christ came to seek and save; instead of the goats.

The damned are referred as goats... that plain and simple. There is no for repetition.

Those that God glorified are the ELECT, and the ELECT alone.

Romans 8:
29 ¶ For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren.
30 Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.

AS MANY AS - not one more, and not one less!

John 17:
2 As thou hast given him power over all flesh, that he should give eternal life to as many as thou hast given him.
3 And this is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.

Sing F Lau
Don't waste time with goats.
Christ is a SHEPherd... He ain't no GOATherd at all.
Only goatherd hirelings want to win goats!

Take a look here: http://things-new-and-old.blogspot.com/2008/02/feeding-sheep-or-entertaining-goats.html