Things New and Old

Ancient truths revealed in the Scriptures are often forgotten, disbelieved or distorted, and therefore lost in the passage of time. Such ancient truths when rediscovered and relearned are 'new' additions to the treasury of ancient truths.

Christ showed many new things to the disciples, things prophesied by the prophets of old but hijacked and perverted by the elders and their traditions, but which Christ reclaimed and returned to His people.

Many things taught by the Apostles of Christ have been perverted or substituted over the centuries. Such fundamental doctrines like salvation by grace and justification have been hijacked and perverted and repudiated by sincere Christians. These doctrines need to be reclaimed and restored to God's people.

There are things both new and old here. "Consider what I say; and the Lord give thee understanding in all things"
2Ti 2:7.

Thursday, June 22, 2023

The Gospel of Free Grace vs a Calvinistic Gospel

June 22, 2012
https://www.facebook.com/photo?fbid=3408799734244&set=a.1182086067794

The gospel of free grace declares Eternal Salvation, WITHOUT any human activity.

Romans 8
29 ¶ For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren.
30 Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.

These two verses of the Holy Scriptures are probably the most tortured and abused passages of the Bible. Even the Calvinistic folks messed it up big time!

A few obvious facts about the passage:

1. The object acted upon by the divine activities are co-extensive throughout, an EXACTLY SAME number and people are involved in each activity of God, not one more and not one less, that is, every action applies to EVERY elect, withOUT exception. That's pretty obvious... "whom he did... he also... whom he did... he also..." 

2. The divine activities here - foreknowledge, predestination, calling, justification and glorification - are all the activities of God. All these activities are by the free and sovereign grace of God, i.e. not conditioned upon anything in, by or of the objects. Those acted upon in these divine activities are completely passive, absolutely incapable of helping or even cooperating. In fact, they, by nature, were actively in ENMITY and REBELLION against God.

3. Those acted upon in these divine activities are EQUALLY ACTED upon - they are ALL EQUALLY foreknown, predestinated, called, justified, and glorified - no one more, and no one less. Every free grace divine action applies to ABSOLUTELY EVERY ELECT, to absolutely equal and same extent. No exception. The activities here deal with and secure ETERNAL salvation for the elect.

4. The divine activities stated here are all that is necessary for the ETERNAL salvation of every elect, without exception. There is no room to place other activities into the five-link chain. The five-link chain is complete and DOES NOT NEED other activities of God; it DOES NOT PERMIT any activities of man.

Why is there no mention of regeneration, adoption, sanctification, etc., etc.?

Why isn't there any mention of the gospel preaching, faith and repentance?
Why? Do you know? If you don't, why not ask?

5. This passage says ABSOLUTELY NOTHING, ZILCH about all those needful activities that involve human instrumentality (means) and activities that are needful for the TEMPORAL salvation of God's children already made fit for eternal glory. If you imagine that any such activities are necessary for eternal salvation, then you have prostituted the pure gospel of grace, deny true monergism, and end up with a synergistic view of salvation - which is so common even among many Calvinists!

When this passage is properly understood, then eternal salvation by God's free grace is adequately appreciated.

I know you may have some objections. I'm ready for them. If you can stick to the subject, comment. If not, don't!
=========

50 comments

Sing F Lau
There is the ETERNAL salvation which God in Jesus Christ has completely and perfectly worked out for His people, and applies to each elect by His Spirit, perfectly fitting each for eternal glory... no human instrumentality is involved the eternal salvation. God alone purposed it, Christ alone accomplished it, and the Spirit alone applies it.

- This is the true context/sphere of 'divine sovereignty' in salvation.

There is the TEMPORAL salvation which God's children (those already bestowed with eternal salvation by God's free grace) have to work out for themselves with fear and trembling for their well-being and usefulness in this present life.

The gospel ministry, administered through human instrumentality, is the divinely ordained means for this specific purpose of saints working out their own salvation:

"12 teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world; 13 Looking for that blessed hope, and the glorious appearing of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ;

14 Who gave himself for us, that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works." Titus 2.

- This is the true context/sphere of 'human responsibility' in salvation. God's children are responsible to work out their own salvation through obedience to the Father's will.

The measure to which men cannot distinguish eternal salvation from temporal salvation is the same measure to which they are messed up in their understanding of salvation by grace alone! They give lip service to salvation by grace alone but in reality, are all work-based salvation to different degrees... EVEN the Calvinists!

Sing F Lau
1. The object acted upon by the divine activities are co-extensive throughout, an EXACTLY SAME number and SAME people are involved in each activity of God, not one more and not one less, that is, every action applies to EVERY elect, with an exception.
================

Necessary implications:

1. The call is the effectual call because ONLY IN EFFECTUAL CALL is every elect called. This is God calling an elect out of his native state of sin and death to that of grace and eternal salvation.

There is absolutely no gospel call here because there are God's children (regenerated elect) that are incapable of being called by the gospel, either because of inability or not being reached by the gospel call.

Gospel call has to do with the temporal salvation of God's children. And there are God's children who are not called by the gospel.

However, because the Calvinists are ignorant of the distinction between ETERNAL salvation and TEMPORAL salvation, they insist that the gospel call is necessary for one's eternal salvation!

2. The justification here is the vital justification by God's free grace because this aspect of justification is true of every elect. This is God's act of justifying the condemned by applying the righteousness of Christ to him personally and forgiving him of his sins... when he is utterly incapable of believing.

There is no justification by man's act of believing here because there are God's children who are INCAPABLE of believing... either because of their inability or not called by the gospel.

However, because the Calvinists are ignorant of the distinct aspects of justification, they confuse the VITAL justification by the free grace of God as the EXPERIENTIAL justification by faith in Christ.

Sing F Lau
Romans 8:29 ¶ For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren. 30 Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.
===============

Question: why is nothing said about regeneration, sanctification, gospel preaching, hearing, faith and repentance, etc, etc... the MANY things that the Calvinists and Arminians alike insist must be added to the five-link chain?

Nick Migliacci
Here's what I came up with on this passage.
http://www.migliacci.com/articles/Rom.8.29-30.swf

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
Sing F Lau Question: why is nothing said about regeneration, sanctification, gospel preaching, hearing, faith and repentance, etc, etc... the MANY things that the Calvinists and Arminians alike insist must be added to the five-link chain? All are included but still accomplished by God. Regeneration makes it possible for the rest to happen, but still, we are fitted and framed together. The term "we must do these things" does not exist when it comes to eternal salvation, but temporal salvation is something I've never heard of except in the Arminian camp where Hebrews 6:4-6 clearly puts a reinstatement of temporal salvation to be non-existent meaning that if you lose it it is impossible to get it back if your temporal salvation refers to being able to lose one's salvation.

I also wasn't aware that the Arminian had a five-link chain. explain?

Sing F Lau
Dellis Layne Worsham Sr., temporal salvation is the salvation that those whom God has freely bestowed eternal salvation have to work out for themselves with fear and trembling through their obedience to the Father's will.

Temporal salvation has to do with the well-being of God's children while here on earth. Eternal salvation has to do with our being as God's children and our fitness and place in heaven with God.

Here is an example of temporal salvation that God's children must labour for themselves...

1Ti 4:16 Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee.

The salvation spoken of here has nothing to do with the eternal salvation that Christ ALONE has secured, and freely applied to each elect, perfectly fitting them for eternal glory.

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
Sing F Lau Like John 8:12 Then spake Jesus again unto them, saying, I am the light of the world: he that followeth me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the light of life.

Sing F Lau
Yes, he that follows Christ does so because ETERNAL SALVATION has been freely and sovereignly bestowed upon him... and following Christ will save him from darkness... following Christ a child of God shall have the light of life... his following Christ will secure him temporal salvation... ensures his well being as God's child!

Any salvation that requires the activities of man has to do with TEMPORAL SALVATION.

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
But I'm not supposed to believe that am I? I am a Calvinist 🙂

Nick Migliacci
I don’t think we can ever presume upon God and state that we have perfect knowledge about our salvation such that we know infallibly that we have been given this “eternal salvation,” as Sing calls it. Paul was humble enough to recognize that if he didn’t persevere, he would prove himself to be “disqualified,” which means lost. (The same word he uses in 1 Cor. 9:27 he uses in 2 Cor. 13:5). And again in Romans 11:21, he puts the fear of God in us lest we become so “sure of ourselves.” “He who endures to the end shall be saved.” That’s the salvation that takes you to heaven. What does Sing base his knowledge on that he has been given “eternal salvation?” That he prayed the sinner’s prayer? Surely not!

Therefore, there is no distinction between a so-called “eternal salvation” and a “temporal salvation.” The salvation we are commanded to “work out with fear and trembling” is the same salvation that will get us to heaven (if we do indeed work it out). Sanctification is part and parcel of being saved. No holiness, no heaven (Heb. 12:14). Sanctification is a prerequisite to going to heaven. If a person does not “keep themselves in the love of God” (Jude 1:21), then they would prove that God never gave them salvation—call it eternal or temporal if you want; there’s only one salvation.

I’m a Calvinist and I approve this message. 🙂

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
Nick@ I know where you are coming from but Sing F Lau does make sense, though what he teaches is true, the wording is different. EG. it is not our relationship that makes us Christians, it is our fellowship. However, Sing used the words sonship and discipleship in the same respect. Sanctification has more to do with God working in you, both to will and to do of His good pleasure. Chastening is the way God gets us to the point of sanctification while here on earth, but if you are regenerate then God has already eternally sanctified you. BTW, Calvinists believe OSAS.

Hebrews 2:11
For both he that sanctifieth and they who are sanctified are all of one: for which cause he is not ashamed to call them brethren,

Hebrews 10:10
By the which will we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.

Hebrews 10:14
For by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified.

The above scripture pertains to God's eternal purpose for us. 1 Corinthians 6:11
And such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. Paul never worried about the destiny of his soul, but he was concerned that his lifestyle in which others in the world saw him was a concern eg. He didn't want to appear to be a hypocrite by living a life that didn't reflect the hope within him. It was for that, that he said to work out with fear and trembling. He for sure knew that God had set him apart (sanctified) for the purpose of being an apostle to the Gentiles.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci, you are indeed a Calvinist, a typical synergist in the doctrine of salvation.

You forgot what Paul said here:
38 For I am persuaded, that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor powers, nor things present, nor things to come,
39 Nor height, nor depth, nor any other creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.

That's eternal salvation secure for His people... nothing can undo it... not even Satan himself.

Paul is realistic about the real possibility of himself making a shipwreck of his faith... that's concerning his temporal salvation, his well-being as God's child.

Nick Migliacci
Yes, I believe the Gospel is “foolishness” to the unbeliever (1 Cor. 1:18; 2:14) and the “aroma of death” to him (2 Cor. 2:16). But that presuppose that he has heard it, does it not? He hears it, it’s foolish to him, and then at the appointed time, God regenerates him (if he’s elected) and it is no longer foolishness to him.

I can see where our views part ways. It’s this idea of “temporal salvation” versus “eternal salvation.” You mentioned Romans 8:38-39 and how absolutely nothing is able to separate us [you understand that to be those who have been granted eternal salvation] from the love of God. But I would point out that that promise is true only for those who are “in Christ.” So what I stated earlier was that none of us knows infallibly that we are in Christ, until we are on our deathbed and can say like Paul that we have fought the good fight. But as long as we’ve got lots of years ahead of us, there is still that possibility that we might make a shipwreck of our faith, and prove that God never did, after all, grant us [eternal] salvation. We deceived ourselves into thinking that He did. We would be like that soil which at first received the Word with gladness but later fell away because of tough times. It’s true that IF God grants [eternal] salvation, it can never be taken away. That is a blessed promise that we can cling to if we can see evidence of sanctification in our life. But it’s equally true that there are many religious people who have deceived themselves in thinking they have that [eternal] salvation when in reality they were lost along (Mt. 7:23). They don’t lose any salvation; they simply never had one.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci, then I conclude that your eternal salvation finally depends on your perseverance to the end! I hope you make it. See, somehow human works must always sneak in to play a role in a man's eternal salvation!

I'm sorry you don't think Christ's work has made eternal salvation certain and assured enough for you, that you need to add a CONDITION to eternal salvation. I just hope you meet it!

Nick Migliacci
Christ's work does guarantee me heaven, IF it was for me He died! How do I know that? By looking at God's work of sanctifying me, because God sanctifies all whom He saves. So far, I have every reason to believe I will make it. I press on toward the goal.... I am what I am by the grace of God.

What proof do you have that you have eternal salvation? Because you prayed a sinner's prayer?

Nick Migliacci
(I'm glad we're able to finally see where our theologies differ.) I'm sure you are too. 🙂

Sing F Lau
Yes, finally.
Yours is grace PLUS conditions...
Mine is grace ALONE.

Yours: no hope for such as Lot, Saul, Solomon... since they did not persevere to the end, they were never saved by God.

Mine: they are as eternally saved as every elect, even though they messed up big time their well-being on earth.

See the difference. I hope you meet the conditions you have set for yourself.

Nick Migliacci
But how can you prove that Lot, Saul, Solomon, or anyone else has been "eternally saved", if not by their life (or what the Scriptures say about them, such as putting them in Hebrews 11, etc.)?

Also, the way people were saved before the Incarnation is the same way people are saved today: believing in Christ. Those in the Old Testament looked forward to Christ, today, we look back. Granted, we have more revelation than they did, but still, everyone is saved by looking to Christ. Genesis 3:15 is the "proto-good news". Galatians 3:8 - "And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, PREACHED THE GOSPEL TO ABRAHAM beforehand, saying, 'In you all the nations shall be blessed.'" So anybody who didn't believe in Christ went to hell.

You still haven't answered whether it's possible for a regenerate person to go to hell, in plain, simple language: yes or no. I have been clear with you, why won't you extend the same courtesy? Don't expect your Scriptures to have the same impact on me as they do you, because I don't come with the same presuppositions as you do. So just answer yes or no: Can a regenerate person remain an atheist all their life and go to hell?

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
Can a regenerate person remain an atheist all their life and go to hell? That's a kind of crazy question since being regenerated automatically makes you a spiritual being and makes you cease to be a natural man.

I have no presuppositions since all I know is from what God's word has taught me, well with the help of the comforter God gave me. If you think about it, those who spoke to God in the OT still had faith though they heard the audible voice of God, saw angels and prophesied according to visions. In the New Testament times, faith is in things not seen. So how is it that we are saved by the same faith as our father Abraham? As far as us hearing the gospel, think of it as one man hearing without understanding and the other hearing with it. Jesus said, "all that the Father giveth me shall come to me" so that makes your question about a regenerate atheist impossible. That should pretty much sum up the rest of the questions you posed. I feel I have been clear enough for a seemingly intelligent man like yourself to understand. If not, I ask, Are you a brother in Christ?

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ Also, the way people were saved before the Incarnation is the same way people are saved today: believing on Christ.

You are COMPLETELY WRONG on one point: Yes, the way people were SAVED by God is the same way people are saved today... there is only one way of salvation... and it is not by believing in Jesus Christ.

You most certainly believe in salvation by works... because believing in Jesus Christ is a work that God expects His children to work.

Here is the proof: John 6
28 ¶ Then said they unto him, What shall we do, that we might work the works of God? 29 Jesus answered and said unto them, This is the work of God, that ye believe on him whom he hath sent.

IT IS by God effectually calling them out of their native state of sin and death to that of grace and salvation based on the righteousness of Jesus Christ.

Believing is an EVIDENCE that a man has been SAVED by God, by His free grace. Believing DOES NOT SAVE anyone. Believing evidences the ETERNAL SALVATION already freely bestowed. ONLY the SAVED by God can ever believe.

If eternal salvation is by believing in Jesus Christ, then MANY elect will go to the lake of fire, since many are either INCAPABLE of believing, or have no opportunity to believe because the gospel call to believe did not get to them.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ "You still haven't answered whether it's possible for a regenerate person to go to hell, in plain, simple language: yes or no."

I will answer your WEIRD Q with a question: Can a child of God go to the lake of fire? Am I asking the same thing? If I am, then the answer is NO NO NO. Regeneration guarantees ETERNAL GLORY - without anything extra or condition on man's part. That's grace, pure unadulterated and uncontaminated grace.

But let me entertain your question: Is it possible for a regenerate person to go to hell, in plain, simple language: yes or no.

Jesus warns his disciples (apostles):
28 But I say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart.
29 And if thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
30 And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.

Is the warning of the Lord to the APOSTLES a vain warning? Isn't the warning that it is a REAL danger to the disciples...

And Nick, are hell and the late of fire the same in your understanding?

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ Therefore, there is no distinction between a so-called “eternal salvation” and a “temporal salvation.” The salvation we are commanded to “work out with fear and trembling” is the same salvation that will get us to heaven (if we do indeed work it out).
============

In this, you are most deluded and confused. You have MIXED eternal salvation by Christ's work. You have just DENIED the completeness and the perfection of Christ's work. You require Christ's work to be completed by yours! And you still blah blah blah salvation by grace ALONE. No, you should be honest and say, 'salvation is by grace PLUS my work.'

Christ's work ALONE secured your eternal salvation. It is based upon the finished work of Christ that God bestowed salvation to a dead condemned sinner.

Your work of obeying God will save you from 'hell' on earth, and bring you temporal blessings - blessings that pertain to/in this life.

Nick Migliacci
I still do not know what you believe. I'm getting closer, but it's like pulling teeth out of you. Why beat around the bush? Are you saying a regenerate person can remain an atheist all their life and still go to heaven? Do you believe that God will ENSURE that the regenerate all believe the Gospel at some point?

Nick Migliacci
Are you separating regeneration from sanctification, saying that it's possible to be regenerated but not sanctified?

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ Can a regenerate person remain an atheist all their life and go to hell?
=======
Have you read this:
Heb 8:10 For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, saith the Lord; I will put my laws into their mind, and write them in their hearts: and I will be to them a God, and they shall be to me a people.

Every regenerate elect KNOWS and WORSHIP God... even though he has never heard of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Look at Cornelius, the Ethiopian eunuch, Lydia... all those devout Jews CONVERTED on the day of Pentecost.

The gospel informs and instructs him about his eternal salvation by God's free and sovereign grace in Jesus Christ.

Hearing and believing the gospel SAVES and sets them free from superstition and lies and errors... teaches them to live soberly, godly and righteously... thus saving themselves from ungodliness and worldly lusts in THIS PRESENT LIFE. That's temporal salvation - i.e. salvation that pertains to THIS PRESENT LIFE.

ETERNAL SALVATION by Christ's work of redemption has ETERNITY in view... saves from eternal condemnation, even from the Lake of fire.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci, just remember this:
Rightly dividing the word of truth is the ESSENCE of sound theology.
The biblical distinction between ETERNAL salvation by free grace alone, and TEMPORAL salvation through the obedience of God's children IS THE ESSENCE of sound theology.

Failure to make this biblical distinction will leave in a cesspool of confusion and contradictions and inconsistencies. Been there for 20 years... and it is a joy and delight to be out of it for 10 years now.

May our Lord set you free to see the glorious truth! Amen.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ I still do not know what you believe. I'm getting closer, but it's like pulling teeth out of you. Why beat around the bush? Are you saying a regenerate person can remain an atheist all their life and still go to heaven? Do you believe that God will ENSURE that the regenerate all believe the Gospel at some point?
==============

Q1 - I don't ever beat around the bush. I am a slash-and-burn type of man <LOL>. Rinse your eyes with some eye salve to see better! <LOL>

Q2 - answered already. Read it.

Q3 - answered too, but you didn't read. Shame!

PJ Walters
"And his disciples came to him, and awoke him, saying, Lord, save us: we perish." Matthew 8:25
-----------------
Is the salvation under consideration in the context of this verse eternal or temporal?

Is the perishing under consideration herein eternal or temporal?

Take heed unto the doctrine, and save thyself and them that hear thee!

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ Are you separating regeneration from sanctification, saying that it's possible to be regenerated but not sanctified?
========
Which sanctification are you talking about - definitive sanctification or practical sanctification?

At regeneration, an elect is definitively set apart from sin and death to that of grace and salvation. This sanctification is once for all, non-repeatable, needs no improvement. Once set apart from sin and death to grace and eternal salvation, FOREVER set apart to grace and salvation. This definitive sanctification is WITHOUT human means - God does it ALL by Himself.

Understand?

Heb 10:14 For by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified.

Calvinists like you have the audacity to ADD to this finished work by Christ... that without practical sanctification a man goes to hell! How much practical sanctification is needed to qualify for eternal glory - can you tell us? And just how does a man know he meets the requirement?

I know what's in your mind - it is practical sanctification that you are concerned with.

Practical sanctification is accomplished through the means of the gospel ministry in the context of the NT local church. Some children of God enjoy this means to a greater degree, others less, and still others NONE. Whatever amount they enjoy, they are all God's children, definitively sanctified, destined for eternal glory!!!

PJ Walters
What of the brother's question concerning an atheist?

Sing F Lau
Pj Walters, here it is, at the end of the paragraph.
======
"You still haven't answered whether it's possible for a regenerate person to go to hell, in plain, simple language: yes or no. I have been clear with you, why won't you extend the same courtesy? Don't expect your Scriptures to have the same impact on me as they do you, because I don't come with the same presuppositions as you do. So just answer yes or no: Can a regenerate person remain an atheist all their life and go to hell?"
----------------
I wonder what provoked him to ask such a WEIRD question?

Maybe Nick Migliacci might like to tell us!

PJ Walters
I'm still studying about hell and the separate state of the soul, so perhaps he may be able to tell us more!

Sing F Lau
No, Nick is far from that issue... 'hell' is just 'hell' to him - the eternal state.

Nick Migliacci
Sing, why do you call my question weird? You yourself said some regenerate people are never (temporarily) sanctified. Thus, they can be a (temporal) atheist, and still be regenerate and go to heaven. By making this man-made disconnection between regeneration and necessary (temporal) sanctification, you have people going to heaven who lived like the devil. Do I understand your view right? I certainly don't want to misrepresent you.

Nick Migliacci
My view, as you probably already know, is that God not only ensures the regeneration of His elect, but He also ensures their sanctification (which you call "temporal sanctification"). And in that way, He ensures they will go to heaven, because no holiness, no heaven. How can a sinner be holy? Only by the working of God in his life.

You may say I believe in a works-based salvation, but that is not accurate; I believe in a salvation based on God's work, and one of His works is His sanctifying work. Yes, I believe sanctification is synergistic (although my work depends on the monergistic initiative of God), but what makes this so different from the Arminian is this: I believe regeneration is wholly monergistic, whereas the Arminian believes in prevenient grace, making the dead man able to choose God. I do not believe dead men can choose God. But once a person has been given life, by all means, they are then made able to cooperate with the Spirit in sanctification. There is a difference between a dead man's abilities and a living person's abilities.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci, I call your question weird because it is like asking, "Do God's children end up in the lake of fire?"

It is like asking, "Do my children have immortal souls? Do they need to live well in order to have immortal souls?"

Do God's children need to meet some condition in order to get into heaven?
Do you ever ask a question like that?

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ You yourself said some regenerate people are never (temporarily) sanctified. Thus, they can be a (temporal) atheist, and still be regenerate and go to heaven. By making this man-made disconnection between regeneration and necessary (temporal) sanctification, you have people going to heaven who lived like the devil.
=========

In discussion, you must guard yourself against putting your words into my mouth.

The idea that a regenerate, a child of God, can be an atheist is entirely your straw man... and you SHOULD BE ASHAMED of yourself for saying that though I have burned your straw man many times over.

A child of God believes God and fears and reverence Him, even though he may not have any knowledge of the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ yet. But you will call a man who has not heard of the gospel an atheist. Was Cornelius an atheist before Apostle brought to gospel to him?

A regenerate has eternal life and is perfectly fitted for eternal glory... nothing more is needed.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ "By making this man-made disconnection between regeneration and necessary (temporal) sanctification, you have people going to heaven who lived like the devil."
===========
"You have people going to heaven who lived like hell' is another cheap straw man - that's your imagination. I didn't say anything like that.

Because you CANNOT accept the idea that there are God's children who do not hear the gospel, you conclude that there are God's children who live like the devil and go to heaven - that's too puerile to even requires a rebuttal! The straw man does not warrant wasting a stick of precious matches.

It is a biblical fact that there are God's children who have no ABILITY to hear and believe the gospel, and also those who have no OPPORTUNITY to hear and believe the gospel.

The Scripture itself makes the NEEDFUL distinction, but you want to join them together and end up with all sorts of contradiction - i.e. salvation by grace PLUS works.

You join the CAUSE and the effects together.

A man like you rave and rant and foam the whole day long that 'salvation is by grace alone' from one side of your mouth, and then screams from the other side that "salvation by grace is complemented/completed by works."

Nick Migliacci
I've created a Forum where you can clearly explain your position, here:
http://www.migliacci.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=109

What Saith The Scriptures: View Forum - "Eternal Salvation" & "Temporal Salvation"
MIGLIACCI.COM

Sing F Lau
There are many useful articles on the subject. Go and read them and understand them before you start discussing them.

In a nutshell:
The saving activities of God secured ETERNAL salvation for His people.

The responding activities of God's children (having been bestowed eternal salvation by God's free grace) secured temporal salvation for this temporal life on earth.

It is that simple and easy.

Heard this saying before? Think about it.

"The most difficult subjects can be explained to the most slow-witted man if he has not formed any idea of them already; but the simplest thing cannot be made clear to the most intelligent man if he is firmly persuaded that he knows already, without a shadow of doubt, what is laid before him." - Leo Tolstoy –

Thanks for the conversation... I'm thoroughly acquainted with your position... was there for 20 years.

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
It makes sense that you can't teach anything to anyone who already knows it all.

Nick Migliacci
I like that quote by Tolstoy.

Why do you suppose God has not secured temporal salvation for all for whom He secures eternal salvation? Doesn't God care about both equally?

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci @ "Why do you suppose God has not secured temporal salvation for all for whom He secures eternal salvation? Doesn't God care about both equally?
==========
HARD Scriptural FACTS!
HARD Scriptural FACTS!
I don't suppose anything.
It is you who supposes a whole lot of things.
Nick, supposing God cared about both EQUALLY, then every elect would be equally saved with eternal salvation, and ALSO equally saved with temporal salvation. The former is true, the latter is an obvious fable!

It is true that every elect is equally saved with eternal salvation, because their salvation is BASED upon the same basis (Christ's righteousness), the same manner (God's free grace) and the same means (regeneration by the Holy Spirit). This is the sole work of the Triune God alone.

It is just a PLAIN LIE that says temporal salvation is equally true for every child of God for the simple reason that temporal salvation is CONDITIONED upon many human factors... which directly affect the degree to which temporal salvation is attained and experienced by a child of God.

If God divinely ENSURES temporal salvation to each of His children, then EVERY ONE of them will enjoy the same degree of temporal salvation, otherwise God's work of ensuring it is just a SHAM and a FICTION!

If God ENSURES temporal salvation, then everyone will know AS LITTLE or as MUCH of the gospel of free grace as you do!!! [no typing mistake!].

Nick Migliacci
You assume that, if God ensures temporal salvation, that it's God's will that everyone enjoys it to the same degree. I don't believe that. I believe it's God's will that some enjoy sanctification (temporal salvation) more than others, and others enjoy it less. Although, I don't use the word "enjoy." I would say it's God's will that some are more sanctified than others, and others are less sanctified than others.

Nick Migliacci
But one thing is sure (as far as what I believe): I believe God does ensure SOME level of sanctification to all the elect. How much sanctification is ultimately up to Him, but there WILL be a difference (2 Cor. 5:17) between the regenerate and the unregenerate.

Sing F Lau
Nick Migliacci, @ "I would say it's God's will that some are more sanctified than others, and others are less sanctified than others."
=========
Then you have to prove that such is God's will indeed, otherwise it is your fable.

But the Scriptures is PLAIN AS THE NOON DAY SUN that the level of PRACTICAL sanctification is dependent and determined by the effort of God's children.

"Work out your own salvation..."
"Feed... feed... feed..."
The definitive sanctification for each elect is as complete and perfect as ENSURED BY GOD. Even God's elect who died in infancy are as perfectly and completely sanctified definitively. Even those who have no opportunity to hear, God ensured that they are as perfectly and completely sanctified definitively.

But in terms of practical salvation, such have NONE, ZILCH. So, according to your fiction, God FAIL MISERABLY in His work of ensuring some temporal salvation in such. Or maybe in such, God ensured that they die without practical sanctification.

I would take that your idea is an evil fiction that impugns upon God's character than that God should fail in His work of ensuring a different measure of temporal salvation to His children.

If He does ensure temporal salvation at all, it would be right to believe that God ensures each child to be equally alike like men such as John Gill or Spurgeon, or Apostle Paul?

Your fiction comes toooooo pathetically far short of God's power and glory! You might as well say it is God who ensures that some have NO practical sanctification.

It is like saying a wicked father ensures that some of his children receive no food, others have little and others have a bit more.

Nick Migliacci
You said, "You might as well say it is God ensures that some have NO practical sanctification. ... It is like saying a wicked father ensures that some of his children receive no food..."

That is where we draw the line. Recall the Parable of the Four Soils. Those who produced ZERO fruit were not saved at all. God ensures that His children bear SOME fruit, some 30-fold, some 60-fold, and others (like John Gill, et. al.) 100-fold.

It's true that we, humans, do have to work out our salvation, but it's God who works in us to do and to will of His good pleasure. So at the end of the day, God is sovereign over how much fruit a person bears. To leave God out of the equation is to deny His sovereignty over man's (temporal) sanctification.

Sing F Lau
Thanks Nick Migliacci. Go your way, brother.
Let me conclude what YOU INSIST:

- God ENSURES that all His children experience temporal salvation.
- God also ENSURES that some of His children experience ZERO temporal salvation.
- The parable of the sower shows God ENSURES some of His children to be fruitless and BARREN.

Please note: the parable of the sower ADDRESSES THOSE THAT ARE IN THE KINGDOM... not how to get into the kingdom, how to be saved, and remain saved, and ensure a place in heaven.

That is your BASIC and fundamental error in understanding the parable.

So, you don't believe that God's children can be fruitless. You insist that the fruitless are not God's children, to begin with.

That's a plain contradiction of the plain teaching of the Bible:

Apostle Peter writing to "them that have obtained like precious faith with us through the righteousness of God and our Saviour Jesus Christ" warns them in these SOLEMN words: "For if these things be in you, and abound, they make you that ye shall neither be barren nor unfruitful in the knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ."

Apostle writing to ALL THOSE SAINTS in Corinth and Achaia these words, "We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain."

God's children who are careless will be fruitless. Christ said it, and His apostles warn against it solemnly... but Nick rejects it!

Thanks... keep your work-based salvation. I hope you do well enough to qualify for a place in heaven.

Dellis Layne Worsham Sr.
I found that while I was a child coming up that many times I did something wrong, something in which my dad would definitely not approve of. While in err I felt guilty and as though I wasn't at peace with Dad, if he found out what I had done from someone else, things would just be worse. Our fellowship was lost because of my guilt...I eventually couldn't take it any, or am told him what I had done and ina lot of cases he confessed to already knowing but out of love for the fellowship, he waited for me to confess. He was always faithful and just to forgive, though sometimes a punishment came even after the confession...That reminds me of temporal salvation. Eternal salvation is always on this wise. No matter what sins I commit while here, Christ, my advocate, takes the blame and paid the price and sees to it that all that is given to Him are never lost....this ensures that we will, one day, stand before God as sons of God without blame. If you want to have a closer walk with Christ, while here on earth, stay and be honest with Him because if you try to hide your sins from Jesus, you are only fooling yourself...He already knows.

King David lost a child because of his unconfessed infidelity and murder...He was punished during his temporal salvation but it affected his eternal salvation none...We workout out our own temporal salvation, God worked out the eternal one.

Sing F Lau
Good illustration. Thanks Dellis.

Saturday, June 17, 2023

"I have the keys of hell and of death."

Re 1:18 I am he that liveth, and was dead;
and, behold, I am alive for evermore, Amen;
and have the keys of hell and of death.

https://www.facebook.com/photo?fbid=10200127166917402&set=a.10200127166077381

June 17, 2013

'Eternal redemption assuredly secured a man's deliverance from the lake of fire...
But does it  necessarily deliver him from his time in hell!'

I'm only inquiring!

======

Anyone who has read the Scriptures enough will acknowledge that Jesus Himself spoke a great deal on hell, and gave very solemn warnings against ending up in hell.

A simple sample:

Mt 5:22 But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.

(There are actions that will put a man in danger of hell fire! Who is Christ addressing here? Does this apply to Christ's redeemed people?)

Mt 10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.

(There is One who can destroy both soul and body in hell! Who is Christ addressing here? Does this apply to Christ's redeemed people?)

Mt 18:9 And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.

(There are actions that will put a man in danger of hell fire! Who is Christ addressing here? Does this apply to Christ's redeemed people?)

Re 1:18 I am he that liveth, and was dead; and, behold, I am alive for evermore, Amen; and have the keys of hell and of death.

(What is the significance of Christ having the keys of hell and death?)

A simple inquiry:

a. Who was Jesus warning against hell: His redeemed people, or those whom He has bypassed?

- If the former, doesn't it imply that the danger of His redeemed people ending up in hell is a harsh reality? If it is claimed that it is impossible for His redeemed people to ever end up in hell, then what is the relevance of His solemn warnings to them?

- If the latter, is Jesus teaching that it is possible that the non-redeemed can escape hell by some actions on their part? Is Jesus teaching eternal salvation by works then?

A simple affirmation:

Kindly note: None of all that are redeemed by Christ will ever end up in the everlasting lake of fire. Christ's eternal redemption secured eternal glory for every one of the redeemed; none will end up in the lake of fire. All whose names are written in the Book of life will not end up in the lake of fire.

This is not the same as saying that none of them will end up in hell temporarily before their assured glorification at the resurrection.

Let's open the Scriptures, and learn together to rightly divide the word of truth together! Thanks. I don't need your opinions, and you don't need mine. We need the plain revelation of the Scriptures.
==========

30 comments

Dallas Eaton II
Amen. May I share this?

Sing F Lau
Everything you can see is for the whole world to see and consider!

Dallas Eaton II
thank you Brother Sing.

Adam Wells
Good questions.

Dallas Eaton II
I would agree with that Brother Julius. I would make a distinction between Hell, that is as in Death and Hell and the Lake of Fire. Death and Hell are to be cast into the Lake of Fire. What many people understand to be 'eternal Hell' is really the lake of fire where even the imagined dominion of Satan (imagined among many as his being a ruler of the condemned in Hell) is cast into for eternal torment.

[A Julius has deleted some of his comments!]

Sing F Lau
Julius, I'm just wondering if there is such a thing as eternal hell? Could you kindly demonstrate to us that it is not just your own opinion but plainly taught in the Scriptures, please. THANK YOU.

Sing F Lau
Julius, I don't have time for games... neither word nor sound games!
You said, "There is eternal hell and a hell on this earth."

I request, show such OPINIONS from the Scriptures.
Thanks.

Julius Stewart
OK I fixed it for you. I deleted all my comments since they had no scriptural viability. Good day!

Sing F Lau.
Julius, you are just shameless. 
You made some assertions, I requested you for Scriptural proof, and you throw a tantrum! You don't need to fix anything for me! Fix your fickle mindedness!

If you were sincere, you should leave those comments as they are... so that others won't repeat the same fable without biblical support!

Julius Stewart
You are right Sing. I am wrong. I can't do anything right. Please forgive me. I will no longer bother you with any of my assumptions or comments.

Sing F Lau
Who cares whether you or I am right??? If that's what you are concerned about, this is not the right place for you. We want to know what the Scriptures say. A man is free to say what he wants... we want Scriptures to back up what a man claims... otherwise it is just his opinions!!!

Sing F Lau
Now give your opinions some worth that they are based on Scriptures... "There is eternal hell and a hell on this earth."

Sing F Lau
Please tell us how have your three comments above have in any way proven that hell is eternal?

Make sure you don't work from phone and drive at the same time... a speedy way to hell! <LOL>

Julius Stewart
uncle! I delete it again. Have a nice life Sing!

Julius Stewart
No worries for me I guess because in your estimation hell is not eternal. I guess it's just temporary both in time and eternity.

Sing F Lau
Poor fickle double-minded Julius! Don't waste your time if you don't intend to help us better understand the Scriptures. There is no need for you to guess what I believe. That would be toooo busybody as well as foolish of you. I'm capable of stating plainly what I do believe. State what you believe and show us that it is from the Scriptures. Anything else is irrelevant.

Julius Stewart
So you deny the eternal sonship of Christ and the eternal hell?

Sing F Lau
If you desire to know what I believe about eternal sonship of Christ, go to the relevant articles in the blog to read it. If you want to know what I believe about hell and the lake of fire, you can linger on and behave like a student of God's word, and we can study together.

Julius Stewart
I have read it. You deny both.

Julius Stewart
Yes or no. Do you deny both?

Sing F Lau
And just what do I believe, may I ask?
Beware of bearing false witness.

I know you are annoyed because I say that you are acting like a fickle double-minded lad!!! Why should I entertain a fickle-minded lad like you?

Julius Stewart
It's a yes or no question. Now who is fickle?

Sing F Lau
Rev 20: 11 ¶ And I saw a great white throne, and him that sat on it, from whose face the earth and the heaven fled away; and there was found no place for them.
12 And I saw the dead, small and great, stand before God; and the books were opened: and another book was opened, which is the book of life: and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.
13 And the sea gave up the dead which were in it; and death and hell delivered up the dead which were in them: and they were judged every man according to their works.
14 And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death.
15 And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.
==============

[The activities are all described in the prophetic past tense to indicate their absolute certainty of coming to the past... they are as good as has happened... accomplished fact. God's sovereignty and immutability guarantee these.]

Their actual fulfilment is yet in the future... at Christ's return to judge the world.

A few observations from this 5-verses paragraph:

i. The momentous events described here shall occur at the end of time... at the threshold of eternity when the begotten Son of the eternal God shall sit upon His great white throne.

ii. Death and hell shall deliver up the dead in them at the end of time.
- Death and hell shall be emptied of their captives. None shall remain in death or hell anymore after that. Therefore, hell shall be emptied, and discarded.
- Hell's temporal/timely function shall cease at the end of time. At the end of time, hell shall have served its purpose.
- The EMPTIED death and hell shall be tossed into the lake of fire.

iii. Those delivered up by death and hell shall be judged every man according to their works.

iv. All those dead delivered up by death and hell whose names are not written in the Book of life shall be cast into the lake of fire.

- Those dead delivered up by death and hell whose names are found written in the Book of life shall not be cast into the lake of fire.

v. Verse 15 "And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire" obviously implies, in context, that of all those dead delivered up by death and hell, there are those whose names are written in the book of life, and others not written in the book of life.

Now, your turn to speak from the Scriptures.

Julius Stewart
Yes or no?

Julius Stewart
Regardless the lake of fire as you have shown in your understanding or interpretation is a place of final destruction. Will that destruction continue for eternity? Is it an eternal ongoing forever place of hell and destruction. Yes or no?

Sing F Lau
Yes, Julius Stewart is a fickled double-minded lad; and no, he is not a good student of the Bible! <LOL> How about that for a yes and no answer? Ya, I sure love goading you a wee bit!!!

Remember, you are a guest here! If you want to study the Scriptures, you are welcome to stay.

If you want to study the subject of the sonship of Jesus Christ, start a thread somewhere, and I may join in.

Julius Stewart
You will not answer the question. You made the jump to this site because Dallas copied your post. I deleted you Sing! Know the facts man. You will not answer the question. Not me.

Sing F Lau
Julius, you are foolish smart aleck... you have already publicly accused me of denying eternal hell (in your understanding of eternal torment), why are you asking me something on which you have declared your judgment? You pretend to be able to read my mind on the matter even before I have expressed my understanding!

Sing F Lau
I have changed the security setting of this thread from "Public" to "Friends Only." I hope this will get rid of that little pesky raving PB lad!!!

Julius said I made the jump to this site because Dallas copied my post!!!

I don't know what site he is about!

OK. Julius wants me to give credit to Dallas for whatever reason I know not.

Thanks, Dallas.

Sing F Lau
There is ONE BASIC presupposition in all of those warnings on hell by the Lord Jesus Christ
Hell can be avoided...
Hell is to be avoided by God's children.
And hell is to be avoided by the effort and conduct of God's children.

Christ alone has delivered God's people from the lake of fire by His work of eternal redemption!

To the non-elect, those not redeemed by Jesus Christ, hell, as well as the lake of fire CANNOT POSSIBLY be avoided.

Rev 20:15 "And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire."

"Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine!



June 17, 2017

"Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee." 1Tim 4:16.

Otherwise, what is the outcome? Temporal destruction of both the preacher and his flock!

"Collapsing any nation does not require the use of atomic bombs or the use of long-range missiles. It only requires lowering the quality of education and allowing cheating in the examinations by the students". (see full quote at the bottom)

EVEN SO, the downfall of any church. All it takes is undermining the ministry of the word; lower the faithfulness to, and expectation of, the word of truth in the ministry of the word, and the demise of the church is assured.

This explains the solemn charge of Paul to Timothy: "Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine." 2Ti 4:2

Also, "Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth." 2Ti 2:15

Since the command is to preach the word, the church must not tolerate anything else in the pulpit. Lowering the standard is suicidal!

The command to be instant in season and out of season in preaching requires the solemn duty to hear with the same urgency.

Not doing so is undermining the ministry of the word!

"Moreover, it is required in stewards that a man be found faithful." 1Cor 4:2. A church must not tolerate unfaithfulness in the ministry. Doing so is suicidal!!!

Now, you see the reason for this injunction:

"Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee." 1Tim 4:16.

Nothing doing so brings destruction to BOTH the preacher himself and his flock.

===========

 * A University professor wrote an expressive message to his students at the doctoral, master's, and bachelor's levels and placed it at the entrance to a university in South Africa.

And this is the message:

"Collapsing any nation does not require the use of atomic bombs or the use of long-range missiles. It only requires lowering the quality of education and allowing cheating in the examinations by the students".

The patient dies in the hands of such doctors.

And the buildings collapse in the hands of such engineers.

And the money is lost in the hands of such accountants.

And humanity dies in the hands of such religious scholars.

And justice is lost in the hands of such judges...

"The collapse of education is the collapse of the nation"



Two Types of Disciples; which type are you?



 

June 17, 2018 
 https://www.facebook.com/sing.f.lau/posts/pfbid0TfuuxG8X2187EDkkgg3eQm5D7W56V2Y7eb4SLEpmGqgmYL8dTTXEb6z3YjDkPnTCl

Two Types of Disciples; which type are you?

Brother HC introduced our first service today; he read from John 6:44-69 and drew our attention to the two types of disciples spoken of in the passage. Thank you, Brother.

Of the one group, it is noted of them, "From that time many of HIS DISCIPLES [emphasis, mine] went back, and walked no more with him." v66.

Of the other, when challenged by Christ, "Will ye also go away?", replied with great pathos, "Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life. And we believe and are sure that thou art that Christ, the Son of the living God."

We were reminded why many of Christ's disciples went back and walked no more with Him. "Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, this is an hard saying: who can hear it?" v60.

This sad phenomenon has not changed, has it?

Disciples, yes, EVEN the disciples of Jesus Christ are offended by all sorts of hard sayings of the Lord in the Holy Scriptures. They cannot bring themselves to humbly believe the truth of the gospel of Jesus Christ.

But thanks be to God that there are also those who confess, "Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life. And we believe and are sure that thou art that Christ, the Son of the living God." Amen.

Such are exhorted to hold fast, to remain steadfast, lest they fall. We live in a perilous time. See 2Tim 4:1ff. God's children are turned away from the truth unto fables.
-----------

16 comments

Adam Wells
Can those that turned away be called true disciples? He told them the only reason they were seeking Him was because their bellies had been filled (6:26). The Father must draw each man, which is God's operation of changing a heart toward Jesus Christ (6:44,65). Why did Jesus use hard sayings? Because He knew the majority of the crowd were insincere believers He needed to send away (6:64).

Sing F Lau
Can those that turned away be called true disciples?  Good question.
(Similar questions: Can those who made shipwreck of their faith be called true disciples? Those represented by fruitless grounds in Mt 13, can they be called true disciples?) 

I have moved on from using "true" and "false" - a zero-sum game played by many Christians.

"The Father must draw each man, which is God's operation of changing a heart toward Jesus Christ (6:44,65)" - you would agree that this deals with the eternal salvation of those drawn to Christ.

I certainly hope that by the statement, i.e. - The Father must draw each man, which is God's operation of changing a heart toward Jesus Christ (6:44,65) - you are NOT implying or concluding that, therefore each man drawn by God to Christ will be a disciple, and that he will continue to abide with Christ; i.e. that none who is drawn by God to Christ will be a disciple that will not turn away from following Christ. I just wish that that reformed fiction is true indeed. Then it would be much easier for Christ's undershepherd.

The effectual calling unto eternal salvation and the discipleship unto temporal salvation need to be distinguished - confounding them has produced all the mess of inconsistencies and contradictions in popular Calvinism.

The disciples turned away because of hard sayings is dealing with temporal salvation.

The doctrine of election is a hard saying to many who claim themselves disciples of Jesus Christ; so also justification by the faith of Christ, regeneration without means, etc. These are distinct from the enigmatic sayings of the parables.

The noun is the disciples; of these, there are good and faithful ones, there are bad and unfaithful ones, and there are diligent and lazy ones... Of the disciples, there are those who are barren and others who are of varying fruitfulness.

I have not seen a false man before; I have seen dead men and living men, big and small men, male and female men, etc. Of the living men, there are healthy robust ones and there are sickly ones...fruitful ones and barren ones and all in between. Of the healthy ones, there are among them mentally retarded, some crippled and some handicapped. They are all men, none of them false men. 

Even false brethren are brethren; they are brethren who are misguided and teach falsehood and errors.

Like the RBs, I USED TO say, "If a man does not persevere in a life of faith and holiness, he can't possibly be a child of God to start with." Grace has taught me to see things from a different perspective.

A distinction between eternal salvation and temporal salvation has helped me not a little in rightly dividing the word of truth.

Sorry for my ramblings.

Adam Wells
I don't disagree that there are weaker vs stronger brothers, i.e. disciples, however, that is not presented here in John 6. What we see are those who made a profession and did not continue, thus proving themselves to be insincere believers. "Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed." John 8:31

I do not follow the PB's in their strange idea of the unconverted elect being everywhere. (Though I do understand from Romans that there can be some.) Jesus consistently taught that his sheep hear and obey. I have never been an RB or PB and wish to avoid both ditches.

Perhaps you could view the notes here:
http://www.letgodbetrue.com/pdf/john-six.pdf and http://www.letgodbetrue.com/pdf/john-eight.pdf

Sing F Lau
Thanks for your thoughts.

You said, "I do not follow the PB's in their strange idea of the unconverted elect being everywhere. (Though I do understand from Romans that there can be some.)"

When you say, "though I do understand from Romans that there can be some", are you just conceding the POSSIBILITY that there may be such, or are you acknowledging that the WERE indeed such? Just asking to make sure that I understand you properly. If the latter, then it is not so strange after all, isn't it? Can't keep the cake and eat it too! 😉

Also, I need to inquire about your idea of conversion. Some sincere folks' understanding of conversion is synonymous with regeneration, i.e. conversion from spiritual deadness to grace and salvation. I believe you are not confusing the two. Before the last trump, there shall indeed be no unregenerated elect being anywhere on earth - that I wholly agree. I hope we can agree on that point. However, consistency necessarily requires you to affirm, "Before the last trump, there shall indeed be no unCONVERTED elect being anywhere on earth."

So, I take it that by conversion, you mean by the conversion as in "faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God." Romans 10:9-15.

Since you do not follow the PB's (you chose to attribute that teaching to them; I attribute the teaching to the Scriptures) idea of the unconverted elect being anywhere, the simple implication is that you do follow after the common and popular idea that every elect, without exception, will be converted through the preaching and hearing of, and the believing in, the word of God during their lifetime here on earth, and shall surely ABIDE as disciples to the end of their life; none shall turn away.

Is that implication drawn fairly? If not, what is a fair implication?

Adam Wells
I think we are on the same page concerning conversion, it is not a once-and-done event and IS NOT synonymous with regeneration. I do not hold the view "that every elect, without exception, will be converted through the preaching and hearing of, and the believing in, the word of God during their lifetime here on earth." That the scripture bears this out is well understood however, scripture is written to the elect with a bent towards discipleship, I have no way to think that I or anyone else is elect unless I/they both believe in and obey the Lord Jesus.

Sing F Lau
Adam @ "I don't disagree that there are weaker vs stronger brothers, i.e. disciples, however, that is not presented here in John 6. What we see are those who made a profession and did not continue, thus proving themselves to be insincere believers. "Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed." John 8:31
========

The Scriptures state that many of His disciples went back because of the hard sayings of the Lord. You chose to conclude that since they turned back and did not abide, they were no disciples at all - if I understand you correctly.

John 6
60 Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is an hard saying; who can hear it?
61 When Jesus knew in himself that his disciples murmured at it, he said unto them, Doth this offend you?
66 From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him.

Those who proved to be insincere believers, are they believers or are they not? The "believers" is a noun, that's what they are; "insincere" is an adjective, providing more information about the noun, i.e. they are insincere. Insincere men don't cease to be men, do they; they are men marked by a certain attribute, insincerity. The lazy and wicked servant is a servant nonetheless but a lazy and wicked servant who deserves severe stripes.

The disciples indeed are the disciples that are represented by the good ground; those who are not disciples indeed are like those represented by the three other types of ground, Mt 13. (All four types of ground are descriptions of disciples!!!) The branches that abide are disciples indeed; they that don't are no less vine branches, such shall suffer the temporal judgment. Fruitless vine branches are a harsh reality, John 15. Fruitless grounds are also a harsh reality. It is easy to just dismiss the fruitless vine branches as thornbushes (or the fruitless ground as granite!) Such are in fact accusing the Lord of expecting grapes from thornbushes.

The warning of John 8:31 presupposes the real danger of those who have believed in Jesus the Messiah not continuing in His word. The Lord was not dealing with hypothetical; the danger of the believers not continuing in Christ's word is real. The Lord didn't waste His words dealing with fictional danger.

Sing F Lau
Thanks for the references. When I have an opportunity, I will take a look.

Adam Wells
Did you get a chance to view the references? It is written more clearly than I am able to do at this point.

Sing F Lau
Maybe I fail to understand your initial statement: "I do not follow the PB's in their strange idea of the unconverted elect being everywhere."

May I ask, when you said you do not follow PB's in their strange idea of the unconverted elect being everywhere:
- by "do not follow" do you mean you don't understand or you don't agree with that idea?
- have you actually met a PB who believes that unconverted elect being EVERYWHERE?

Perhaps you have set up a straw man, or at least misrepresented their position. In any case, I have not heard of a PB who entertains the strange idea that the unconverted elect being EVERYWHERE. When we can't represent others correctly, we have not earned the right to dispute them.

I have heard of PBs who believe that there are God's children, i.e. the elect that are regenerated, who remain UN-reached or IN-capable of being reached, by the gospel ministry and therefore remain UN-converted in this life.
(This is affirmed by the Particular Baptists in 1689.10.3... "... 
so also are all elect persons, who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the Word.)

On the one hand, you said: "I do not follow the PB's in their strange idea of the unconverted elect being everywhere."

When pointed out the necessary implication of your statement, you said:
"
I do not hold the view "that every elect, without exception, will be converted through the preaching and hearing of, and the believing in, the word of God during their lifetime here on earth."

Can I then conclude then that you do believe that there are unconverted elect being SOMEWHERE, since you admitted: "that the scripture bears this out is well understood."

Adam Wells
I apologise if my statement is a bit vague or unclear. I am certainly not trying to misrepresent anyone. Would I be correct to say that you would liken these John 6 "disciples" which turned back, to those who choose the wide and broad way described in Matt 7:13? And that the destruction spoken of in verse 13 is only temporal in nature? If so, this is what I meant by elect being everywhere. I certainly agree with you that we should not be as those who turned aside, however, I differ in that I don't believe that the scripture is here pointing out elect people who couldn't continue; thus there are not two types of disciples, only one. Disciples of Christ love and obey him.

Sing F Lau
I'm still trying to understand what you are saying.
Maybe my little mind is confused by the way you use "elect" and "disciples".

What's the connection between "unconverted elect everywhere" and the disciples?

You said, "However I differ in that I don't believe that the scripture is here pointing out elect people who couldn't continue; thus there are not two types of disciples, only one."

You have "elect people" and the "disciples" together in the statement above. How are they related?

You don't believe that the scripture (I assume you are referring to John 6:44-69) is here pointing out elect people who couldn't continue.

So what do you believe that the scripture is pointing out?
- the scripture is pointing out that the elect are those who do continue? (the corollary, those who don't continue are not elect)?
- the scripture is pointing out that Christ's disciples who turned back were not elect people?
- Let me hear from the stallion's mouth?

Adam Wells
What I am saying is that though the word here used is "disciples," the John 6 hearers were not genuine and thus not really disciples. The passage bears that out and makes it clear to us. I used the word "elect" to try to make my meaning clear which seemed to only muddy the waters. Please disregard it if it isn't clear to you. What I did want to make clear is that Jesus' hard sayings or hard preaching sifted out those who were genuine vs those who were not.

As he spake these words, many believed on him. Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed;
John 8:30-31

Belief or mental consent is not enough, hence the statement in John 8.

Sing F Lau
Adam, permit me to ask one last question. Your answer will help me.

Those disciples that turned back from following Christ, whom you described as not genuine, do you consider them as unconverted elect or converted elect, or not elect at all?

Thanks.

Adam Wells
I've no reason to believe that these John 6 hearers are elect.

Sing F Lau
At last, I understood you. I should have asked that question at the beginning. Thanks.

Sing F Lau
Adam @ "However, scripture is written to the elect with a bent towards discipleship, I have no way to think that I or anyone else is elect unless I/they both believe in and obey the Lord Jesus."
=============

That's so true. The Scriptures are obviously intended for the sentient elect who are capable of being called out as disciples. Pictures are for those who have sight!

This is NOT THE SAME as saying all the elect without exception have access to the Scriptures or the ministry of the word in their lifetime here on earth and are all converted. There are God's children (regenerated elect) who remain UN-converted in their lifetime; the lifetime of some is brief!

"I have no way to think that I or anyone else is elect unless I/they both believe in and obey the Lord Jesus." Someone said, just because you don't see that dazzling flower in the harsh desert does not mean that that unknown flower does not exist! God's children exist OUTSIDE of the little world of our limited experience.

I'm in hearty agreement that no man has any ground or basis to claim that he is a child of God UNLESS he believes in the gospel of Jesus Christ and obeys him. The statement presupposes that the gospel of Jesus Christ has been presented unto him. Those who have never had the gospel preached to them have often been injuriously and wrongly labelled as unbelievers.

Say hello to Fawn and the four children. Your family is remembered by the church here.

Saturday, June 10, 2023

No faith, no justification says some RBs

  

Dear sister BumbleBee,

Thank you very much for your effort in proofreading. See my comments below, after yours marked ##

## Pastor Hoe in one of his sermons did say: “We are not justified by our faith but by the work of Christ alone.”  In another sermon previous to this, he also said that “we are justified by God’s grace alone, and by Christ’s blood, but this justification comes to us by faith”.  So, no one is “actually” justified in time until a person repents and believes in Christ.

sing: Finally speaking, it still boils down to “No faith, no justification” no matter how Pastor Hoe qualifies about justification by the work of Christ alone and justification by God’s grace alone. The bottom line is ‘justification by faith alone’ and that is a serious error.

We are justified
- by the grace of God (the MANNER it is applied, freely, at effectual calling) alone 
- through the blood of Christ alone (the BASIS/GROUND, at the cross), and
- faith and works of faith are (MEANS/INSTRUMENT) make manifest this free grace justification. (like breath manifests life.)

The Scripture says, ‘The just shall live by faith.’ This is repeated no less than 3 times in the Scriptures.

This simple declaration that the just shall live by faith alone is enough to tell us that faith is the effect of justification. The just are those justified by God. It is the JUSTIFIED ONES (past tense) that shall live (future, indicative) by faith (believing in Christ). Abraham was a classic proof – because Abraham was ALREADY a justified man, he believed the gospel of the promised seed – Gen 15:1-6, Romans 4:1-8. His believing is counted to him for righteousness, I.E. his faith was blessed to experience the blessedness of his justified state.

Think about this carefully… IT IS “the just shall live by faith”… and NOT “by faith, the condemned shall be justified and live” – this is commonly believed.

## It was said, “No repentance, no eternal life.”  Conversion is essential to salvation.

sing: Here’s a riddle: how does a person without life (spiritual and eternal) ever believe or repent?

Here is another riddle: how does a person without eternal life ever be converted – persuaded and embrace the gospel?

An elect is given eternal salvation so that he can be converted to know and experience temporal salvation here on earth. Eternal salvation is by grace from beginning to end. Temporal salvation is conditioned upon obedience to the gospel. Conversion is obedience to the gospel. Conversion is only possible because God has FIRST bestowed eternal life. 

## With regeneration we have a new nature.   And conversion is the first act of that new nature.

sing: With regeneration, we are given eternal life (the term spiritual life is not used in the Scriptures, but eternal life is spiritual life). The eternal life begotten in us explains the new nature. The eternal life ANIMATES all spiritual activities that follow.

So this third statement CORRECTLY admits that eternal life must PRECEDE repentance and faith. It, therefore, CONTRADICTS the second statement above, which is erroneous. 
[Do you notice that Cornelius manifested many acts of the new nature BEFORE he was converted by Apostle Peter's ministry?]

## Below is a summary of my understanding on the teaching thus far (which I think both parties would agree?).  The circle with the red outline represents the “redeemed of the LORD”. 



sing: I have a similar diagram – much simpler based on the 1689.10. The framers were theologians… and theologians of those days were all trained logicians because logic was one of the primary disciplines.

The Venn diagram below summarizes chapter 10 of the 1689 CoF:

M = the whole mankind; E = all the elect, and consists of those who are capable as well as those who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word; G = all those who are outwardly called by the ministry of the word, those of the elect and non-elect.

I am in complete agreement with the truth summarized by the 1689.10.

Let me outline here the logical order and the relationship of the 4 paragraphs:

Para 1: describes the effectual calling of ALL the elect. All the elect are effectually called to eternal life in precisely the same manner at God’s appointed and accepted time – whether they are infants or adults, sound minds or idiots, capable or incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word.

[This is the only and only way EVERY elect is brought to grace and salvation by the Triune God. There is not a NORMAL WAY nor an EXCEPTIONAL WAY. God has only one way of salvation. The exceptional way is invented by confused men to accommodate their confused minds.] 

Para 2: describes all those effectually called elect in Para 1 who receive the outward gospel call.

Para 3: describes all those effectually called elect in Para 1 who do not receive the outward gospel call. For various reasons, they are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word. The gospel call has reference to those who have the capacity to hear and understand, who can be communicated with the gospel. It is irrelevant to all others.

[This is not an exceptional way of salvation. These are among the elect in paragraph 1, therefore included in paragraph 1, an are saved by God in the same way. These people are not outwardly called by the gospel. But they are saved by God in the one and same way.]

Para 4: describes all those not in Para 1, i.e., those who are not predestinated to eternal life, but who have the outward gospel call.

You don’t need to reply to this.

I will send you a book to read – if you have time to read at all before your early retirement.

By grace alone,
sing

---