Things New and Old

Ancient truths revealed in the Scriptures are often forgotten, disbelieved or distorted, and therefore lost in the passage of time. Such ancient truths when rediscovered and relearned are 'new' additions to the treasury of ancient truths.

Christ showed many new things to the disciples, things prophesied by the prophets of old but hijacked and perverted by the elders and their traditions, but which Christ reclaimed and returned to His people.

Many things taught by the Apostles of Christ have been perverted or substituted over the centuries. Such fundamental doctrines like salvation by grace and justification have been hijacked and perverted and repudiated by sincere Christians. These doctrines need to be reclaimed and restored to God's people.

There are things both new and old here. "Consider what I say; and the Lord give thee understanding in all things"
2Ti 2:7.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

A Visit to Justification Town - 2g

Message 71
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 13:51:37 +0800

Repeating his phrase: every believer, as soon as he believes, is pardoned and accepted of God. Perhaps in a catechism class Buchanan would ask:
Q. When is a sinner pardoned?
A. As soon as he believes
Q. When is a sinner accepted of God?
A. As soon as he believes

Brother Tom,

No problem at all.
You insist that this is Actual Justification by faith. I believe it is Declarative Justification by faith.
[As soon as a sinner believes, he declares and attests to the prior Actual Justification by God’s free grace. Declarative Justification presupposes the prior Actual Justification.] I believe Actual justification by God's free grace is presupposed and precedes Declarative justification by faith. Quite simple, to me anyway.

I am sorry that the five fold aspects of justification do not help you in the least to rightly divide the word of truth.
sing


Message 72
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 13:51:38 +0800

"The moment you believe, your sins shall be washed away in Christ's blood"
"O what encouragement is here for great sinners, old sinners, backsliding sinners Jer.3.12 to believe in Christ! ..What though you are the worst of men, the greatest of sinners, and under matchless guilt; let it be so, and you are under the blackest character, yet there is hope; Isa 1.8 ie they (thy sins) shall be washed away in Christ’s blood that very moment that you believe in him."

Brother Tom,

No problem here at all.

The moment you believe... I assume that you do believe that the work of God's in the effectual call to grace and salvation MUST PRECEDE before there is any possibility of believing. If you don't, please state it clearly for me to hear, and I will show you that you have just repudiated many plain statements of Scriptures and the statements of Keach [affirmed and signed] in the 1689.

If the work of free sovereign grace has preceded to make believing possible, then Keach must be understood, and correctly and consistently understood, as speaking in the Declarative aspect of justification and salvation.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 73
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 15:03:20 +0800

Brother Sing,

Perhaps I misunderstood your definition of Actual Justification. I understood it this way:
Actual justification is the time when God declares the sinner just in His sight by pardoning him of all his sins (past, present and future) and imputes to him the righteousness of Christ. Declarative justification is when a sinner's works & faith declares to himself and others the justification (actual) that is already present.

When anyone says "your sins shall be washed away the moment you believe" means simply this: sins shall be washed away at the time of belief (no merit- in case you are stumbled by the Arminian thorn that is pricking you).

Similarly a person is actually justified, in real possession of Christ's righteousness when he believes. The Sins of all the Elect, while they remain in Unbelief, are charged upon them by the Law; and that the Righteousness of Christ is not actually imputed to them, until they do believe in Jesus Christ. Every believer, as soon as he believes, is pardoned and accepted of God. That justification (wholly of the free grace of God) is through the imputation of the perfect righteousness of Jesus Christ by faith. God imputes the complete and perfect righteousness of Jesus Christ to a believing sinner, though ungodly in himself, absolving him from all his sins, and accepting him as righteous in Christ. He that believes is perfectly justified, and freed from the curse of the law, and accepted, and accounted righteous in the sight of God, and hereby hath a certain title to eternal life.

I can say no more. The statements are clear as a bell. It is only when a sinner believes that righteousness of Christ is imputed and sins are pardoned.
Q. How can a sinner believe, you ask?
A. Through the quickening work of the Holy Spirit.
Q. What happened when the sinner believe (through the quickening work of
the Spirit)
A. He is accounted righteous in the sight of God (accounted righteous in
the sight of men will follow), freed from the curse of the law.

tom


Message 74
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 02:00:12 +0800

Brother Tom,

Tom: Perhaps I misunderstood your definition of Actual Justification. I understood it this way: Actual justification is the time when God declares the sinner just in His sight by pardoning him of all his sins (past, present and future) and imputes to him the righteousness of Christ. Declarative justification is when a sinner's works & faith declares to himself and others the justification (actual) that is already present.>>


When anyone says "your sins shall be washed away the moment you believe" means simply this: sins shall be washed away at the time of belief (no merit- in case you are stumbled by the Arminian thorn that is pricking you).

Is this your latest definition of Actual Justification? Please tell, where does your faith figure in this new definition? Is your Actual justification by your faith or WITHOUT your faith? [Your further statements below provide the answers.]

Actual Justification occurs at the time when God effectually calls an elect out of the state of sin and death to grace and salvation... this involves Actual justification, regeneration and adoption of an elect. No faith is involved here - for an elect in the state of sin and death CANNOT and WILL NOT believe because there is NO grace of faith worked in him without the indwelling Spirit. After he is justified (Actual), regenerated and adopted, an elect is enabled to believe and perform works of obedience.

Declarative Justification is the time when a regenerated elect is brought to faith and obedience. Faith and works declare and attest the Actual justification; faith and works are graces that accompanied a justified (Actual) elect. Faith and works declare and attest the justified state of a believer.

tom: When anyone says "your sins shall be washed away the moment you believe" means simply this: sins shall be washed away at the time of belief (no merit- in case you are stumbled by the Arminian thorn that is pricking you).

Brother, I have no Arminian thorn but Calvinist's irrationalism! You still don't see the point after all these exchanges. "The moment you believe" MUST necessarily presuppose the prior Actual Justification, without which "the moment you believe" is just an UTTER impossibility. "The moment you believe" has to do with Declarative justification alone!!! Your believing declares and attests and proves the Actual justification that HAS ALREADY taken place – all by God’s free grace.


tom: Similarly a person is actually justified, in real possession of Christ's righteousness when he believes. The Sins of all the Elect, while they remain in Unbelief, are charged upon them by the Law; and that the Righteousness of Christ is not actually imputed to them, until they do believe in Jesus Christ.


Without the righteousness of Christ imputed in [Actual Justification], an elect is in a state of condemnation (unjustified) and death (spiritually dead) and alienation (in enmity against God). You have not answered my questions on 1689.11.4 yet. Think about it. Don't have to reply. I had always thought only the Arminian expect such a condemned, dead and alienated person to believe in order to be justified (Actual)?

sing
"And some believed the things which were spoken,
and some believed not" Acts 28:24

Message 75
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 01:59:53 +0800

tom: This is also clear from his subsequent statements, and I quote:

Since it is clear to you, let me ask you some questions concerning his statements. You should have no trouble answering since they are clear to you.

tom: "The relation which subsists, in respect of order, between Regeneration and Justification, is sufficiently determined, for all practical purposes, if neither is held to be prior or posterios to the other, in point of time…..then it follows,- _that no unrenewed sinner is justified,- and that every believer, as soon as he believes, is pardoned and accepted of God_./

Q1. The relation which subsists, in respect of order, between Regeneration and Justification... which Justification do you think Buchanan has in mind - the Actual OR the Declarative? The answer should be very plain to all - since he said it "is sufficiently determined"!

I suggest to you this answer to 'mislead' and 'deceive' you:
Actual justification > Regeneration > Faith > Declarative justification.
The biblical order is an answer to much of your confusion. Don't dismiss it lightly.

RBs folks like you INSIST regeneration before Actual justification... and would not deal with the moral question of how a man under the just condemnation of God, i.e. unjustified, is also already regenerated by the Spirit of God, and therefore can believe in order to be justified (Actual). Why do you keep on insisting believing such a notion when you have a big MORAL issue with such notion??? Why Brother???

Only a justified (Actual) elect already imputed with the righteousness of life by the Father is regenerated with eternal life by the Spirit. This regenerated elect is enabled to believe... believing, his faith declares and attests and evidences his prior Actual justification by God's free grace.

Buchanan says, ""Actual Justification comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative." Declarative justification by faith necessarily presupposes, and is preceded by the Actual justification by God's free grace. That which is necessarily presupposed is that which must necessarily be prior logically and chronologically.

Q2. What does Buchanan mean, 'for all practical purpose'? How does this shed light on the nature the first question?

Actual Justification is in the legal and forensic realm.
Declarative justification is in the practical realm.
It seems your reading of Buchanan has not help you to understand him!
Nothing further needed be said.

Q3. When he said, "... that no unrenewed sinner is justified..." which justification is he speaking of - Actual or Declarative, assuming that by 'unrenewed' he meant 'unregenerated'?
[I may assume wrongly. You are free to suggest what you think it means... and then answer the question.]

Will any unrenewed person believe and be justified (declarative) by faith?
Will any one in the state of sin and death believe and be justified (declarative) by faith?

tom: "Repeating his phrase: every believer, as soon as he believes, is pardoned and accepted of God."

Please tell, what MUST happened before an elect in the state of sin and death is able to believe? Shouldn't there be that prior sovereign and free grace work of effectaul calling from out of the state of sin and death to grace and salvation?
Please tell, what must take place in the effectual call from out of sin and death to grace and salvation?

Can there be effectual call from out of sin and death to grace and salvation without the Actual removal of the condemnation of death and the Actual imputation of Christ's righteousness to the elect personally?

Can there be effectual call from out of sin and death to grace and salvation without the Actual imputation of Christ's righteousness to the elect personally and the regeneration unto eternal life of the elect?

Can there be believing without the person having been justified (Actual) and regenerated?

These are simple questions RBs do not wish to answer.

tom: Perhaps in a catechism class Buchanan would ask:
Q. When is a sinner pardoned?
A. As soon as he believes
Q. When is a sinner accepted of God?
A. As soon as he believes

Buchanan is right... he is speaking of the practical Declarative justification by faith. You want to make it the forensic Actual justification by faith.
Your reading of Buchanan's statement, "Actual Justification comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative" has not helped you at all because you are still insisting that Buchanan is speaking of Actual Justification while he was in fact speaking of Declarative Justification, with the Actual Justification necessarily presupposed and taken for granted. Without Actual Justification presupposed, there can be NO - NO - NO believing to speak of. Those under the condemnation of death CANNOT possibly believe. There Actual Justification MUST be presupposed if you are going to talk about sinners believing.

Gill put it nicely: I quoted it before... you may have missed it. Here it goes... "and this is readily allowed, that no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes." I believe Buchanan's questions are saying exactly the same, BUT you insist that Buchanan is speaking of justification in the Forensic and Actual sense.

Slow down and read some. Enjoy your… You may learn something.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing
---


Message 76
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 09:11:59 +0800

Pastor Lau,
Your questions are answered by Buchanan (without me having to 'read into' the sentence- which I think you are trying to do in order to 'justify' your position).

Read further and you will find this: "that no unrenewed sinner is justified,- and that every believer, as soon as he believes, is pardoned and accepted of God". The justification that Buchanan refers to is that Justification when person is pardoned and accepted of God. That is certainly Active Justification. One is pardoned and accepted of God at the time of Active Justification. One receives the assurance and sense of his justification (both before himself and men) during Declarative Justification.

I believe the Particular Baptists and Puritans are known for being careful with words: To be pardoned and accepted of God means Actual Justification; to receive a sense and comfort or assurance of their justification = Declarative Justification. Otherwise their arguments against the 'heresy' of eternal justification falls into total confusion because their opponent will not be sure what it is they are saying.

Should try reading Keach's sermon on the Marrow of Justification, and the Narrative that the Particular Baptist pastors wrote in support of Henry Coleman. FYI no one has held to a heresy called Declarative Justification before faith in the history of the church (that I know of- but my reading is limited, so please advise if you have come across). So the article "Actual Justification Rightly State proving there is no justification or actual union with Christ before Faith" refers to Actual Justification (just like the title says).

a justified sinner

regards
Tom


Message 77
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 09:45:39 +0800

Pastor Lau,
No wonder we are going around in circles. Your definition (quoted below): confuses Actual Justification with Effectual calling, or you have not defined Actual justification.

sing: Actual Justification is the time when God effectually calls an elect out of the state of sin and death to grace and salvation... this involves Actual justification, regeneration and adoption of an elect.

The confession: 1. Those whom God effectually calls, he also freely justifies, not by infusing righteousness into them, but by pardoning their sins, and by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous.........

Question: Is the confession here talking about Actual or Declarative? i.e. when God pardons their sins and account/accept them as righteous. Same words as Buchanan used, because he was talking about Actual Justification. Nobody argues over Declarative Justification as before or after faith- it has never been a point of contention.

Where is faith in all these? Keach's reply to the Question below is instructive:

/Quest. But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?/
/Ans. Yea as a condition of connection by way of order...and in this sense creation is a condition of salvation, if a man be saved, he must be created; so if a man believe, he shall be saved; _believing is a condition of connection_./

He went so far as to exhort his readers: /Such who receive this sacred pearl by faith, though they were dead, it immediately quickens them; and raiseth them from the dead to a state of spiritual life, Eph ii 1 /

There is no need to compile these things into a booklet. Get hold of Keach's exposition of the parables and read him. It is edifying. There is too much strife and conflict within the Church of Christ already. People are already discouraged by schisms. The Actual Justification controversy has been dealt with in 1696. Reading Keach's 2 sermons on the Marrow of Justification, and the Particular Baptist's defense of their colleague Henry Coleman re: Justification has enough material to give a sense of their beliefs.

walking the weathered path of the Particular Baptist ;-)
Tom


Message 78
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 12:56:43 +0800

Brother Tom,

tom: No wonder we are going around in circles. Your definition (quoted below): confuses Actual Justification with Effectual calling, or you have not defined Actual justification.

That's not the reason we are going in circle. [Your mistaking the Declarative Justification for the Actual Justification is.]

I said: Actual Justification is the time when God effectually calls an elect out of the state of sin and death to grace and salvation... this involves Actual justification, regeneration and adoption of an elect.

There is no confusion either.
My purpose was not to define Actual Justification. You looked for a definition of AJ when there is none. What I did state is the TIME when Actual Justification occurs - and that you will not see. See 1689.11.1 for my definition of Actual Justification... which is necessarily presupposed when there is faith to receive it, for Actual justification is declared and attested by faith.

I deliberately placed Actual Justification in the CONTEXT of Effectual Calling because that's where the CRUX of the matter is: Actual Justification takes place when FAITH is NOT POSSIBLE, when an elect under the condemnation of death is justified (Actually). Where do you find faith in a condemned and spiritually dead elect... 'in his state of sin and death'? You seem to ignore or reject this simple biblical fact.

tom: The confession: “1. Those whom God effectually calls, he also freely justifies, not by infusing righteousness into them, but by pardoning their sins, and by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous.........”

I am glad you are quoting the 1689 now.
Please tell, when God effectually calls an elect out of his state of sin and death to grace and salvation, and justifies (Actual), regenerates and adopts him, is he able to exercise faith? Is a condemned, dead and alienated elect able to exercise faith in order to be justified (Actual)?

tom: Question: Is the confession here talking about Actual or Declarative? i.e. when God pardons their sins and account/accept them as righteous.

My answer: the Actual justification at effectual calling to grace and salvation.
Actual justification is by free grace, and WITHOUT and BEFORE faith.
Actual justification is then received by faith... which is the instrument attesting and declaring the PRIOR Actual Justification.

tom: Same words as Buchanan used, because he was talking about Actual Justification. Nobody argues over Declarative Justification as before or after faith- it has never been a point of contention.

Buchanan's point is that Actual Justification is necessarily presupposed in Declarative justification by faith. He is talking about Declarative justification that takes place at believing. Whenever there is believing on the part of the believer involved, the subject and context is Declarative justification. The Actual justification which HAS TAKEN place by free grace is received by faith... declared and attested by faith.

Nobody [i.e. among the old school Baptists] ever believe that Actual Justification is BY faith. [Many of their step children, the RBs do!]
Many [all those that signed the 1689 CoF] believe that Actual Justification by God's free grace.
And this Actual justification by God's free grace is received, attested or declared through faith.
Faith is NOT possible without PRIOR Actual Justification. This biblical fact is ignored and rejected by

Nobody [i.e. among the old school Baptists] ever believe that Declarative Justification is BEFORE faith even though many like Gill and Buchanan were accused of believing that nonsense because they believed Actual Justification is BEFORE faith.

Those like Buchanan and Gill who taught that Actual Justification IS BEFORE faith were MISUNDERSTOOD and maligned and misrepresented as teaching that Declarative Justification is BEFORE faith. So they have to emphatically state and defend that Declarative justification is through faith. [They were defending against such perverse charge against them, and it was in that context that they said “no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes.” The standard reformed folks pervert their words and make them say “no man is Justified (Actual) until he believes.”]

Here's their words of defence:

"What scriptures may be thought to speak of faith, as a prerequisite to justification, cannot be understood as speaking of it as a prerequisite to the being of justification; for faith has no causal influence upon it, it adds nothing to its being, it is no ingredient in it, it is not the cause nor matter of it; at most, they can only be understood as speaking of faith as a prerequisite to the knowledge and comfort of it, and to a claim of interest in it; and this is readily allowed, that no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes; that is, he cannot have the knowledge of it, nor any comfort from it; nor can he claim his interest in it, without faith; and this being observed, obviates another objection, that if justification is before faith, then faith is needless and useless. It is not so; it is not of use to justify men, which it is never said to do; but it is of use to receive the blessing of justification, and to enjoy the comfort of it." [Gill - Body of Divinity, bk 2, chapter 5)

The words highlighted imply several things:
- Actual Justification is BEFORE and WITHOUT faith.
- Those teaching 'Actual Justification is BEFORE and WITHOUT faith' are often and still misunderstood and maligned as teaching 'Declarative Justification is BEFORE faith’ and Actual Justification in eternity.
- Faith is NEVER SAID to do so - has any place in Actual Justification. Faith 'is not the use to justify men' - obviously in the Actual sense.

Buchanan said virtually the same thing in his paragraph.

"…The Protestant doctrine affirms that a sinner is made or constituted righteous by having Christ’s righteousness imputed to him; and that, being thus justified actually, he is also justified declaratively, when his acceptance is proved or attested, so as to be made manifest to his own conscience, or to his fellow-men. In both cases it is one and the same Justification that is spoken of:– his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God; but in the one it is considered simply as a fact, in the other as a fact that is attested and proved. Actual Justification comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative; and hence, if any one is declared to have been justified, we conclude that he was actually justified, or accepted as righteous in the sight of God…" [Buchanan - Justification, Lecture 8, Proposition 2]

- Actual Justification comes first - when faith was not possible.
- Actual Justification by God's free grace is then attested and proved by faith in the Declarative Justification. WCF says faith is a grace found in a justified (Actual) man.

The CRUX of the whole controversy is this: The Declarative Justification by faith taught by the old school has been misunderstood and perverted into Actual Justification by faith. Those old school men like Gill and Buchanan clearly distinguished the two... but very many standard reformed men have confused the two.

When the old school speaks of Declarative Justification by faith, they are seen and understood by the modern standard reformed folks as speaking about Actual Justification by faith.

When the old school speaks of Declarative Justification presently, and NOT that which (AJ) is necessarily presupposed, the modern standard reformed folks make them to speak presently of Actual Justification, which is necessarily presupposed, already happened.

Until this cross-eyed vision is realized, you and I will read and understand the old school men differently. Until then, the parallel roads are not likely to meet.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 79
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 19:24:06 +0800

Brother Tom,

tom: /Quest. But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life.
Ans. Yea as a condition of connection by way of order...and in this sense creation is a condition of salvation, if a man be saved, he must be created; so if a man believe, he shall be saved; _believing is a condition of connection_/

This is a 'powerful' quote... let's see what Keach is saying.

Don't misread Keach.
He did not say, 'The gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life.' I fear only those words attracted your attention. He did say, 'Yea, [gospel requires faith as a condition of justification and eternal life, but only] AS A CONDITION OF CONNECTION BY WAY OF ORDER... believing is a condition of connection.' Did you give any consideration to Keach's words, 'as a condition of connection by way of order'? I quite doubt it, Brother. You only want to read, 'as a condition.' You have no use for the words that QUALIFY the condition.

Your treatment of Keach words is a classic illustration of what I stated before: "When the old school [Baptists] speaks of Declarative Justification, they are seen and understood by the modern standard reformed folks as speaking about Actual Justification. When the old school speaks of Declarative Justification presently, and NOT that which is necessarily presupposed, the modern standard reformed folks make them to speak of Actual Justification which is necessarily presupposed, already happened."

If you want to take Keach's answer in the Actual sense, then you make him to contradict everything he affirmed and signed in the 1689 CoF. You are making Keach to say that those spiritually dead in sin is able to believe to have eternal life (i.e. faith is a condition to eternal life), those under the condemnation of death is able to believe to be justified (Actual) before God (i.e 'faith is a condition to Actual justification.)

Either you are right... in which case I conclude that Keach is grossly inconsistent and self-contradicting with what he has affirmed in the 1689 CoF. Or you are plainly wrong and are FORCING a Particular Baptist to speak and believe like an full-blown Arminian!

However, if Keach's answer is understood in the Declarative sense, then it makes perfect sense and is in complete harmony with what he affirmed and signed in the 1689 CoF. I understand Keach answer as, "The gospel requires faith as a condition to declare and attest and prove justification and eternal life." This way a Particular Baptist is understood as he should.

One can either choose to read Keach as an inconsistent and self-contradicting man, or as a consistent and logical Particular Baptist. I choose the later.

I have often cautioned against reading by the *sight* and *sound* of words. Learn to read the *sense* of the word. Scriptures declare in so many places, "Whoever believes has eternal life." This statement which declares a simple fact is so often understood as a statement offering eternal life on condition of faith.

"Believing is a condition by connection, by way of order..."
What is the connection spoken of? What is the way of order spoken of?

What is the connection, by way of order?
Is it: Believing > Justification (Actual) > Regeneration (eternal life),
Or is it: Justification (Actual) > Regeneration (eternal life) > Believing > Declarative Justification (faith declaring, attesting, proving the prior Actual Justification).

You insist that Keach speaks of the first connection by way of order. So, you make Keach to believe that the spiritually dead can believe in order to be given eternal life, and make him to contradict and denounce what he affirmed and signed in the 1689 CoF.

Just for the record...
sing


Message 80
Date: Fri, 05 Jan 2007 15:27:14 +0800

Pastor Lau,
Here's a modification of your statements:

Actual justification at effectual calling to grace and salvation.
Actual justification is by free grace, and WITHOUT and BEFORE faith.
Actual justification is then received by faith... which is the instrument /of/ attesting and declaring the PRIOR Actual Justification.

What is it that faith receives ( fr your third statement)?
God imputes, faith receives the righteousness of Christ- all happened at Actual Justification
/Is faith the cause of justification - no, it is free grace
Is faith the ground of justification-no, it is the satisfaction made by Christ
Is faith the means/instrument of our justification- yes, the dignity is not in faith as a grace, but relatively,as it lays hold on Christ’s merits. /

How is faith the means/instrument of justification?

/Faith justifies a sinner _in the sight of God,_ not because of those other graces which do always accompany it, or of good works that are the fruits of it, nor as if the grace of faith, or any act thereof, were imputed to him for his justification; but only as it is an instrument by which he receiveth and applieth Christ and his righteousness./ (Larger Catechism)//

/None can be said to be actually reconciled, justified, or adopted, until they are really _implanted into Jesus Christ_ by Faith. (/From the General Assembly of the Particular Baptist Churches in 1689)

/14. This justification comes about because of Christ, but not in the absolute sense of Christ's being the cause of vocation. It happens be-cause Christ is apprehended by faith, which follows calling as an effect. //Faith precedes justification as the instrumental cause, laying hold of the righteousness of Christ from which justification being apprehended follows; //therefore, righteousness is said to be from faith, Rom. 9:30; 10:6. And justification is said to be by faith, Rom. 3:28. /

/15. This justifying faith is not the general faith of the understanding by which we give assent to the truth revealed in the Holy
Scriptures, for that belongs not only to those who are justified, nor of its nature has it any force to justify, nor produce the effects which are everywhere in Scripture given to justifying faith. / (from William Ames)

Statement 14 is Actual Justification - by (justifying) faith.
Statement 15 is Declarative Justification by faith.

To be honest, I doubt very much that the puritans and Particular Baptists wrote a great deal about Declarative Justification (by faith & works)- that has never been an issue of great contention. Therefore to read into statements of Justification by faith to make it say 'Declarative' Justification is biased.

btw you have asked repetitively how a sinner dead in trespasses and sin can exercise faith- you know the answer as well as I do. /Faith is a gift of God, given at the time of effectual calling where He enlightens their minds spiritually and savingly (quickening- I presume) to understand the things of God, taking away their heart of stone and giving to them a heart of flesh (in regeneration) and renewing their wills and determining them to that which is good (faith)

Then, those whom God effectually calls (above) He also freely justifies./..........I'm sure you can rattle of the rest by now. Sounds like good sound theology to me - these 1689 people.

Your cuppa must be adulterated coffee. Does not taste like original… white. ;-) (sorry! can't resist a dash of sanctified sarcasm- must be fr my ... younger days)

tom




A Visit to Justification Town - 2f

Message 61
Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 02:09:06 +0800

Brother Tom,

Read some words of John Gill, and you will see that he and Buchanan are saying exactly the same thing. I am only repeating old stuff. I hope you take note.

sing
------

"What scriptures may be thought to speak of faith, as a prerequisite to justification, cannot be understood as speaking of it as a prerequisite to the being of justification; for faith has no causal influence upon it, it adds nothing to its being, it is no ingredient in it, it is not the cause nor matter of it; at most, they can only be understood as speaking of faith as a prerequisite to the knowledge and comfort of it, and to a claim of interest in it; and this is readily allowed, that no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes; that is, he cannot have the knowledge of it, nor any comfort from it; nor can he claim his interest in it, without faith; and this being observed, obviates another objection, that if justification is before faith, then faith is needless and useless. It is not so; it is not of use to justify men, which it is never said to do; but it is of use to receive the blessing of justification, and to enjoy the comfort of it." [Gill - Body of Divinity, bk 2, chapter 5)
----------

"…The Protestant doctrine affirms that a sinner is made or constituted righteous by having Christ’s righteousness imputed to him; and that, being thus justified actually, he is also justified declaratively, when his acceptance is proved or attested [by faith, sing], so as to be made manifest to his own conscience, or to his fellow-men. In both cases it is one and the same Justification that is spoken of:– his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God; but in the one it is considered simply as a fact, in the other as a fact that is attested and proved [by faith, sing]. Actual Justification comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative; and hence, if any one is declared to have been justified, we conclude that he was actually justified, or accepted as righteous in the sight of God…" [Buchanan - Justification, Lecture 8, Proposition 2]


Message 62
Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 22:32:08 +0800

Pastor Lau,

Thanks for taking the trouble to compare the two.
1) Agree that John Gill most probably believes (actual) justification to precede faith,- although I have to admit not having read his writings much.

2) Your quote from Buchanan's Lecture 8 Proposition 2 is accurate. However dropping the words [by faith] in the sentence describing declarative justification is misleading and does no justice to the author's intention. [I almost get the impression you are trying to mislead me O:-) !). If you care to read the Proposition 2 a little further on you might be warmly surprised that he holds to what you consider the 'heretical view' of Actual Justification by faith. I quote here:

/The Protestant doctrine affirms that a sinner is made or constituted righteous by having Christ’s righteousness imputed to him; and that, being thus justified actually, he is also justified declaratively, when his acceptance is proved or attested, so as to be made manifest to his own conscience, or to his fellow-men./ (page 234, in this chapter Buchanan rightly pointed out the important theological distinction between Actual and Declarative Justification)

/The distinction between Actual and Declarative Justification, may be further illustrated by what is said of the Old Testament believers in the 11th chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews. The Apostle refers to them as _been actually justified by faith_; but his expressions show that he speaks also, and very specially, of their declarative justification…._.Their Actual Justification is presupposed, but their Declarative Justification is specially referred to...Justification, considered as the pardon of a sinner and his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God, is by faith./ (taken from pages 236-238).

Later in page 251,
/The act of justification introduces _believers _into a state of Justification…..is an act of God in time,- not His eternal purpose merely, as some Antinomians have held,- nor is it a mere revealing of what was always true, and is now only made known and believed…..It is an act of God with reference to the individuals, and it takes place at a definite period in the life of each,- for as long as any one remains without Christ, and in a state of unbelief, he is charged with guilt, and exposed to wrath; but as soon as he believes and is united to Christ, his state in this respect is entirely changed./

Merely standing on giant's shoulder,
Tom


Message 63
Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 22:34:04 +0800

Pastor Lau,
I've replied to some of your statements below in a previous mail. Just a quick one here: You said below (correctly) that:

Actual justification by God's free grace comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative by your faith.
Actual justification by God's free grace is declared and attested by faith in Christ.

But both these statements are not in dispute, and introducing them confuse the issue and add unnecessary length to the post. I believe (as you do) that Actual justification precedes Declarative justification. Where we differ is whether Actual Justification is by faith or before faith. Actual Justification is by the instrumentality of (non-meritorious) faith - that, of which is a gift of Christ
Declarative Justification is by faith and works (although you seem to think Declarative justification is by faith only).

tom


Message 64
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 00:44:14 +0800

Brother Tom,

Now I am very puzzled.
You said my two statements are correct, and are not in dispute.

The first statement excludes the vain notion that your Actual Justification is by your faith! Your Actual Justification cannot be, at one and the same time, by God's free grace and by your faith too. It is either by God's free grace, or by your faith.

The second statement excludes the vain notion that BOTH your Actual Justification and your Declarative Justification are by your faith.

You state correctly that where we differ is whether Actual justification is by faith or before faith. That is a very good summation of the issue at hand.

Please tell, what is the spiritual state of an elect before Actual Justification?
What can an elect do spiritually before his Actual Justification?
I asked some questions on 1689.11.4? Did you consider them? (Message 59)

You said, “Declarative Justification is by faith and works (although you seem to think Declarative justification is by faith only).

I believe this: "Jas 2:24 Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only." "... It [faith] is not alone in the person justified, but ever accompanied with all other saving graces..." 1689.11.2.
Now you can be certain what I do believe on this point.

Faith and works justify DECLARATIVELY ONLY. BOTH are saving effects of Actual Justification.

You insist that faith justifies in BOTH the Actual and Declarative Justification.
That's where the heart of the difficulty and confusion lies.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 65
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 00:44:42 +0800

Brother Tom,

Thanks for the extra paragraphs from Buchanan.
I may be deceived, but to think that I wish to mislead you is laughable... easier to swallow an African elephant than to deceive a [clever and intelligent] man like you .

You complained about my putting '[by faith, sing].' The purpose is not to mislead you. I am not good at deception... I was stupid to bracket ‘by faith’ with my name there . The purpose is to assist reader to see the distinction more clearly. May I ask, how else is Actual Justification declared and attested but by faith - as the context of the paragraphs show?

See my comments. I have read the Proposition II several times... maybe with coloured glasses... in which case it is your honour to tell what colour the glasses is.

"The distinction between Actual and Declarative Justification, may be further illustrated by what is said of the Old Testament believers in the 11th chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews. The Apostle refers to them as been actually justified by faith; but his expressions show that he speaks also, and very specially, of their declarative justification… Their Actual Justification is presupposed, but their Declarative Justification is specially referred to...Justification, considered as the pardon of a sinner and his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God, is by faith." (taken from pages 236-238).>> [emphasis mine, sing]

Please note carefully BUCHANAN'S QUALIFYING words, "but his [the author of Hebrews, sing] expressions show that he speaks also, and VERY SPECIALLY, of their declarative justification..." Could Buchanan qualify more plainly that he understood the justification spoken of by the author of Hebrews is VERY SPECIALLY the declarative justification by faith, and not the actual justification by faith?

Again he said, "Their Actual Justification is presupposed, but their Declarative Justification is SPECIALLY referred to." Could Buchanan distinguish more plainly that the justification spoken of is SPECIALLY the declarative justification by faith, and NOT the Actual Justification by faith?

I conclude:
a. Actual justification by God's free grace is presupposed.
b. Actual justification is by God's free grace. What is presupposed is separate and distinct from, and precedes the Declarative Justification by faith.
c. Actual justification is NOT by faith.
d. Actual justification IS - IS - IS received by faith.
e. Actual justification by God's free grace IS - IS - IS attested and declared by faith.
f. Faith is the instrument to declare and attest the Actual justification by God's free grace.

Do these simple statements make sense?

Tom: The act of justification introduces _believers _into a state of Justification…..is an act of God in time,- not His eternal purpose merely, as some Antinomians have held,- nor is it a mere revealing of what was always true, and is now only made known and believed…..It is an act of God with reference to the individuals, and it takes place at a definite period in the life of each,- for as long as any one remains without Christ, and in a state of unbelief, he is charged with guilt, and exposed to wrath; but as soon as he believes and is united to Christ, his state in this respect is entirely changed./

This describes Actual Justification in time nicely, manifesting itself in Declarative Justification through faith. In Buchanan's own words, 'their Actual Justification [in time] is presupposed, but their Declarative Justification is specially referred to."

It is so plain that Buchanan is refuting the false accusation of 'Actual Justification' in eternity. He had to state categorically, that 'Actual Justification is an act of God in time - i.e. at effectual at God's appointed and approved time. Actual Justification brings an elect out of the STATE of sin and condemnation into a STATE of justification. Again, 'takes place at a definite period of time in the life of each.

I have nothing more to say. I better shut up lest I mislead you .
I will leave you to believe what you will. Thanks for the exchanges.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 66
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 09:59:06 +0800

Pastor Lau,

Both the RB and yourself believe the same regarding Justification by free grace. Indeed our salvation is all of grace.

Our difference lies in the whether faith is before or after Actual Justification. You say faith justify as a work - but that's the Arminian concept of faith. The RB (together with the Particular Baptist) says faith is the instrument or beggarly hands that receive the Righteousness of Christ. And that faith is a gift. And therefore Actual Justification is by free grace through faith.

by grace through faith
Tom


Message 67
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 10:38:21 +0800

Dear Pastor Lau,
Your reading of Buchanan is clearly biased. Please allow me the liberty to show why, and I re-quote:

/The distinction between Actual and Declarative Justification, may be further illustrated by what is said of the Old Testament believers in the 11th chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews. The Apostle refers to them as been _actually justified by faith_; but _his expressions show that he speaks *also*, and very specially, of their declarative justification_…../
/Their Actual Justification is _presupposed_, but their Declarative Justification is specially referred to./
/Justification, considered as the pardon of a sinner and his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God, is by faith./

From the first two statements it is clear that Buchanan is saying: Hebrews 11 presupposes that the OT believers have been Actually Justified by faith, and speaks of their declarative justification. Notice where he puts the 'by faith' - viz next to "actually justified". The third statement talks about active and passive justification (not declarative) and they are by faith.

Let me quote another 'heretical' (by your estimate) view of a reformed baptist:
/"O what encouragement is here for great sinners, old sinners, backsliding sinners Jer.3.12 to believe in Christ! ..What though you are the worst of men, the greatest of sinners, and under matchless guilt; let it be so, and you are under the blackest character, yet there is hope;….Isa 1.8 ie they (thy sins) shall be washed away in Christ’s blood that very moment that you believe in him."/

I have no problems giving the same invitation to sinners. If we hold to the foolish notion of justification before faith, the appeal to sinners above would be theologically impossible/.

/Believing in Jesus Christ is no work, but a resting on Jesus Christ; ...The poor wearied sinner can never believe on Jesus Christ till he finds he can do nothing for himself; and in his first believing doth always apply himself to Christ for salvation…..This doctrine of free justification by faith alone, hath this advantage, that it suits all men’s spirits and frame in their serous approaches to God in worship. (Robert Traill)/

soli Deo gloria,
Tom


Message 68
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 12:31:23 +0800

Your reading of Buchanan is clearly biased. Please allow me the liberty to show why, and I re-quote:
> /The distinction between Actual and Declarative Justification, may be further illustrated by what is said of the Old Testament believers in the 11^th chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews. The Apostle refers to them as been _actually justified by faith_; but _his expressions show that he speaks *also*, and very specially, of their declarative justification_…../

Brother Tom,

I knew this was coming.

The word 'actually' (an ADVERB) as in 'actually justified by faith' is now taken by you to mean Actual (an adjective) as in Actual Justification. Can you see just how a slight misreading can do to the meaning of a simple statement.

My advice: don't read by *sight* and *sound* of a word, read by the *sense* of the word in its context.

I am sure you have no problem distinguishing an adverb from an adjective.
If you want to read the word 'actually' as a adjective, try reading the sentence again and see Buchanan openly contradict himself in the very same sentence. I think he is more consistent than many who are reading him.

For a moment try reading 'actually' as 'really justified by faith.' Then the whole idea of Actual justification disappear from the paragraph altogether. But you will go on insisting that it is there because of the *sight* and *sound* of that word *actually*.

We went through this before, didn't we?

A believer (like Abraham in Gen 15:1-6) is really/actually justified by faith in Declarative justification.
He was really/actually justified by grace in Actual justification at effectual calling out of sin and death.
The latter precedes the former, both logically and chronologically.
[*also* only indicates that Actual Justification is necessarily presupposed.]

I think you need to distinguish Actual justification is by God's free grace, and that Actual justification is received by faith; the former precedes the latter, both logically and chronologically. Actual Justification by grace must have taken place before it can be received by faith in Declarative Justification.

Actual Justification is not by faith. Actual justification is received by faith - and that is Declarative Justification by faith. Faith is the instrument to declare and attest the Actual Justification by the free grace of God. That's the proper relationship [and order] between the two.

Please do believe whatever you do understand at this stage.
I don't think I am in a position to teach you anything. You appear to me to be quite an accomplished self-taught man.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing
---

Message 69
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 12:55:55 +0800

Pastor Lau,
The quote was from Benjamin Keach- his system of theology is unashamedly evangelical RB
"The moment you believe, your sins shall be washed away in Christ's blood"

"O what encouragement is here for great sinners, old sinners, backsliding sinners Jer.3.12 to believe in Christ! ..What though you are the worst of men, the greatest of sinners, and under matchless guilt; let it be so, and you are under the blackest character, yet there is hope;Isa 1.8 ie they (thy sins) shall be washed away in Christ's blood that very moment that you believe in him."

Tom


Message 70
Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2007 13:36:05 +0800


Brother Tom,

Tom: Both the RB and yourself believe the same regarding Justification by free grace. Indeed our salvation is all of grace. Our difference lies in the whether faith is before or after Actual Justification. You say faith justify as a work - but that's the Arminian concept of faith The RB (together with the Particular Baptist) says faith is the instrument or beggarly hands that receive the Righteousness of Christ. And that faith is a gift. And therefore Actual Justification is by free grace through faith.

I believe Actual justification is by free grace, and Declarative justification is by faith. Yes, by grace alone, declared and attested through faith in Christ.

All along, RBs like you have insisted that Actual justification is by faith. Go back and read your own posts, and the way you have been reading Buchanan and many Particular Baptists through that glasses.

I say faith and works justify in the declarative sense, they are evidences that declare and attest to the prior Actual justification by God's free grace.

"The grace of faith... is the work of the Spirit of Christ in their hearts and is ordinarily wrought by the ministry of the Word." 1689.14.1. In that sense it is a gift, like ALL other saving graces worked in their hearts, and they not of their own.

The grace of faith worked in the heart of God's children by the indwelling Spirit of God, and the believing acts of God's children as a result of that gracious work are quite different things. God's children themselves must do all the believing. It is their activities... they do the believing. [Their spiritual work of believing is the instrument for their declarative justification.]

Faith and works are ALL effects of Actual Justification. This is what Particular Baptists declared in the 1689:
"Faith thus receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness, is the alone instrument of justification;(6) yet it is not alone in the person justified, but ever accompanied with all other saving graces, and is no dead faith, but worketh by love."

Faith is NOT ALONE in the person justified [Actual]. Many other graces are worked in them by the Holy Spirit that dwells in them. Is it not obvious that faith is a product or effect of Actual Justification? How could a product of Actual justification be the instrument of Actual justification? I have asked that long ago... and no RB care to give an answer.

Faith is the instrument to declare and attest the Actual justification by God's free grace. Faith is NOT the instrument of Actual justification - you insisted all along that it is.

Actual justification is by free grace... declared and attested through faith. This is VERY different from saying that Actual justification is by your faith... something which you HAVE INSISTED all along in our LONG series of exchanges.

I think you are still quite confused about a simple thing: faith as the instrument to receive the righteousness of Christ is a whole world of difference from saying that your faith is the instrument of your Actual justification. The former is the Declarative and Experiential aspect of salvation. The latter is Actual or Objective aspect of salvation.

A man that has beggarly hands that move to receive something... is he still under the condemnation of death, i.e. is he still an unjustified man... is he still spiritually dead... is he still an un-adopted alien...? Then what explains for the life and spiritual activities...? Think about it Brother Tom!

Thanks for the exchanges.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing

A Visit to Justification Town - 2e

Message 51
Date: Wed, 06 Dec 2006 15:40:29 +0800

Dear Pastor Lau,

I guess you are right- we are going in circles trying to convince that we are both on the side of the Particular Baptist.
Neither succeeding very much.

If any of my words have caused offence please forgive me for none is ever intended. Even the so-called 'cheeky' remarks are not sarcasm but to alleviate tension in such an atmosphere.
I am not one who liked theological debates- they almost always end up sadly. However I thank you for your gentlemanly exchanges and willing to discuss truth with someone who is not worthy. It is frustrating because you can't see what I see 'wink!' ;-]} (bearded man again!), but I guess you will say 'ditto' to that. Thanks for the theological journey. I actually have to sit down and read some of the stuff by Keach and the others. They are good! If I get round to going through Keach's Marrow of Justification and typing his (and others) Narrative - I will send you a copy. I understand solid ground books are reprinting the Marrow of Justification but no news of release yet.

Yes, I have to prepare some talks for the … and work in the office is also piling up a bit. Please continue to pray for us even though we may not agree on every jot and tittle. My regards to the brethren in SDC and your charming family.

in Christian love,
Tom.


Message 52
Date: Wed, 06 Dec 2006 16:54:56 +0800

Brother Tom,

Rest assured that no offence is taken at all.
We will let the matter rest until some other time.
We did pray that the Lord will bless your ministry at the youth camp. May our Lord hear the prayers of His needy children.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 53
Date: Fri, 08 Dec 2006 00:55:51 +0800
Subject: Keach and peaches

Brethren,

A brother quoted from Keach these words:

From his exposition of the parables p.174, "Such who receive this sacred pearl by faith, though they were dead, it immediately quickens them; and raiseth them from the dead to a state of spiritual life."
In answering an objection
"Obj. But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?"
"Ans. Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic"

What do you think Keach is saying? Is he teaching that faith is a prerequisite to life? I don't have any book by Keach.
Could you help me with some quotes from his writings that repudiate that idea if he indeed did not hold to that idea?
Such blatantly Arminian interpretation contradicts his public and confessional statements in the 1689 CoF.

sing


Message 54
Date: Thu, 07 Dec 2006 13:10:57 –0500

Dear Brother Sing,

The reason I have not answered your questions on this matter is that I simply don't know. I plead ignorance. A casual perusal of http://www.apuritansmind.com/Creeds/BenjaminKeach'sCatechism.htm yields the following, more agreeable, statement:

"Q. 34. How does the Spirit apply to us the redemption purchased by Christ?
“A. The Spirit applies to us the redemption purchased by Christ, by working faith in us, and thereby uniting us to Christ in our effectual calling. (Eph. 2:8; 3:17)"

The excerpt you have posted above sounds an awful lot like he is saying that faith is a prerequisite to life, but some of the other catechisms on the URL above do, too. It is primarily a Puritan website. Puritans and Calvinists are often known for their logic, but sometimes it appears to me that they come down on both sides of an issue, and willingly embrace contradictions, as do some Baptists who are heavily influenced by such teachers. I thought, with my mathematics training, that I would be able to follow their logic, but I often fail, and I love the straightforward harmony that I find among most Primitive Baptists when they declare the work of Jesus Christ.

Love, Marty


Message 55
Date: Fri, 08 Dec 2006 10:22:51 +0800

Dear Brother Marty,

Glad to hear from you. Keep speaking... I need help to think.
The question/answer you quoted struck a thought in my mind.

May be in the mind of Keach there is a distinction between the Father applying to us the redemption purchased by Christ and the Holy Spirit applying to us the redemption purchased by Christ. What do you think?

Keach did say, if I can take the 1689 CoF as Keach's statement of faith, concerning the former:

"Those whom God hath predestined unto life, He is pleased in His appointed and accepted time, effectually to call, by His Word and Spirit, out of that state of sin and death in which they are by nature, to grace and salvation by Jesus Christ."

And concerning the latter:
"The grace of faith, whereby the elect are enabled to believe to the saving of their souls, is the work of the Spirit of Christ in their hearts, and is ordinarily wrought by the ministry of the Word."

The former is the work of bringing an elect OUT OF the state of sin and death INTO that of grace and salvation.
The latter is the work of bringing a child of God (i.e. already justified, regenerated and adopted) IN gospel ignorance to experientially know the word of truth, the gospel of his salvation by free grace.

[One question: what does 'saving of their souls' mean?]

I take it that faith can only be worked in one who already has life. Can't work faith in one who is still in the state of sin and death. The RBs will despise this as rotten human logic! They do like the 'blessed inconsistencies' trench better. Probably they will now charge me for making false distinctions to get away with my heresy. I think confusing the two will end up portraying Keach as a self-contradicting man. I think Keach must be quite a logical man too - I heard he was successful in his business.

Just some simple thoughts,
sing


Message 56
Date: Fri, 29 Dec 2006 15:53:07 +0800

Dear Pastor Lau,
I received this email from Dr Choo. It is lengthy and I have no inclination to read all of it. However the reference to Paul made me decide to forward it to you. Although I understand the reason for SDC changing over to KJV, I trust it is not for the same reasons as Chuck's group!

May the Lord's blessing be upon you and your family for the year ahead.
Tom

(The long article by Dr Choo deleted here.)


Message 57
Date: Fri, 29 Dec 2006 17:45:06 +0800

Brother Tom,

Thanks for your post. I read the few lines written by you and deleted the rest. If I understand Dr Choo correctly from his pestering posts in the past, he believes in regeneration that is conditioned upon using the right translation of the Bible, i.e. no KJV, no regeneration, no salvation. I have proof of this in my email archive.

Put simply, that is just another heresy... no more serious than the baptismal regeneration of the RCs or the gospel/faith regeneration of the RBs or the decisional regeneration of the others. They are all in the same category.

Dr Choo once said (shortly after the passing away of LFJ) that the late Pastor LFJ is probably in hell because when he died he was not using the KJV!!! Choo's hobbyhorse was already beaten to death then! It is funny that such an intelligent man does not see that the KJV came to the scene 15 century TOO LATE! I think he is now trying to serve you with some of the same rotten horsemeat. May the Lord have mercy upon such deluded folks, and keeps us from such similar delusions of the devil.

Even God's children have that perverse propensity to pervert the free grace of God.... Very few are content to embrace the grace of God as pure and free. They must add something of their own into the equation of eternal salvation by grace: whether it is their baptism, or their hearing the gospel or their faith or their decision, or their perseverance, etc...

Are you still convinced that Keach, a particular Baptist, taught that someone dead in sin must believe IN ORDER to have eternal life? I don't know how on earth you have come to a DEAD end road like that. I am truly puzzled!

I am glad that our eternal salvation is by God's pure and free grace... not conditional upon anything in man in any sense. Our temporal salvation in this life here - deliverance from ignorance and unrighteousness, etc - is through our own obedience as God's children, working out our salvation with fear and trembling by the grace of God.

If you wish to know why SDC switched to KJT, I would be glad to tell IEC so. There is no need to speculate. Your trust is appreciated.

May our Lord bless you and all in IEC richly in the year ahead.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 58
Date: Tue, 02 Jan 2007 14:56:58 +0800

Dear Pastor Lau,

I'm rather surprised at your calling the standard reformed doctrine (and myself, by association) a 'heresy'. :-[ Surely that would be out of character and a swinging to the extreme.

Yes, I've done a bit more reading of Keach and others. There are no reasons to believe that Keach holds to an Actual Justification before faith. This is what he wrote in a sermon: “That justification is an absolute act of God’s most sovereign grace, whereby he imputeth the complete and perfect righteousness of Jesus Christ to a _believing_ sinner, though ungodly in himself, absolving him from all his sins, and accepting him as righteous in Christ.”

Keach believed that The imputation of Christ righteousness is to a "believing" sinner. Similar doctrines are held by Francis Turretin, James Buchanan. Although I have not the privilege of reading Owen and Goodwin on this, I will not be surprised that both these men are of the same sentiments as Keach, Turretin and Buchanan. This is the doctrine of the particular baptists
of the 1689. The evidence is quite clear.

The doctrine of justification before faith is an error. Attributing that doctrine to the early Particular Baptist is not faithful to history. If you are not tired at looking at evidence I'll copy you more when I come across them.

Hopefully having considered me a heretic will not prejudiced you against truth presented. Perhaps you may be convinced to change your mind. ;-)

I still remain,
A brother in the Lord
Tom


Message 59
Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 00:15:28 +0800

Brother Tom,

Thanks for your reply.

I didn't say you are a heretic. I did point out a serious error and call it a heresy, and stated some errors in the same category. There is no need to put words in my mouth. Get rid of the hair ticks if they are troubling you.

I do consider the teaching that a correct translation of the Bible is necessary for regeneration as a heresy... so is the teaching that believing is necessary for ACTUAL justification or regeneration. These errors are in the same category - eternal salvation is by God's free grace PLUS something.

I have a very simple proposition: regeneration MUST precede believing... and ACTUAL/PERSONAL justification must precede regeneration... without ACTUAL/PERSONAL removal of ACTUAL/PERSONAL condemnation of death upon an elect in ACTUAL/PERSONAL justification by the Father, there could be no warrant for the Spirit to regenerate an elect who is still in the state of ACTUAL/PERSONAL condemnation of death.

1689.11.4says: “God did from all eternity decree to justify all the elect, (11) and Christ did in the fullness of time die for their sins, and rise again for their justification;(12) nevertheless, they are not justified PERSONALLY, until the Holy Spirit doth in time due ACTUALLY apply Christ unto them.(13)”

My observations: three aspects of justification are stated above:
1. DECRETAL justification from eternity by God
2. LEGAL justification by Christ's death and resurrection.
3. ACTUAL/PERSONAL justification when Christ is actually applied to them personally by the Holy Spirit.

The other two biblical aspects not mentioned here but elsewhere are:
4. DECLARATIVE/EVIDENTIAL justification by faith is ordinarily wrought by the ministry of the Word. (1689.11.2)
5. FINAL justification by Christ at the resurrection to eternal glory.

My questions concerning 1689.11.4
1. What is the spiritual state of the elect UNTIL "the Holy Spirit doth in time due actually apply Christ unto them?"
2. UNTIL Christ is applied to them personally by the sovereign and gracious work of the Holy Spirit, is there spiritual life in the elect?
3. UNTIL Christ is applied to them personally, i.e. UNTIL they are actually/personally justified, is there ability to believe?
4. WHEN Christ is applied to them personally, i.e. WHEN they are personally/actually justified, what change occurs in their spiritual state?
5. Is actual/personal justification by your faith or by God's free grace while the elect is in the state of sin and death?

Please consider these simple questions.

With ACTUAL justification at effectual call to grace and salvation, an elect in sin and death is regenerated and adopted - thus enabled to believe. This makes the next aspect of justification - i.e. declarative justification by faith - possible. Not all elect will experience declarative justification by faith. 1689.10.3

All elect will experience Final justification - on the great judgment day.

You quoted Keach: “That justification is an absolute act of God’s most sovereign grace, whereby he imputeth the complete and perfect righteousness of Jesus Christ to a _believing_ sinner, though ungodly in himself, absolving him from all his sins, and accepting him as righteous in Christ.”

Scriptures says: "God justifies the ungodly", and this "freely by His grace."
Please find out the spiritual state of the ungodly. Try reading Psalm 1.
The ungodly can't meet the condition of faith... actual justification has to be freely by God's grace. Declarative justification is by/through faith.

Scriptures says: "The just shall live by faith." Who shall live by faith?
It is not the ungodly who shall live by faith and are justified by God. That's a lie.

Justification took place when the sinner is in the state of ungodliness.

You said, “Keach believed that the imputation of Christ righteousness is to a "believing" sinner.”

I believe it is very simple to understand Keach words: a believing sinner gives evidence or make manifest by his believing that he has been imputed with Christ's righteousness by God’s most sovereign grace when he was an UNGODLY state. His believing is evidence of his justified state while ungodly - "the just shall live by faith." A 'believing sinner' is a sinner that has been regenerated, Christ's righteousness has been applied to Him by God's act of sovereign grace.

[You are in effect saying that Keach believed that a man under the just condemnation of death (i.e. an unjustified man) can believe in order to have that condemnation of death removed, in order to be justified. You are also in effect saying that a man under the just condemnation of death (i.e. an unjustified man) is spiritually alive and can believe in order to be justified by God. Think about it.]

Sorry for repeating the same old stuff.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 60
Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 02:09:02 +0800

Brother Tom,

You said, “Similar doctrines are held by Francis Turretin, James Buchanan. Although I have not the privilege of reading Owen and Goodwin on this, I will not be surprised that both these men are of the same sentiments as Keach, Turretin and Buchanan. This is the doctrine of the particular baptists of the 1689. The evidence is quite clear.”

I have not read anything by Turretin. I have read some of James Buchanan.

Here are few lines from his magnum opus - 'Justification' - Lecture VIII, Proposition II, Paragraph 1 and 2. [All emphasis original.] .
--------
“Proposition 2. While "Justification" is a forensic or judicial term, it is used in Scripture to denote, sometimes the acceptance of a sinner as righteous in the sight of God, sometimes the manifestation or proof of his acceptance, by which it is attested and made sure; and this variety in the application of it is the ground of an important theological distinction:– the distinction between ACTUAL and DECLARATIVE Justification.

This distinction does not imply, either that there is more than one Justification before God, as Romish writers have alleged, or that the sense of the term is ambiguous; for that term relates invariably to one and the same Justification, when it denotes a change in man’s relation to God. But this change may be considered in two distinct aspects:– either as being actually accomplished when he is accepted as righteous, or as being declared and attested, so as to give him the comfortable assurance of it. And the same term may be applied to it in each of these aspects, without making its meaning ambiguous, since the context will enable us to determine in which of the two it is contemplated by the sacred writer. The Protestant doctrine affirms that a sinner is made or constituted righteous by having Christ’s righteousness imputed to him; and that, being thus justified actually, he is also justified declaratively, when his acceptance is proved or attested [by faith, sing], so as to be made manifest to his own conscience, or to his fellow-men. In both cases it is one and the same Justification that is spoken of:– his acceptance as righteous in the sight of God; but in the one it is considered simply as a fact, in the other as a fact that is attested and proved [by faith, sing]. Actual Justification comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative; and hence, if any one is declared to have been justified, we conclude that he was actually justified, or accepted as righteous in the sight of God.”
---------
My comments:
Actual justification is by God's free grace when you were dead in sin... when Christ was applied to you personally by the sovereign and gracious work of the Spirit [when there is no possibility of your exercising faith.]
Declarative justification is by your faith in Christ when you are a child of God [regenerated.]

Actual justification by God's free grace comes first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative by your faith.
Actual justification by God's free grace is declared and attested by faith in Christ.
I just don't want you to misrepresent James Buchanan. If I am mistaken, I ask for your forgiveness.

John Gill marshaled Owen and Goodwin not a little in his chapters on Justification. Check it out in his Body of Divinity - book 2 chapter 5, book 6 chapter 8. If anyone know where Owen and Goodwin stood, John Gill is the man. They unanimously see actual justification by God's free grace, in distinction to declarative justification by believer's faith. To them, believer's faith IS ALWAYS declarative and attesting in nature.

Your breath declares and attests to your possession of life! That is surely simple enough to comprehend.

I am only repeating what I have written before... but you take no notice.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing

Monday, January 28, 2008

A Visit to Justification Town - 2d

Message 41
Date: Sat, 02 Dec 2006 18:27:04 +0800

Brother Tom,

Dismissing you is never my intention. Stopping the discussion is... because we are going in circles.

I have nothing left to say except that when Declarative justification is mistaken for and confused with Actual justification, then so much become contradictory, inconsistent and deficient. When each is seen in its proper biblical place, things are consistent and harmonious.

That statement on John Murray being one of new school men is made by a reformed presby... Berkhof is included...

Those famous words you quoted where the term 'actual justification' is used, you have to ascertain whether they are used in the ‘technical’ sense you are using it. Owen used the term like 'absolute justification,' 'first justification,' and 'continual justification.' Beeke uses terms like decretal, legal, actual/vital and practical, and final... Some uses 'actual' to mean experientially, personally actually become aware of it through faith. [Actually (or really) experiencing the justification is certainly not the same as the Actual/Personal justification at effectual calling.]

You said:
You seem to want to view Scripture (on this issue) with an a priori assumption- i.e. if there is faith, then there is no more grace.

I don't know if there is anything a priori about this view: since Actual/Personal justification is by grace, and faith is a grace worked by the Spirit in a vitally justified person, then faith, being the PRODUCT, is the instrument to manifest or evidence that free grace justification, faith is the instrument to Declare the justification (Vital/Actual) that has taken place. I say, when there is faith, there is evidence of God's glorious grace. Kindly represent me correctly. They must be put in their proper and biblical place.

Tom: I am merely interested to find out what the Particular Baptists of 1689 thought on this issue- i.e. what the confession meant. The words from Keach, Kiffen and Knolly seem to provide a clear exposition of what chapter 11 of the 1689 really says.

I am also interested in what the framers of the Confession say. With the same document, we are at loggerhead. I genuinely wish someone would show me the inconsistencies and contradictions and deficiencies in my understanding of the Confession. I have honestly endeavored to point out the many inconsistencies and contradictions and deficiencies of your understanding of the Confession, but you don't seem to want to deal with them.

[What do you say about the difference between your 3 statements and 4 statements compared to the Confession of Faith? Do you agree with them?]

That's why I feel that it is of no benefit to continue the discussion. I am glad your mind is made up and is pretty convinced about your position.
Thanks. I will close with two short paragraphs from Lloyd-Jones below my signature, brought to my attention by L-J admirer, a staunch RB.)

sing
"And some believed the things which were spoken,
and some believed not" Acts 28:24
---------

Writing about the application [sic] of redemption, he said these:
"Now, let me, therefore, suggest to you certain possible orders. I shall not keep of necessity to any one of them, but if you look at it from the logical and objective stand point you might very well take them like this. You might say that the first and the fundamental thing is union with Christ, that we are ultimately saved by union with Christ, so you start with that. Then, because of that you put justification next, and then, because of that, you follow with regeneration. Out of that comes faith, and out of that adoption. Then you can put conversion, which includes repentance and a turning away, and a believing, and a believing, then sanctification, and then perseverance."

"If, on the other hand, you are more anxious to stress the subjective element [experiential aspect? sing] and still try to keep some theological order, you might put it like this: You might start with what is called 'effectual calling', that which makes the offer, the call, effectual in men and women. This is the first thing. Then you could go on to regeneration, and then to faith, followed by justification, then union with Christ, then repentance and conversion, then adoption, then sanctification, and then perseverance." Great Doctrine Series, Vol 2, pg.

He speaks of a justification before regeneration and faith in the first paragraph. In the next paragraph on the same page, he speaks of a justification that follows faith - what we identify as 'Declarative justification' (using your preferred terminology) - faith declaring the justified state. The justification that precedes both regeneration and faith is what I identify as Actual justification (using your preferred terminology.)

On this point I am agree with Lloyd-Jones. I heard that he was an undisputed scholar on the Puritans in the 20th century.


Message 42
Date: Sun, 03 Dec 2006 00:26:06 +0800

Brother Tom,

You quoted from Watson:
Q. Are we justified from eternity?*
A. No: for,
(1.) By nature we are under a sentence of condemnation. John 3:18. We could never have been condemned, if we were justified from eternity.
(2.) The Scripture confines justification to those who believe and repent. ‘Repent, that your sins may be blotted out.’ Acts 3:19. Therefore their sins were un-cancelled, and their persons unjustified, till they did repent. Though God does not justify us for our repentance, yet not without.

[The question was asked because men like Watson was accused of believing Actual Justification from eternity because they believe in Actual Justification in time, but before and without faith.] Please bear this basic fact in mind.

Just one more attempt to see whether you would deal with plain inconsistencies and contradictions of your interpretation of Watson. Are you inconsistent or was Watson inconsistent? I agree with both statements in the answer above.

As an aside: incidentally Gill did too. RBs ignorantly accuse Gill of believing in justification from eternity. Concerning the charge of justification from eternity, he replied, quoting Owen's reply to Baxter ( Baxter charged Owen for holding to eternal justification) as his own reply to similar charge:
"I neither am, nor ever was of that judgment; though as it may be explained, I know better, wiser, and more learned men than myself, [and he might have added, than Mr. Baxter, sing] that have been, and are." [all emphasis original.] - Body of Divinity, Bk 2, Chapter 5, last few lines before chapter 6.

> (2.) The Scripture confines justification to those who believe and repent. ‘Repent, that your sins may be blotted out.’ Acts 3:19. Therefore their sins were un-cancelled, and their persons unjustified, till they did repent. Though God does not justify us for our repentance, yet not without.

Now let's assume that Watson meant that the Scriptures confines ACTUAL justification to those who believe and repent - as you would insist that he did.
- Therefore, without believing and repenting, their sin will not be ACTUALLY blotted out.
- Therefore, their sins were ACTUALLY not forgiven or cancelled, till they did repent.
- Therefore, their person is unjustified, still under 'ACTUAL condemnation' till they repent.
- Therefore, without repentance, there is no ACTUAL justification, they remain under condemnation.

Watson subscribed to the WCF. And WCF.10.3 declares this:
"Elect infants, dying in infancy, are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit, who worketh when, and where, and how he pleaseth. So also are all other elect persons, who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word."

Whatever you may think this paragraph is saying, I think you and I are agreed that these are elect - two broad categories mentioned, infant dying in infancy, and all other elect person - who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the Word. Being incapable of outwardly called by the ministry of the word (but effectually called to grace and salvation by God) - these would express NO faith or repentance.

According to your interpretation of Watson, these elect (mentioned in paragraph 3)
- their sins remain ACTUALLY uncancelled and unforgiven;
- their persons remains ACTUALLY unjustified; still under condemnation;
- therefore they remain in their ACTUAL condemnation, deserving of eternal wrath.
- these elect remain in their ACTUAL condemnation of death, YET is regenerated!
Would you want to make Watson to say something like that?

These elect mentioned in paragraph 3, they are ALL justified [vital/personal/actual] by grace at their effectual call at God's appointed and accepted time, among all those mentioned in 1689.10.1 and 11.1. For that reason they are regenerated - for without the imputation of the righteousness of life (ACTUAL justification) there can be no regeneration or giving of life. These elect in paragraph 3, having no faith or repentance experience no DECLARATIVE justification.

Now, assume that Watson meant that the Scriptures confines DECLARATIVE justification to those who believe and repent - as I have endeavoured to show you, then Watson is not made to appear so illogical and inconsistent and self-contradicting.
Seen in that light:
- Therefore, without believing and repenting, they do not experience sins forgiven.
- Therefore, their sins remain uncancelled experientially, till they did repent.
- Therefore, their person is unjustified experientially till they repent.
- Therefore, without repentance, there is no experiential/declarative justification.

Between an interpretation that produces inconsistency and contradiction, and one that is harmonious, I would invariably choose the latter. You seem to want to choose the former despite I endeavouring to show the consequences, and yet would not want to deal with the consequences. I am a bit lost by such approach.

You said:
Tom: Watson was alluding to Actual Justification all the way. It would not make sense for him to argue for Declarative Justification in the reference to Justification from eternity.

It makes perfect sense for Watson to speak of DECLARATIVE justification in reference to justification from eternity. Watson speaks of justification in time... in the SUBJECTIVE experience of an elect. ACTUAL justification is also justification in time, but that DOES NOT involve any act on the part of the elect... read 1689.11.1 carefully, and with some honesty. A believer's act of receiving is the experiential justification, the EFFECT of the Objective/Vital/Actual justification... faith being the instrument to declare the Vital/Personal justification by God's free grace.

Brother, please think about it... confusing 'actual' and 'declarative' do have unpleasant consequences.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 42a
From: "David Scarbrough"
Date: Mon, 4 Dec 2006 10:41:15 -0600

It seems to me that many today are confused over the issues of the Actual verses the Declarative aspects of salvation. Especially when they try to break apart salvation into its individual parts.

However, John Calvin, John Knox, Miles Coverdale and the other reformers who penned the Geneva Bible marginal notes had a clear understanding of the 'Actual' and 'Declarative' aspects of salvation. The note on John 6:37 states:

"The gift of faith proceeds from the free election of the Father in Christ, after which everlasting life necessarily follows: therefore faith in Christ Jesus is a sure witness of our election, and therefore of our glorification, which is to come."

In other words, our faith is a "sure witness", a testimony of our election and of everything that follows it; everything from election to glorification - the complete salvation process. They are declarative, not causative. They declare our salvation, to ourselves and others, but they do not cause it. God is the cause, the actual cause, without which we could not be saved. The same is true of repentance. It is a testimony of our election and of everything that follows it. True forgiveness can only be granted by God, the repentance is simply our acknowledgement of that forgiveness.

If we are elect, the rest is SURE to follow regardless of our declaration.

-DS (ReformedBaptist list)


Message 43
Date: Sun, 03 Dec 2006 16:37:10 +0800

Brother Tom,

You have hardly spoken too much.
However, you might have spoken boldly, a wee bit too quickly.

A simple solution will answer to all that you have written below: Let's go back to basics:

Read again, please, slowly.
1. Those whom God effectually calleth, He also freely justifieth,(1) not by infusing righteousness into them, but by pardoning their sins, and by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous;(2) not for anything wrought in them, or done by them, but for Christ's sake alone;(3) not by imputing faith itself, the act of believing, or any other evangelical obedience to them, as their righteousness; but by imputing Christ's active obedience unto the whole law, and passive obedience in His death for their whole and sole righteousness,(4) they receiving and resting on Him and His righteousness by faith, which faith they have not of themselves; it is the gift of God.(5) - 1689.10.1

Did you skip the above? If you didn't, please read it again in any case.

There is the ACTUAL justification that is APART from 'anything wrought in them, or done by them.' Faith is a grace wrought in them, and believing is an act done by them. Actual justification is FOR Christ's sake alone - it is not for Christ's sake alone PLUS your faith in Him sake. ACTUAL justification is by God's free grace; it is not by God's free grace PLUS your faith in Christ.

In addition to what I have said in relation to Watson, please note very carefully that this ACTUAL justification is true of every elect effectually called to grace and salvation. This ACTUAL justification is APART from faith, and embraces EVEN THOSE who are INCAPABLE of manifesting faith (1689.10.3)

Is that simple enough?

Do these make sense to you?

Have I not simply stated what the Confession says?

There is the DECLARATIVE justification that is by your faith. Faith is the instrument to declare your ACTUAL justification. Your act of receiving and resting in Christ and His righteousness declares your prior ACTUAL justification by God's free grace.

Is that simple enough?

Tom: Q. Whether Believers were not actually reconciled to God, actually justified and adopted when Christ died?/
A. That the Reconciliation, Justification, and Adoption of Believers are infallibly secured by the gracious purpose of God, and merit of Jesus Christ. Yet none can be said to be actually reconciled, justified, or adopted, until they are really implanted into Jesus Christ by Faith; and so by virtue of this their Union with him, have these Fundamental Benefits actually conveyed unto them. And this we conceive is fully evidenced, because the Scripture attributes all these Benefits Faith, as the instrumental cause of them. Rom 3.25, 5.11,5.1.; Gal 3.26. And gives such Representation of the state of the Elect before Faith as is altogether inconsistent with an actual Right in them, Eph 2.1,2,3-12.

Let me state that I perfectly agree with the above, as you do. With the same words, you and I make them say vastly different thing. Isn't that incredible?

The word 'actually' does appear in the answer above. The context shows us that the authors are obviously speaking of actually (as in 'really' experiencing the benefits of salvation - i.e. the experiential aspect. "And this we conceive is fully evidenced, because the Scripture attributes all these Benefits to Faith, as the instrumental cause of them." [They are hardly speaking of the Actual Justification the Confession speaks of.]

O yes, it is fully evidence, is it not? What God has done by His free grace, apart from 'anything wrought in them, or done by them,' CAN ONLY BE EXPERIENCED by their faith in Christ! Actually/really experiencing reconciliation, justification and adoption is by faith in Christ. There is no other way to experience it.

- Virtual reconciliation, justification and adoption is at the cross.
- Actual (adjective) (Vital, Personal, Applied) reconciliation, justification and adoption is at effectual calling apart from faith... This is true of EACH and EVERY elect.
- Actually (adverb) Experiencing reconciliation, justification and adoption is indeed BY FAITH... Amen and Amen and Amen. This is true of each elect that has faith through the ministry of the word.

That's what these Particular Baptist authors are saying... in perfect conformity to the Scriptures, and summarised in the Confession. [You read them to say something else – because you have a different definition of ‘Actual Justification. The Declarative Justification by faith has disappeared from you scheme!!!]

Rightly distinguishing Declarative justification from Actual justification [as defined by the Framers wrote in the Confession] would go a long way in rightly understanding the early Particular Baptists.

May our Lord give light to us to see the truth.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 44
Date: Sun, 03 Dec 2006 17:28:25 +0800

Dear Pastor Lau

I've only dared to be bold where I think the PB statements were clear ;-]} If I may be a wee bit bold again to suggest that you have to interpret the statements that way because of an a priori assumption that faith is work.

The 1689 people said this:
Moreover he and we with him, distinguish, or explain Union with Christ, and Justification thus;
1. That all the Chosen of God are decretively justified, &c. from Eternity
2. Virtually at the Death, or rather at the resurrection of our blessed Saviour.
3. Yet that no Adult Elect Person is really and Actually in Union with Christ, and Actually Justified before he doth Believe in him: And so is transplanted out of the first Adam as a common Head, and implanted into the second Adam: It being impossible any should stand in (or grow out of) two common roots at one and the same time; since all (as considered Actually in the Second are made Alive and brought into Justification, and declared free for ever from Condemnation, Rom 8.1. If any man have not the Spirit of Christ, the same is none of his. That is Actually his, tho' many of them may be in the Election of Grace.

My opinion is that the Particular Baptists of 1689 hardly make much about Declarative Justification. The 3 statements above, especially statement no.3 is quite clear. Actual Justification is by faith, Union with Christ is by faith.

The paragraph 10.3 "Elect infants, dying in infancy, are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit, who worketh when, and where, and how he pleaseth. So also are all other elect persons, who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word." is inserted to point out precise that- that this is an exception to the norm. If we were to look at your way of interpreting the confession on this- para 10.3 will be redundant- why put it there when everyone is Actually justified and saved without faith.

No adult elect person is really and actually in union with Christ before faith (10.3 then spells out the exception i.e. infants)
No adult elect person is actually justified before he doth believe (don't tell me this is declarative justification because it is in the same statement as being in union with Christ).

Before I read this Narrative by Keach, Kiffin and Knolly, i would agree that you can interpret all the justification statements in the BCF and prefixed it with Actual or Declarative based on one's own a priori assumption. But this is certainly as clear as I have seen it.

Sorry for being so 'bold' but it's unmistakable to me, in plain English. There may be some difficult issues to reconcile- I would agree. But at least I know the PB meant what they say in the BCF.(having difficult issues that is hard to reconcile is not new. You can easily argue your way to a unitarian position but having an a priori assumption that God is One and leave no room for the Trinity because you just can't reconcile it logically. Same as saving faith. Now that I have Keach in front of me allow me to quote: rom his exposition of the parables p.174
"Such who receive this sacred pearl by faith, though they were dead, it immediately quickens them; and raiseth them from the dead to a state of spiritual life."In answering an objection "Obj. But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?" "Ans. Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic"

Unless you want to interpret eternal life is a conscious appreciation of eternal life- assurance of salvation- Keach is quite consistent.

Please reconsider your interpretation. Following the Particular Baptist is an eye-opener, and a reassurance for me.

a undeserved servant,
Tom


Message 45
Date: Mon, 04 Dec 2006 11:50:28 +0800

Brother Tom,

See some comments marked ## in your post.
Let me know when it is become wearisome to read my thoughts. I am learning as I read from your posts. It shows me where the difficulty lies.

Tom:I've only dared to be bold where I think the PB statements were clear ;-]} If I may be a wee bit bold again to suggest that you have to interpret the statements that way because of an a priori assumption that faith is work.

## Clear statements can so easily be misread by many - e.g. 'whoever believes has eternal life' is commonly misread as a conditional statement of offer, instead of a declarative statement of fact. In your case, Declarative/experiential justification is automatically read as Actual/personal justification.

I fear your boldness may be misplaced. Nothing a priori and no assumption - just wanting to be consistent with Scriptures.

You would agree that faith is a spiritual activity of a man that has eternal life - is this an a priori assumption or a statement of truth? Some RBs, Ho Eng Ghee, insist on spiritual ability without eternal life. Faith IS the activity of a man that HAS BEEN imputed with the righteousness of life (justified vitally, actually, personally) and regenerated. Is that a statement of truth or an assumption?

You may want to deny that faith - man's act of believing and resting in Christ - is an activity by and of the effectually called elect. Perhaps you also disagree with the PB statement that faith is a grace wrought in the elect - "The grace of faith... is the work of the Spirit of Christ in their hearts." 1689.14.1. You may also disagree with the Framers who declared that the justification of the elect is "not for anything wrought in them, or done by them." Faith is most certainly something wrought in them, and believing is also most certainly something done by them.

> Moreover he and we with him, distinguish, or explain Union with Christ, and Justification thus… ... not the Spirit of Christ, the same is none of his. That is Actually his, tho' many of them may be in the Election of Grace.

## I would appreciate if you can tell me where the above quotes are taken from. Do me this kind favour.

I read the same thing, and I do agree with what they say. The word 'really' and 'actually' has reference to the experiential sense in conversion. Making alive and brought into Justification (Actual) obviously refers to the effectual call (1689.10.1) and the third aspect mentioned in 1689.11.4, and this reality by God's free grace is declared and manifest by faith. Therefore NO elect - adult or not - actually and really experience his Actual Justification by God's free grace while ungodly and in a state of sin and death.

Tom: My opinion is that the Particular Baptists of 1689 hardly make much about Declarative Justification. The 3 statements above, especially statement no.3 is quite clear. Actual Justification is by faith, Union with Christ is by faith.

That you have such opinion is probably because you are misled [and confused] by the sight and sound of the word 'actually' (and not the 'sense' of the word in context) and conclude therefore that they are speaking of the 'Actual Justification' that you have in your mind and which you have defined. You see 'Actual Justification' (your definition) when they are in fact speaking of really (actually) justified DECRETIVELY by faith. You see 'ACTUAL union' with Christ at effectual call to grace and salvation when they are in fact speaking of the union with Christ declared and experienced by faith at conversion.

Faith which receives and rests in Christ is the only instrument to experience and declare and make manifest the virtual/legal and 'vital/actual union (to use your terminology) that have taken place by free grace at effectual call to grace and salvation. The Confession states plainly enough that personal/applied justification is by God's free grace.

Faith as an instrument declares the justified (personal) state by free grace.

The Particular Baptists are speaking so much about declarative justification by faith, and declarative union by faith... but you insist in seeing than as your 'Actual Justification' by faith and 'Actual Union' by faith.

Buchanan put it this way, "Actual Justification come first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative." (pg 234). "Their ACTUAL Justification is presupposed, but their DECLARATIVE Justification is specially referred to." (pg 235, all emphasis original.) Buchanan uses 'actual' and 'declarative' (uppercase) in the strict technical sense, not with the general sense of 'really' or 'actually experienced.'

I suggest that you read James Buchanan's work on Justification - just Lecture VIII, Proposition 2 - a section that deals specifically the technical distinctions between Actual justification and Declarative justification. You may want to redefine you definition of 'Actual justification.'

He said, "... it is the ground of an important theological distinction, - the distinction between ACTUAL and DECLARATIVE Justification" end of first paragraph. Read the rest, and have a firm grasp ... and you would begin to read the Particular Baptists in a proper light.

Reading the same thing does not guarantee we will understand them the same way. The root cause: Your ACTUAL justification is by faith, and DECLARATIVE justification is by faith and works; mine is by grace alone, and declared by faith and works, respectively.

It is like having a presupposition that reads 'whoever believes has eternal life' as a conditional statement of offer, instead of a declarative statement of fact.

I hope I am not wearying you.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 46
Date: Tue, 05 Dec 2006 10:13:55 +0800

Brother Tom,

Take time to read and you may learn something. Feel free to express your disagreement.

> The paragraph 10.3 "Elect infants, dying in infancy, are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit, who worketh when, and where, and how he pleaseth. So also are all other elect persons, who are incapable of being outwardly called by the ministry of the word." is inserted to point out precisely that- that this is an exception to the norm. If we were to look at your way of interpreting the confession on this- para 10.3 will be redundant- why put it there when everyone is Actually justified and saved without faith.

I believe the relationship of the four paragraphs of 1689.10 is quite simple and plain. You may want to dispute it too. I am puzzle that RBs don't see its simplicity, but are so confused.

Para 1: describes the effectual calling of ALL the elect. Each and everyone of the elect are effectually called to eternal life in exactly the same manner at God’s appointed and accepted time – i.e. ACTUALLY justified, regenerated and adopted - when in the state of sin and death.
Para 2: describes all those effectually called elect in Para 1 who DO receive the outward gospel call and DO experience Declarative Justification by faith.
Para 3: describes all those effectually called elect in Para 1 who DO NOT have the outward gospel call, and therefore DON'T experience Declarative Justification by faith.

Does this way of looking at 1689.10.3 make it redundant? Did you understand my interpretation of 1689.10.3? Every one is effectually called to grace and salvation without faith; yes Actually Justified without faith, BUT not every one of them will experience Declarative Justification by faith. Please DON'T misrepresent me.

This paragraph is to anticipated the popular errors, among new school Baptists (e.g. RBs), that NONE but only those who experience DECLARATIVE justification by faith are eternally saved, that there is NO elect among all those who do not have the gospel call, that all who are in heaven have heard and believed the gospel on earth, that eternal salvation is conditioned upon declarative justification through faith. The paragraph is NOT expressing an exception - the idea of an exception arises from an a priori assumption - learning to use your favourite term - that there are different ways of effectual callings and different ways of justification.

Para 4: describes all those not in Para 1, i.e., those who are not predestinated to eternal life, but are reached with the outward gospel call.

It is a serious and popular error to think of Para 3 as an exception. If it is an exception, then what is the norm? Is effectual call to grace and salvation BY faith the norm, and the effectual call to grace and salvation WITHOUT faith the exception? But Para 1 speaks of ALL elect without exception.

Is Actual Justification BY faith the norm (if there is such thing as your idea of Actual Justification by faith to begin with!)? And what is the exception - is it Actual Justification WITHOUT faith, or is it that there is no Actual Justification for these since they are incapable of faith? If you choose the former, then you have plainly contradicted Para 1 because Para 1 speaks of ALL elect without exception.

The simple truth is: All elect are effectually called and these SAME elect that are effectually called are ALSO Actually Justified without faith. [meaning personally imputed with the righteousness of Christ at effectual call out of sin and death, as distinct from the declarative/evidential justification by faith at conversion] the same way

I believe Para 3 is stating simply that some effectually called elect - i.e. Actually Justified, regenerated and adopted - DO NOT experience DECLARATIVE justification because by providence, they are incapable of faith and repentance.

Someone said, "if a scheme of salvation need exceptions for some, then it is very likely humanistic." Rightly divided, the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation needs no exception. Human schemes do, divine scheme needs no exception.

May the Lord bless you to see the light.

sing


Message 47
Date: Tue, 05 Dec 2006 12:43:25 +0800

Brother Tom,

I saw this paragraph as a post/script in one of your post.

> Honestly I'm not sure what to make of Gill. Neither do a number of people more 'intelligent' than I. I've read some chapters of his body of divinity and commentary- to great benefit. Yes I would agree that he would hint at faith making manifest of our justification in our conscience in several place but no statement to counteract the above.

It is not a matter of intelligence. The difficulty is more likely by one's theological presuppositions. If it were intelligent, you have plenty of it.

May be these few lines will clear your mind:

"Justification, as a transient act, and declarative, follows vocation; but as an immanent act of God, it goes before it, of which we are only speaking, as ought always to be remembered." Last sentence of 2b7d.

Vocation here is certainly calling to life, i.e. regeneration.
Declarative Justification - a transient act - FOLLOWS vocation.
Actual Justification - an immanent act - PRECEDES regeneration.

There is Actual Justification by grace (i.e. the third aspect mentioned in 1689.11.4) before regeneration. Righteousness of life is applied before the bestowal of life, before there is any possibility of faith. This is as plain as noonday sun - I think. [Only one’s theological presupposition will cause mental block.]

There is Declarative Justification by faith after vocation to life, when the grace of faith is called forth by the ministry of the word.

This paragraph 2b7e, following the sentence above, elaborate it pretty plainly, I would think. Take a careful read and see what you think.

"It is affirmed, that those various passages of scripture, where we are said to be justified through faith, and by fairly, have no other tendency than to show that faith is something prerequisite to justification, which cannot be said if justification was from eternity. To which the answer is, that those scriptures which speak of justification, through and by faith, do not militate against, nor disprove justification before faith; for though justification by and before faith differ, yet they are not opposite and contradictory. They differ, the one being an immanent act in God; all which sort of acts are eternal, and so before faith; the other being a transient declarative act, terminating on the conscience of the believer; and so is by and through faith, and follows it. But then these do not contradict each other, the one being a declaration and manifestation of the other. What scriptures may be thought to speak of faith, as a prerequisite to justification, cannot be understood as speaking of it as a prerequisite to the being of justification; for faith has no causal influence upon it, it adds nothing to its being, it is no ingredient in it, it is not the cause nor matter of it; at most, they can only be understood as speaking of faith as a prerequisite to the knowledge and comfort of it, and to a claim of interest in it; and this is readily allowed, that no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes; that is, he cannot have the knowledge of it, nor any comfort from it; nor can he claim his interest in it, without faith; and this being observed, obviates another objection, that if justification is before faith, then faith is needless and useless. It is not so; it is not of use to justify men, which it is never said to do; but it is of use to receive the blessing of justification, and to enjoy the comfort of it.” [emphasis mine, sing]

Do remember that Gill was an independent Particular Baptist highly respected in his days by 'reformed' men (old school, of course) of different denominations.

By Christ's continuing mercies,
sing


Message 48 Date: Wed, 06 Dec 2006 10:15:06 +0800

Pastor Lau,
Thanks. Yes it is interesting (humanly speaking) how we interpret things based on an a priori set theology.

Let me try to reason some things out and see if there is agreement.

sing: See some comments. Take time to read... don't rush but please read them. I have given careful consideration to everything you have written... and reciprocate in kind. So, yes, I am saying that it is declarative justification by faith because it is in the same statement speaking of experiential union with Christ by faith.

So there is now a Real Justification and Real Union with Christ - that is also the same as Declarative Justification and Declarative Union with Christ. I am getting the impression that you are making up these definitions as we go along. The whole Narrative of the 1689 framers were talking about Actual Justification - bearing support for their brethren who has been accused by church members of being in error. No one in their right mind would leave their church and accuse their pastor of serious error over Declarative Justification before faith. At least no one in history has held this view before. If you interpret the statement to mean Declarative Justification, then the whole purpose of the Narrative is meaningless.

sing:You are so convinced by now, I am not sure if anything I am going to say is of any value to you. You read the word 'actually' being used in the writing of these great men, and you automatically equate them to Actual Justification you have in mind. May I suggest to you that you are somewhat mistaken. The context where the words 'actual' and 'actually' occur simply means real in the experiential sense, actually experiencing it. In that light, everything they say is perfectly true. Without faith, no one will actually/really experience their justified state by free grace.

Dear Pastor, I would have to say 'ditto' i.e. you are so convinced that faith - cannnot - have a place in Actual Justification even if the Lord has put it in Scripture because it just isn't logical to fallen human thinking. The RP seem to think otherwise. Please read my comment below on the Pearl of Great Price.

sing: What do you think Keach is saying here? How do you want to interpret him?
What is the 'it' that immediately quickens them, and raises them from the dead to a state of spiritual life? Faith? Sacred pearl?


Yes, it is Christ who quickens. That's what Keach is saying. Can you not also see in the whole sentence that "such who receive Christ by faith, though they were dead, Christ immediately quickens them; raiseth them from the dead to a state of spiritual life" ? I'm sorry if I can only interpret this so plainly. Those who receive Christ by faith - Christ immediately quickens them.......There is no way in any human language that this can be interpreted to mean - Declarative quickening, or coming to a knowledge of their quickened state .....just in case you are headed that direction ;-]} (icon means bearded man- sorry can't risk being cheeky!)

sing: I would appreciate if you could help me to understand what 'as a condition of connexion by way of order' mean.

The gospel requires faith as a condition of justification [Actual] and eternal life. Faith being there as part of God-ordained chain of events (that's why faith is a gift). Calling-faith-justification.

sing: I hope you DO NOT want to interpret Keach as saying that your faith is a condition to obtain your Actual Justification as well as Eternal life! Are you saying that Keach is consistent in teaching that faith is a condition to Eternal life as well as Actual Justification? Would you want to interpret Keach to teach that you must exercise faith in order to have eternal life - just as Ho and many others believe that. I do believe that Keach is saying consistently that faith is a condition to declare and experience the actual justification and eternal life, i.e. a condition to declare the possession of actual justification and eternal life by God's free and sovereign grace.

Keach has just answered your objection (it's almost prophetic of Keach) : "You say: But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?" Keach says: "Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic" Keach did not say a condition to - declare and experience - Actual Justification and eternal life.
Please read his words - plainly (without assumption). If he were to reply to the objection (remember it is an objection similar to yours: "don't tell me that faith is a condition of obtaining Actual Justification and eternal life") Hence his reply - yes it is a condition (in a sense) because it is there as part of a connected chain of events put in order by eternal decree- as one depend on another. Make sense?

Read Keach- you will be surprised. Can't comment much for Kiffin and Knolly because we have no access to their materials.

Tom


Message 49 Date: Wed, 06 Dec 2006 15:10:34 +0800

Brother Tom,

Thanks for your reply. See some comments marked ##.

>Tom: So there is now a Real Justification and Real Union with Christ- that is also the same as Declarative Justification and Declarative Union with Christ. I am getting the impression that you are making up these definitions as we go along. The whole Narrative of the 1689 framers were talking about Actual Justification - bearing support for their brethren who has been accused by church members of being in error. No one in their right mind would leave their church and accuse their pastor of serious error over Declarative Justification before faith. At least no one in history has held this view before. If you interpret the statement to mean Declarative Justification, then the whole purpose of the Narrative is meaningless.

I do think your first sentence above is a grave misunderstanding of what I have said. I was dealing with the confusion of the word 'actually' and 'really' with 'Actual Justification.' I am not inventing terms. I forgive you for your imagination.

All I have said is that 'actually and really justified' is used by the PB to mean the Declarative Justification by faith in the context of what they were saying. They were dealing with the false and perverse accusation of 'actually and really justified' from eternity because they believed in Decretal Justification. They replied that Declarative Justification is 'actually and really' experienced at the point of faith. They were not dealing with, or denying that Actual Justification is before faith. For before Actual Justification, there is NO POSSIBILITY of exercising faith in a state of sin and death.

The whole purpose of the Narrative is pointedly served in rebutting the perverse accusation.

Let me repeat something very plainly on the various aspects of Justification.
- There is Justification Decreed before time
- There is Justification Accomplished at the cross, all elect justified Legally.
- There is Justification Applied to individual personally when they are in the state of sin and death. (Faith is only possible when the righteousness of life has been applied, when the individual has been regenerated. A man under the condemnation of death is not capable of believing.)
- There is Justification Declared and Experienced by faith.
- There is Justification at Christ's Coming.

The first 3 aspects are stated clearly in 1689.11.4.
The fourth aspect is stated in 1689.11.2.

Where the difficulty lies is your intermingling and confusing the third and fourth aspects: You have defined Actual Justification (third aspect) and Declarative Justification (fourth aspect) thus: (your post dated Wed, 22 Nov 2006)

> 2. We are actually justified by saving faith
> 3. We are declaratively justified by evidential faith - Agreed
> I think the main difference between what you are proposing and the standard reformed position is No.2

In your scheme of soteriology, your faith in involved in both the Actual Justification and Declarative Justification. You have invented a new distinction between 'saving faith' and 'evidential faith.' You have also attributed to faith vastly different function.

The simple truth is 'saving faith' is a grace found in a person that Declares and Evidences his justified state (Actual Justification) by God's free grace while he was in the state of sin and death (Actual Unjustified state). Isn't this such a simple and obvious truth stated by the Framers in the Confession?

Saving faith is the instrument to Declare and Evidence the Actual Justification and Regeneration and Adoption by God's free grace at Effectual calling. [Only person in such state will ever have the grace of faith worked in them!]

Your 'actually justified' is remotely related to the 'Actual Justification' as defined and summarised by the 1689. The sight of a similar sounding word has misled you. Your 'actually justified' is really what the Confession defined by 'receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness by faith...' - what the Framers described as 'Declarative Justification' - a justification that is declared by faith.

> Tom: Dear Pastor, I would have to say 'ditto' i.e. you are so convinced that faith _cannnot_ have a place in Actual Justification even if the Lord has put it in Scripture because it just isn't logical to fallen human thinking. The RP seem to think otherwise. Please read my comment below on the Pearl of Great Price.

The Framers did say these things - you have read them before, but through your own spectacles, I believe.
"Those whom God effectually calleth, He also freely justifieth,(1) not by infusing righteousness into them, but by pardoning their sins, and by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous;(2) not for anything wrought in them, or done by them, but for Christ's sake alone;(3) not by imputing faith itself, the act of believing, or any other evangelical obedience to them, as their righteousness; but by imputing Christ's active obedience unto the whole law, and passive obedience in His death for their whole and sole righteousness,(4) they receiving and resting on Him and His righteousness by faith, which faith they have not of themselves; it is the gift of God.(5).

It is pretty clear to me that it is only those that are Actually Justified that are able to exercise faith, thus giving evidence or declaration of the Actual Justification by God's free grace, and "not for anything wrought in them, or done by them."

Faith as a gift of God is found ONLY in those that are Justified (Actual), Regenerated and Adopted. You would want to believe that this gift is given to and is found in the Unjustified (Actual) - i.e. still under the just Condemnation of Death.
You would agree that before Actual Justification, an elect is under Actual Condemnation... i.e. in the state of sin and death. You can dismiss it as human reason. You would want to agree that a man under such spiritual state is incapable of faith. You can dismiss it as human reason.

But Christ certainly did say, "No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.... And he said, Therefore said I unto you, that no man can come unto me, except it were given unto him of my Father."

It is quite simple to me: no effectual calling by the Father to grace and salvation - and effectual call to grace and salvation necessitates Justification (Actual), Regeneration and Adoption - no coming to Christ in Faith. You can dismiss this as human reason. [No Actual Justification by grace, no Declarative Justification by faith. Remember the words of Buchanan and Gill?]

> Tom: Yes, it is Christ who quickens. That's what Keach is saying. Can you not also see in the whole sentence that "such who receive Christ by faith, though they were dead, Christ immediately quickens them; raiseth them from the dead to a state of spiritual life" ? I'm sorry if I can only interpret this so plainly. Those who receive Christ by faith- Christ immediately quickens them....... There is no way in any human language that this can be interpreted to mean - Declarative quickening, or coming to a knowledge of their quickened state .....just in case you are headed that direction ;-]}(icon means bearded man- sorry can't risk being cheeky!)

## Let say, I agree with your conclusion that these words of Keach teach that the spiritually dead exercises faith in Christ and is immediately quickened by Christ and is raised from the dead to a state of spiritual life.

Now, assume that I can give you evidence from Keach's own writing also that the sovereign work of regeneration must precede any exercise of faith, would you consider that either Keach is being inconsistent here, or he is being plainly misinterpreted? Would that be reasonable? Would you agree that both may be possible? To err is human; to be inconsistent too.

My method is to understand and interpret a man's particular writing in light of, and in harmony with, his overall view, at the same time bearing in mind that being man, there will be progress in understanding, and so there may be inconsistencies too.

Keach did put his signature, with many other PBs of his days, to these words (1689.20.4):
"Although the gospel be the only outward means of revealing Christ and saving grace, and is, as such, abundantly sufficient thereunto; yet that men who are dead in trespasses may be born again, quickened or regenerated, there is moreover necessary an effectual insuperable work of the Holy Spirit upon the whole soul, for the producing in them a new spiritual life; without which no other means will effect their conversion unto God.

Your plain interpretation of Keach's quote may be correct, in which case, I conclude that he has contradicted himself badly. Or you can interpret his words in light of his overall writing. The choice is yours.

>Tom: The gospel requires faith as a condition of justification and eternal life. Faith being there as part of God-ordained chain of events (that's why faith is a gift). Calling-faith-justification.

You choose this way to understand Keach's word. That way you make Keach out to be self-contradictory, which may be possible. There is another way to understand his words - faith is a condition to manifest, to declare, to evidence Actual Justification and Eternal Life... because the Confession that he signed say that only such that has eternal life can be brought to faith, 'conversion unto God.' You know my choice. I choose a way that give Keach some due respect, and not bear a false witness against him.

> Keach has just answered your objection (it's almost prophetic of Keach) : You say: But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life? Keach says: "Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic" Keach did not say a condition to /declare and experience /Actual Justification and eternal life. Please read his words- plainly (without assumption). If he were to reply to the objection (remember it is an objection similar to yours: "don't tell me that faith is a condition of obtaining Actual Justification and eternal life") Hence his reply -yes it is a condition (in a sense) because it is there as part of a connected chain of events put in order by eternal decree- as one depend on another. Make sense?

## You want to believe that Keach is teaching that your faith is a condition to obtain your Actual Justification and Eternal Life, and accept that he is also self-consistent [with his other writing.] I want to believe that Keach is simply teaching that your faith is a condition to Declare your Actual Justification and Eternal life, thus recognising him as a man consistent in his thought.

So, we differ. That's ok.

Tom: Read Keach- you will be surprised. Can't comment much for Kiffin and Knolly because we have no access to their materials.

## Yes, if I can take the 1689 CoF to which Keach put his signature, then I think I have read some of Keach clear [doctrinal and confessional] thoughts too.

Brother Tom, I have nothing more to say. If you have, please feel free to do so. I would be busy in the next weeks or so. This week we have a week of fasting and praying: last night we gathered in brother Woon and sister Yueh Lay's home to specially remember all the churches that were once associated with us... praying for each of them and their leaders the Lord's rich blessing upon them, praying even for reconciliation...

The whole of SDC is reading all our exchanges... I want them to learn along the way.

I must say that you have mounted a most substantial challenge (no flattery here) against my understanding of the doctrine of salvation, which incidentally, is also believed by those Baptists whose churches had always had the 1689 CoF as their church doctrinal standard since the 18th century until today.

I have thoroughly enjoyed exchanges of our opinions [sic]. With your permission, I will compile all the exchanges, and that of few others into a booklet. All traces of your name or slight reference to you shall be removed. Since you are so convinced, making known the view expressed may actually protect others from my errors. I assume permission granted, since making our theological views would assist others in seeking the truth, and warn them of errors.

I love you, dear brother in Christ. Thanks for the study, and the humour. Good to study serious things with some humour. I enjoyed it.

By grace, I remain
your brother in Christ,
sing


Message 50
Date: Wed, 06 Dec 2006 16:48:14 +0800

Brother Tom,

This is the 50th message in the series.

Tom: Keach has just answered your objection (it's almost prophetic of Keach): You say: But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life? Keach says: "Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic" Keach did not say a condition to /declare and experience /Actual Justification and eternal life. Please read his words- plainly (without assumption). If he were to reply to the objection (remember it is an objection similar to yours: "don't tell me that faith is a condition of obtaining Actual Justification and eternal life") Hence his reply -yes it is a condition (in a sense) because it is there as part of a connected chain of events put in order by eternal decree- as one depend on another. Make sense?

I think you are quite mistaken if you think Keach is answering my objection. Keach was dealing with a rhetorical question posed by detractors who accused the PBs as believing Actual Justification from eternity. So the objection is really quite different.

I am insisting that faith is a condition in Declarative Justification.
I am denying that faith has any role in Actual Justification.
I believe both statements are affirmed by Keach's word. Read on if you have not dismissed me altogether.

I made this request: "I would appreciate if you could help me to understand what 'as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic' mean."

You replied, "The gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life. Faith being there as part of God-ordained chain of events (that's why faith is a gift). Calling-faith-justification.” [I assume you refer Actual Justification.]

I am quite tempted to call this answer a knee-jerk kind of response. Keach said, "Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic" Please note that Keach does not speak derogatively about human logic as RBs are quick to do so. You are in danger of getting into that mode too.

May I suggest to you that the simple answer to my question on the meaning of Keach statement, in the words of Buchanan and Gill, is simply this: that Declarative Justification by faith depends on Actual Justification by grace in logic.

Buchanan put it this way, "Actual Justification come first, and is necessarily presupposed in that which is declarative." (pg 234). "Their ACTUAL Justification is presupposed, but their DECLARATIVE Justification is specially referred to." (pg 235, all emphasis original.)

Gill put it this way: "They differ, the one being an immanent act in God; all which sort of acts are eternal, and so before faith; the other being a transient declarative act, terminating on the conscience of the believer; and so is by and through faith, and follows it." (in 2b7e quoted previously.) The pronoun 'they' obviously refer to AJ and DJ.

"The connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic" refers to Actual Justification and Declarative Justification in their proper connexion and logical order.

Actual Justification before faith was never disputed among the early Particular Baptists. They were also wholly agreed that Declarative Justification is by faith, and not before. They were fighting against the perverse accusation that they believe in Actual Justification from eternity. That is why 1689.11.4 has, "nevertheless, they are not justified personally, until the Holy Spirit doth in time due actually apply Christ unto them." And the Holy Spirit applies Christ unto them at effectual calling to grace and salvation at God’s appointed and approved time – that’s when they are Justified [Actual Justification].

That explains Keach’s reply to the smart-alecky objection of one who accuses the PBs of Actual Justification from eternity - like some confused RBs still do to this day: "But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?" Keach says: "Yes, as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic." Keach affirmed what the detractors thought he would deny. The detractors had naively assumed that Keach held to Actual Justification from eternity. [Keach affirmed Actual Justification in time, and faith as a condition to manifest and declare that prior Actual justification and eternal life.] Keach affirmed Declarative Justification by faith - but only in its proper connexion and logical order to Actual Justification by grace.

I am done. Thanks for listening. Please continue if you have fresh thought. I have none left. You have been skilful to drain out all that is there.

sing
"And some believed the things which were spoken,
and some believed not" Acts 28:24