Things New and Old

Ancient truths revealed in the Scriptures are often forgotten, disbelieved or distorted, and therefore lost in the passage of time. Such ancient truths when rediscovered and relearned are 'new' additions to the treasury of ancient truths.

Christ showed many new things to the disciples, things prophesied by the prophets of old but hijacked and perverted by the elders and their traditions, but which Christ reclaimed and returned to His people.

Many things taught by the Apostles of Christ have been perverted or substituted over the centuries. Such fundamental doctrines like salvation by grace and justification have been hijacked and perverted and repudiated by sincere Christians. These doctrines need to be reclaimed and restored to God's people.

There are things both new and old here. "Consider what I say; and the Lord give thee understanding in all things"
2Ti 2:7.

Monday, February 11, 2008

Romans 1:18-32 Who are they?

On Thu Nov 1, 2007 4:43 pm sing wrote:


Brethren,

Romans 1:28 "And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient...

Please permit me to ask some childish questions. Please help me.

1. Who are referred to by the pronouns "they" and "them"?
2. What does it mean 'to retain God in their knowledge'?
3. What kind of knowledge is this - innate, natural, spiritual?
4. Does "as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge" imply that they had God in their knowledge before but did not want to retain it any longer, i.e. have jettisoned it?
5. Is it necessary to give a reprobate over to a reprobate mind?
6. Is having a reprobate mind the same as being a reprobate?
7. Can a child of God, under certain circumstances, be given over to a reprobate mind?

Pardon my genuine inquiries. Please help me to understand.

sing
=======

On Thu Nov 1, 2007 11:33 pm, Benny wrote

Bro Sing,

Please permit my answers...correct as needed, but you good brethren be gentle. :)

I believe Paul is speaking of mankind in general in Romans 1, and that by "retaining God in their knowledge" it means that man did not want to acknowledge that there is a creator. In other words, God made man and for some period of time, mankind in general, whether righteous or wicked, knew there was a creator God. Take Cain for example, who was "of that wicked one" (1 John 3:12), yet he knew full well there was a creator God (Genesis 4:9). However, as time went on, man erased the fact that there is a creator God from his teachings, thoughts, etc, despite the fact that nature itself testifies of a Creator (Romans 1:20). I guess you would say that is a natural, or historic knowledge of God. Simply put, a general recognition of the existence of a Divine Creator God.

If I am way off base, call me back from the limb I am out on. (or at least throw me a safety rope)

God bless,
Benny
=======

On Fri Nov 2, 2007 1:32 pm sing wrote:

Brother Benny

I have thrown a big and thick mattress under the limb... so the danger is minimal.
Thanks for your thoughts. I went back to read the passage, and my mind was provoked with some questions.

Brethren, please help me with these honest questions...

Romans 1:18-28 "For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness;...

Sorry, more questions - just honest question in order to rightly divide the word of truth.
- Who are these men who hold "the truth" in unrighteousness?
- Do natural men ever hold the truth"? And hold the truth in unrighteousness?
- What is meant by "the truth"? Does the definite article 'the' has any significance?
- What is meant by "holding the truth in unrighteousness"?
- Do God's children hold the truth?
- Do God's children hold the truth in unrighteousness?
This question surely reminds me of the children of God among the Jews in apostolic times, in their hard unbelief of the gospel of Jesus Christ.

- Is the indictment against natural men in general who ought to hold the truth in righteousness but who actually hold the truth in unrighteousness?
- Or is the indictment against God's children who ought to hold the truth in righteousness but who actually hold the truth in unrighteousness?
- Which would make most sense?

Needing to learn,
sing
=======

on Fri Nov 2, 2007 1:20 pm, Jay wrote:

Brother Sing,

I think if you check the meaning of the Greek word translated "hold," you'll discover that it means to hold down or to suppress. These men do not clutch the truth to themselves as a treasure, but they rather do as much as they can to suppress or destroy it. The word can mean to hold something treasured, but it can also mean to suppress or hold down. I believe in this context that is the proper interpretation of the word.

Hope this thought helps some of your questions,
jay
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 1:03 am, sing wrote:

Brother Jay,

Thank you for the light. You are right. The NKJ has 'suppress,' and 'hold down' in the margin. My KJ copy has 'hold back' in the margin. Is there any difference between 'hold down' and 'hold back'?

Whether 'hold down' or 'hold back' (i.e. hold it in an unrighteous manner) would it right to say that such action presupposes the possession or knowledge of "the truth"? How does one suppress, hold down, or hold back the truth if he does not know the truth?

Verse 18-19 constitutes one sentence (that's how my copy of the KJ read). Would it be right to say that "the truth" in verse 18 is elaborated in verse 19 - "the truth" is that which may be known of God. And that which may be known of God, God Himself has shown it to them?

So most probably "the truth" is something more than natural innate knowledge of God that every man possesses by nature (I assume this is true... I may still be wrong.) Is it possible that "the truth" that God Himself has shown it to them is just the natural innate knowledge of God? If it is just innate knowledge, would there be a need at all for God to show it to them? All honest questions to learn the truth.

It seems to me that Rom 1:18-32 deals with those who sin grievously against clear light, and not just natural men in general. The more I read, the more apparent this gets. It seems Apostle Paul is dealing with a specific group of people who is highly privileged... who have been shown the truth, did not want to retain/have it..

They have the truth of God. God has shown it unto them
- BUT they hold the truth in unrighteousness. They knew God (v21). God has shown it to them.
- BUT they glorified Him not as God, neither were thankful.
- But they worshiped and served the creature MORE than the Creator.
- BUT they changed the glory of the incorruptible God into an image... They have the truth of God.
- BUT they changed it into a lie.
- BUT did not like to retain God in their knowledge. They know the judgment of God against ungodliness and unrighteousness
- BUT do them regardless.
- BUT delight in other that do the same.

Are these things speaking of natural men in general? I am wondering if the text is not saying too much?

Thanks for guiding a lad,
sing
=======


Sat Nov 3, 2007 1:58 am

Brother Sing,

My thoughts to your questions.

Do these people possess the truth by the term "hold" or "hold down"? I'd say that Paul's intent is that they are enemies to the truth and their objective is to suppress it, not that they possess it in any personal or inate manner. They likely hate it more than "hold it."

I do believe the context deals with the ability of mankind in general to look at nature and to know certain fundamental truths that "creation" testifies regarding its "Creator." One of our church members was a vice president for Boeing until his recent retirement. A year or so back he attended a conference in which government, industry, and education interests were represented. Most of the presentations were openly pro-evolution and anti-creation, anti- Christianity. A leading speaker in the conference spoke clearly of his anti-Christianity, but he also spoke in detail regarding the order and intelligent design that we see in nature. Our member sat by this man for dinner one night and struck up a conversation with him, thanking him for making such a strong case FOR God and for God's intelligent design of nature. The man was quite startled. Brother Ron Johnson is a member of FGF. He could give you more details of this fascinating interaction, but the point was-is clear. God has left His distinct marks on His creation. It speaks of intelligent origin and design, not of accidental evolution. Wicked natural men are more often inclined to actively seek to suppress this information than to acknowledge it.

Many years ago I read an article in a magazine from a creation research society. The article told about a leading scientist in Great Britain who was a featured speaker at a national gathering of scientists. In the speech he acknowledged that he was not a Christian, but that, as a scientist he could no longer support the idea of evolution as being credible and believable science. He then used this analogy. To advocate that the present universe came into being by evolution is the scientific equvalent to alleging that a tornado can sweep through a junk yard and assemble a Boeing 747 jet aircraft flight ready! Wow!

While nature sufficiently bears such testimony to God's existence and power, "...his eternal power and godhead..." most of the time wicked men consciously suppress or avoid such conclusions. If they acknowledge God in creation, they must deal with Him in terms of morality! I do not believe it is outside natural man's ability to know that God exists. "God is not in all his thoughts" more likely refers to a favorable or spiritual consideration. In Job the wicked shake their fist at God and tell Him, "Depart from us for we desire not the knowledge of thy ways." James tells us that the devils believe in God's existence and tremble.

I believe Paul's major objective in this section of Scripture is to affirm that on Judgment Day, God will pass sentence on wicked men, and that sentence will be altogether just and right. He will produce the evidence of their sin, sin that includes in many cases an active, conscious dedication to suppression of any consideration of Him and His power.

Hope this helps,
Jay
=======

Fri Nov 2, 2007 4:38 pm

Brother Sing,
I believe Jay is correct about the intent of the word "hold" in this passage. Its about suppressing the truth. Those described in the passage "hold" truth in unrighteousness, NOT holding it in righteousness. Hence, their intent is to suppress the truth by withholding and suppressing it from others.

Regarding the word "Truth" in the passage. Consider these various categories of truth. I do believe the Scriptures set forth several categories of truth. Consider the following:

1.) There is truth revealed in Natural Creation to all mankind. This is "natural truth" and is available to all mankind. It's closely akin to "natural science".
2.) There is truth revealed in the Law to Jews only. (Ps. 147: 19, 20)
3.) There is truth revealed in the Gospel to only the regenerated Elect . (Matt. 11:25; 1 Cor. 2: 12- 14)

All the above categories have reference to "Truth". But in each category the truth refers to a different context of it.
Brother Sing, I believe the "truth" Paul is addressing in Romans 1:18 relates to the truth about Natural Creation. (see #1 above) Read again verse 18,19 & 20 in Romans 1. What do you think? I do understand these to be speaking about Natural Creation and the "truth" that is self-evident from it.

Just my American dollar's worth! Not what it once was worth!

Eddie
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 1:03 am

Dear Brother Eddie,

Thanks for the cool refreshing breeze from the desert. I am glad the fire was no where near you.

You said
== Brother Sing, I believe the "truth" Paul is addressing in Romans 1:18 relates to the truth about Natural Creation. (see #1 above) Read again verse 18,19 & 20 in Romans 1. What do you think? I do understand these to be speaking about Natural Creation and the "truth" that is self-evident from it. ==

You may be right. But I have questions in my rusty head. This is what I think.

On the one hand we have the truth about the natural creation that is "clearly seen," yes, "truth that is self-evident" as you say. Now, if this aspect of truth are clearly seen and is self-evident, then I would conclude that this category of truth DOES NOT need God to show it.

However, "the truth" spoken of requires God Himself to show it, "God hath showed it to them." Therefore the truth that needs God Himself to show it is of the truth of a different sphere.

keep blowing the cool breeze,
sing
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 1:24 am

Brother Sing,

I think Romans 1:20 is explaining how it is that God has shown it unto them (in verse 19). He shews it unto them and all mankind by the fact that he continues to uphold His creation before the eyes of mankind by the word of his power (Heb 1:3). Through God's upholding of his creation before mankind's eyes, He is speaking to all mankind or shewing to all mankind that there is a God.

Psalms 19:1-3 says, "The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork. Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge. There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard."

All over the earth, God shows or teaches mankind that there is a God by his sustaining and upholding His creation before their eyes. It is not that creation is really shewing itself.

Consider this.
If I hold up a dollar bill before your eyes, it is obvious that I was the one who shewed you the dollar bill. The dollar bill did not really shew itself to you. I was the one that shewed it to you by holding it up before your eyes.

Likewise, it is through God's upholding of creation (Heb 1:3) before our eyes that He shews us His creation whereby mankind is without excuse to acknowledge His existence.

Blessings,

Vincent
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 4:39 pm

Brother Vincent,

Thanks for your thoughts...

Ps 19 is interesting. However Ps 19 is the confession of a child of God. Would it be right to say that what the Psalmist perceives is what every natural man in general perceive? Yes, there are God's people in every speech and language who hear the voices of the heavens and firmament declaring the glory of God. It is making the text to say FAR TOO MUCH that natural man in every speech and language hear the voices of the heavens and firmament declaring the glory of God.

I would consider suitable proof texts for your assertion.

I do believe there is a vast difference between God 'upholding all things by the word of his power' - including the whole human race - and His activity of making himself known to men such that the visible creation actually confirmed to them the eternal power and God-head of God.

NO amount of the visible things of the creation can reveal the invisible things of God to natural man. Spiritual things are spiritually discerned. Invisible things of God are certainly things of the Spirit of God, spiritual things. This is a reasonable statement, I think.

Visible things of the creation can reveal the invisible things of God to spiritual men only, God's children. This is a reasonable statement, I think.

The invisible things of the creation are CLEARLY SEEN - not seen by physical eyes of the natural men, but seen by the eyes of faith of spiritual men. This is a reasonable statement, I think.

I would be glad to hear further. Please keep talking. Righteous communication edifies. I am in need of being build up in the most holy faith.

sing
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 1:50 am

Brother Sing,

I fully agree with both Brother Eddie's and Brother Jay's explanation of these verses. The context makes it very clear to me.

Concerning Paul's statement in Romans 1:18 "For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness," and a resulting question regarding Romans 1:19, "Just how did God show it unto them?", consider the first phrase in verse 19: "Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them." God hath showed it unto them intellectually with conscious knowledge by manifesting unto them that which may be known of God. Psalm 19:1-6, along with the context of Romans 1:20, reveal how God manifest it unto them. 1:20 reads: "For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse." Paul, in this Romans 1:18-32 context, is not speaking of a revelation of God about "Spiritual things", but about "Natural things"--i.e. about God's natural creation as per Genesis 1:1-31. Psalm 19, verses 1 to 6, from the OT, give another strong clue which correlates with Paul's NT passage. Note the reading in Psalm 19:

1 The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork.
2 Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge.
3 There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.
4 Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. In them hath he set a tabernacle for the sun,
5 Which is as a bridegroom coming out of his chamber, and rejoiceth as a strong man to run a race.
6 His going forth is from the end of the heaven, and his circuit unto the ends of it: and there is nothing hid from the heat thereof.

Romans 1:18-20 is not a revelation of God given "through the Gospel." 1:18-20 is in contrast to the power of the gospel revelation in Romans 1:16-17. 1:18-20 is a revelation of the wrath of God sent directly from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness; and is not that revelation that is conveyed through the Gospel. Romans 1 speaks distinctively of two different kinds of revelation, the one revelation of the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith through the Gospel; the other revelation speaks of the wrath of God which is revealed directly from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness."

As both Brother Joe and Brother Ed have factually given regarding this "holding the truth in unrighteousness", the people of whom Paul is speaking in this particular context "hold back" the truth of God's creation and would "suppress" it so as to deny and hide the authority of God's eternal power and Godhead which is abundantly revealed in and by His CREATION. These persons, of whom Paul speaks in this precise context, are without excuse in their denial of the authority of the Godhead's eternal power to CREATE the universe. In this very context, Paul is denying the errant concept of "verticle evolution," and is giving all the authority to God for all of His CREATIVE WORK IN NATURE. In this, David also concurs with Paul by asserting that: "The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork. Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge. There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard. Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world..." This makes the fool without excuse (Rom. 1:20).

Such Scriptures reveal just HOW God hath shewed it unto them. By opposing and rejecting this revelation of God in His works of CREATION, Psalm 53:1 states: "The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. Corrupt are they, and have done abominable iniquity..." The "fool" suppresses the "truth" of God's works in creation by holding back that truth in unrighteousness. They are without excuse to suppress this "truth."

May God bless,
Bernardo
=======

Fri Nov 2, 2007 10:59 pm

Bro. Sing,

I have no answers, but I do have a few thoughts for you.

I think the real question is "To what degree can a child of God sin?"
If you make a limit on what a child of God cannot do so far as sin, then it would seem logical to me that we would have to put a limit degree on what a child of God can do in the realm of good.
I do not want to put limits on either.
I think that the judgment of the eternal destiny of any man is in the hands of God only, and we only know who are His and who are not by His direct pronouncement about the person.

I do not believe our old human sinful nature is changed in any degree by regeneration. It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing. That which is born of the spirit it spirit. That which is born of the flesh is flesh (the word 'flesh' meaning our Adam nature).

How much further away from God, right, good, which dishonours God, can a child of God go, than to believe that a totally depraved, dead in trespasses and sins person can and must do something, acceptable to God, before God will make that person His child?
How could some immoral sin, compare to such a spiritual sin; especially the sin of a 'dead in sin person' having to do in order to get eternal divne life from God?

I think the texts, under consideration, reveal the chastening love of God for His disobedient people in allowing them to discover their hog-pen thinking and practice so they will repent and return to right thinking and honour God.

Personally, I believe these people in Romans 1:18-28 are children of God.

Verses 18-21 are one sentence, and verse 22 begins with "Professing themselves...". I do not want to compromise and say there could be some unregenerate under consideration, because the texts say such things as -men-, not mankind, who hold the truth in unrighteousness, because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; (in those who hold the truth in unrighteousness) for God hath shewed it unto them, for the invisible things (spiritual) of him (God) from the creation of the world (not 'by' the creation of the world) ('from' has to do with time and not the physical creation) are clearly seen (it is the invisible things of God that are clearly seen and are being understood) being understood by the thing that are made (and the things that are made are invisible things) (because the things that are understood by them are understood by faith. the reason I say these things are understood by faith is because of what it is, in part, that is understood) even his eternal power and Godhead;(God's eternal power and Godhead are not understood by seeing and understanding the physical science of the natural creation. you might understand there had to be a supreme being who created all things; but not the Godhead of God.) so that they are without excuse: (these people have no excusing, from a 'time world' wrath of God, while they are living on earth, because what God has revealed in them is what they know -revelation from God and of God is spiritual, not physical.)

Among God's children, and in the sight of God, before a physical moral wrong is performed, they have already departed from fellowship with God spiritually, and resorted to their old flesh nature to follow it. The prodigal left his father's house before he got to the hog pen.

I think the Lord inspired Paul to write this in order to reveal the spiritual corruptness of the Jewish people, like He did to John when He called Jerusalem spiritually Sodom and Egypt. These Jewish people who were, in their thinking, more holy than the Gentiles with whom they worshipped, that they needed to know where they stood with God so they would stop their condemning of the Gentiles in the same church at Rome. That is what chapter 2 is about.

Just a few random thoughts of mine.
If any help, okay, praise the Lord, no charge.
If any hinderance, forgive, and charge the error to me personally.
God Bless You Dear Brother.
If you have a mind to help me where you see my errors in thinking, please do.
In love of the Lord and His Holy Word.

Far east
=======

On Nov 3, 2007, at 6:22 AM, Bernardo wrote:

Brother Sing,

Perhaps we should observe that Romans 1:28-32 says way too much for Paul to be speaking of children of God in these verses. Notice carefully the reading:

Romans 1:28-32 "And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient; Being filled with all unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness; full of envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity; whisperers, Backbiters, haters of God, despiteful, proud, boasters, inventors of evil things, disobedient to parents, Without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful: Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them."

For the new creature (creation) in Christ Jesus, these old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new. (2 Cor. 5:17). A definite change of nature is made in the heart of the child of God in regeneration.

How can we reckon that a child of God can in any way be described by these terms that Paul uses? As an example, how is it that children of God can be "haters of God?" Rather than being haters of God, the children of God love God because God first loved them (1 John 4:19).

Truths seriously to be considered,
Bernardo
=======

Saturday, November 03, 2007 04:10 AM

Dear Brother Bernardo,

Thanks for your thoughts.

I am trying to see from the other direction. If apostle Paul is merely speaking of the natural men in general, isn't he stating the obvious and plain? Why such urgency and gravity? Why point out such obvious and plain matter to a church in Rome? There must be more to such a serious indictment being stated.

I do believe God's children, though new creatures with a NEW nature, are capable of all those things stated in Rom 1:28-32. Many passages testify to this reality. And God's children, holding the truth in unrighteousness, do descend into various hideous sins enumerated. That explains the gravity of the matter raised by apostle Paul.

I am just thinking, it was said of the whole generation that perished in the flood - "the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every imagination of the thought of his heart was only evil continually." Were there God's children among those described above that perished in the flood? . If there were, were they included in the description above? Honest questions.

I am thinking of God's children among the Jews living in the generation of the Apostles who were so opposed to the new covenant. Many suffered horrendous destruction in the hands of the Romans... Kind of remind me of the flood...

scattered thoughts,
sing
=======

Sat Nov 3, 2007 11:54 pm

Brother Sing,

I surely do need you to answer these questions, please:

How can someone who loves God from the heart also hate God from that same heart?
Don't you believe that love and hate are opposites?
How do you rectify this dilemma?

Curious,
Bernardo
=======

Sun Nov 4, 2007 12:55 am

Brother Far-east,

Thanks for your thoughts. There are things you said I don't seem to understand. Let me work through it line by line. My comments indicated by ##.

== I think the real question is "To what degree can a child of God sin?" If you make a limit on what a child of God cannot do so far as sin, then it would seem logical to me that we would have to put a limit degree on what a child of God can do in the realm of good. ==
## Are you indicating that it is a wrong start to say that God's children can't possibly do those things ["make a limit] mentioned in Romans 1:18-32, and therefore must speak of natural man?

== I do not want to put limits on either. ==
## Hmmmm. Why not? Please tell me the reason.

== I think that the judgment of the eternal destiny of any man is in the hands of God only, and we only know who are His and who are not by His direct pronouncement about the person. ==
## What about the declaration, "whoever believes has eternal life'?

== I do not believe our old human sinful nature is changed in any degree by regeneration. It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing. That which is born of the spirit it spirit. That which is born of the flesh is flesh (the word 'flesh' meaning our Adam nature). ==
## I do see the point. It is not the old nature got fixed in any degree. It is a new nature given at regeneration.

== How much further away from God, right, good, which dishonours God, can a child of God go, than to believe that a totally depraved, dead in trespasses and sins person can and must do something, acceptable to God, before God will make that person His child? ==
## Well, may be two inches further! It is easier for may to accept that God's children may be very messed up in their mind, BUT can their lives be so messed up as in Romans 1:18-30?
It is very strange nevertheless - I have met RBs who give lip service to total depravity... and at the same time insist that one must believe to have eternal life. But of course so many of God's children do not even believe in the total depravity of natural men!

== How could some immoral sin, compare to such a spiritual sin; especially the sin of a 'dead in sin person' having to do in order to get eternal divne life from God? ==
## I have never compared immoral sin with a irrational sin. I am not sure if they can be compared at all. Is being muddled headed a spiritual sin - is believing an error a spiritual sin. Honest questions. Not trying to disagree. Just searching to understand.

== I think the texts, under consideration, reveal the chastening love of God for His disobedient people in allowing them to discover their hog-pen thinking and practice so they will repent and return to right thinking and honour God.
Personally, I believe these people in Romans 1:18-28 are children of God. ==
## I am beginning to think that they are indeed the folks Apostle Paul is dealing with, with urgency and great gravity. I am assessing what credible objections against such understanding...

== Verses 18-21 are one sentence, and verse 22 begins with "Professing themselves...". I do not want to compromise and say there could be some unregenerate under consideration, because the texts say such things as -men-, not mankind, who hold the truth in unrighteousness, because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; (in those who hold the truth in unrighteousness) for God hath shewed it unto them, for the invisible things (spiritual) of him (God) from the creation of the world (not 'by' the creation of the world) ('from' has to do with time and not the physical creation) are clearly seen (it is the invisible things of God that are clearly seen and are being understood) being understood by the thing that are made (and the things that are made are invisible things) (because the things that are understood by them are understood by faith. the reason I say these things are understood by faith is because of what it is, in part, that is understood) even his eternal power and Godhead;(God's eternal power and Godhead are not understood by seeing and understanding the physical science of the natural creation. you might understand there had to be a supreme being who created all things; but not the Godhead of God.) so that they are without excuse: (these people have no excusing, from a 'time world' wrath of God, while they are living on earth, because what God has revealed in them is what they know -revelation from God and of God is spiritual, not physical.) ==
## Thanks for your observations. My copy has v18-19 as one sentence, and v20-21 as another sentence. That is why I said 'the truth' in verse 18 has to do with the knowledge of God that God himself has shown to them in verse 19 of the same sentence. The next sentence speaks of the affirmation and vindication of the spiritual truth shown to them by God through the visible creation. And this knowledge of God - "the INVISIBLE THINGS of him" - that God has shown to them is clearly affirmed and testified by the VISIBLE THINGS of the creation.

If "from..." is understood as "since the creation of the world" it would make plenty of sense.
Would this rendering preserve the same meaning:
"For the invisible things of HIM are clearly seen [by His children, because shown to them by God] SINCE the creation of the world, [the invisible things of Him - eternal power and Godhead] being understood by [through] the things [visible] that are made."

Why do you say that "the things that are made are invisible things"? I think they are visible things which point to and affirm the invisible things, namely eternal power and Godhead of God.

== Among God's children, and in the sight of God, before a physical moral wrong is performed, they have already departed from fellowship with God spiritually, and resorted to their old flesh nature to follow it. The prodigal left his father's house before he got to the hog pen. ==
## I believe Romans 1:18-30 speaks of actual act of ungodliness and unrighteousness spelt out explicitly, not just the sins in thoughts.

== I think the Lord inspired Paul to write this in order to reveal the spiritual corruptness of the Jewish people, like He did to John when He called Jerusalem spiritually Sodom and Egypt. These Jewish people who were, in their thinking, more holy than the Gentiles with whom they worshipped, that they needed to know where they stood with God so they would stop their condemning of the Gentiles in the same church at Rome. That is what chapter 2 is about. ==
## Quite likely. I thought to myself... surely Apostle Paul is dealing with something very urgent and closer at home concerning the church in Rome. It seems the description in Romans 1:18-30 fit many of God's children among the Jews in the period of reformation (AD 30-70). Many of them suffered horrendous death (death spoken of in verse 1:30?) in AD 70.

== Just a few random thoughts of mine. If any help, okay, praise the Lord, no charge. If any hinderance, forgive, and charge the error to me personally. God Bless You Dear Brother. If you have a mind to help me where you see my errors in thinking, please do. In love of the Lord and His Holy Word. Far-east ==
## Your random thoughts are appreciated. Thanks that it is without charge.
As it is, I can't even see the many errors of my own. I am in need of help from veterans.
So don't expect any help from this lad.

sing in the south seas.
=======

Sun Nov 4, 2007 3:27 pm

Brother Bernardo,
No bunker bomb please!
sing
----


Sun Nov 4, 2007 9:08 am

Bro. Sing,
Please find some further random thoughts in ff.
Far-east

sing: Are you indicating that it is a wrong start to say that God's children can't possibly do those things ["make a limit] mentioned in Romans 1:18-32, and therefore must speak of natural man? No Sir. I am saying that a child of God is capable of doing good and bad.

f: I do not want to put limits on either.
s: Hmmmm. Why not? Please tell me the reason.
ff: Because I believe our human Adamic nature is as evil as before regeneraton and that our new nature cannot sin.

f: I think that the judgment of the eternal destiny of any man is in the hands of God only, and we only know who are His and who are not by His direct pronouncement about the person.
s: What about the declaration, "whoever believes has eternal life'?
ff: I am not saying that God cannot say who has eternal life. I am saying that I cannot look on the heart of the individual. I can only make my conclusions from what is made manifest by a person and what is manifest may or may not be the fact.

f: I do not believe our old human sinful nature is changed in any degree by regeneration. It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing. That which is born of the spirit it spirit. That which is born of the flesh is flesh (the word 'flesh' meaning our Adam nature).
sing: I do see the point. It is not the old nature got fixed in any degree. It is a new nature given at regeneration.
ff: Amen!

f: How much further away from God, right, good, which dishonours God, can a child of God go, than to believe that a totally depraved, dead in trespasses and sins person can and must do something, acceptable to God, before God will make that person His child?
s: Well, may be two inches further! It is easier for may to accept that God's children may be very messed up in their mind, BUT can their lives be so messed up as in Romans 1:18-30?
ff: I say Yes, especially when they have known the truth and turned from it. God was justified in what He did to Jerusalem in AD 70, because or the Jews rejection of the thruth they had known. He called them Sodom and Egypt spiritually. Rev. 11:8

s: It is very strange nevertheless - I have met RBs who gives lip service to total depravity... and at the same time insist that one must believe to have eternal life. But of course so many of God's children do not even believe in the total depravity of natural men!
ff: I am one who believes that our thanksgiving to God will be based primarily upon our understanding of our own total depravity.

f: How could some immoral sin, compare to such a spiritual sin; especially the sin of a 'dead in sin person' having to do in order to get eternal divne life from God?
s: I have never compared immoral sin with a irrational sin. I am not sure if they can be compared at all. Is being muddled headed a spiritual sin - is believing an error a spiritual sin. Honest questions. Not trying to disagree. Just searching to understand.
ff: My Dear Honest Truth Seeking Brother Sing, I love you, if we never agree.
I really do not know what you would clasify as irrational sin, or being muddled headed.
I think of believing a lie as sin. Is that the same as believing an error?
To me, sin is anything that is not like Jesus Christ, whether in motive, thought, word, or deed.
The new man, the inward man, the new creature, that which is born of the Spirit, is the only part of us that cannot sin. I Jnl. 3:9

f: I think the texts, under consideration, reveal the chastening love of God for His disobedient people in allowing them to discover their hog-pen thinking and practice so they will repent and return to right thinking and honour God. Personally, I believe these people in Romans 1:18-28 are children of God. >>
s: I am beginning to think that they are indeed the folks Apostle Paul is dealing with, with urgency and great gravity. I am assessing what credible objections against such understanding...

== snip ==

s: Why do you say that "the things that are made are invisible things"? I think they are visible things which point to and affirm the invisible things, namely eternal power and Godhead of God.
ff: Moses endured as seeing Him who is invisible. I just think that the invisible things of Him who is invisible are spiritual.
God is Spirit. Isn't the understanding of His eternal power, and 'Godhead of God', a spiritual lesson?
Holding the truth in unrighteousness seems to set the stage for spiritual underestanding of those who hold the truth in unrighteousness.

f: Among God's children, and in the sight of God, before a physical moral wrong is performed, they have already departed from fellowship with God spiritually, and resorted to their old flesh nature to follow it. The prodigal left his father's house before he got to the hog pen.
s: I believe Romans 1:18-30 speaks of actual act of ungodliness and unrighteousness spelt out in explicitly, not just the sins in thoughts.
ff: Amen. Physical manifestation is the end product of conceiving sin.
=======

Mon Nov 5, 2007 10:06 am

Big Brother Bernardo,

When my wise teacher ask me HARD question, I take it that he asked it in order to teach me the truth. Wise teacher asks very hard questions that may overwhelm his student.
Since I do desire to learn the truth, I will risk my neck to consider your 'bunker bomb' question.

I am in perfect agreement with 1 Jn 4:19 : we love God because He first loved us. I think it is a mild error to conclude from this that every child of God loves God from the heart. To say that anyone who loves God does so because God has first loved him IS TRUE. To conclude from this that every child of God loves God from the heart is a hurdle that stumbles a little lad like me.

Your question seems to assume that EVERY child of God loves God from the heart.
Can you please confirm whether this is so.
If every child of God loves God from the heart, then 'haters of God' in Romans 1:30 definitely and exhaustively exclude the children of God.

In another post, I mentioned several things in the passage pointing us to the children of God being under consideration...

I do believe hating God manifests itself in many forms. Is worshipping and serving the creature MORE than the Creator a form of hating God? A good way for a man to express his hatred of his wife is to adore and serve other women more than his own wife. No? Is setting aside the commandments of God hating God? Are those who cannot endure sound doctrine but have itchy ears for the doctrine of demons and fables God haters? Perhaps. I am not sure.

A redeemed man is a weird and peculiar creature... he has his old nature of sin and he has his new nature of life. His old nature is sinewy and hardy... it's a monster if not mortified daily. Yes, I do believe that love and hate are opposites, and these opposites may find comfortable lodging in a child of God. This love-hate affair is all too real. I even heard the Lord's complaints against His people.

I am not attempting to rectify anything. I don't yet see what needs rectifying. Please explain a bit so that I may know the problem, and get the right tools from the garden shed.

sing
=======

Mon Nov 5, 2007 11:00 am


Dear Brother Sing,

Some more serious 'bunker bomb' questions!

If a child of God does not love God from the heart, from where in man or woman does the child of God love God?

In the new birth, God writes His love in the heart of the elect of God. This love of God is part of the righteousness of Christ applied to the heart of the elect at the point of regeneration. This in-wrought and applied love by the grace of God is one element of the new nature given to every elect in regeneration. An integral part of man's nature is definitely changed in regeneration, else there is no quickening of the heart. A man's hatred for God is removed at the point of regeneration and replaced with the love of God and, therefore, the regenerate person possesses a love for God. Such a person "born from above" cannot be a hater of God.

To allege that a child of God does not necessarily love God is part of the 'hollow log' doctrine--which doctrine is the claim that regeneration neither changes one's nature, nor has a lasting effect on an elect. In 1 John 4:19, the apostle gave no hint whatsoever that a regenerated person does not love God. John gave no exceptions (and no buts or oppositions) to this love of God that God hath wrought in the elect when regenerated. He merely stated that "We love Him because He first loved us." No exceptions in this whatsoever.

If a child of God does not necessarily love God as part of his/her nature change, which change actually occurs in regeneration, then please reveal to us what are the "old things that are passed away" as Paul records in 2 Corinthians 5:17? "Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new."

Please inform us "what are the old things that are passed away?"
Please also name what are the "all things that are become new?"

Will be curiously waiting,
Bernardo
=======

Mon Nov 5, 2007 4:18 pm

Dear Teacher Bernard,

== Some more serious 'bunker bomb' questions! ==
## The first 'awed' me. The following are little plastic bullets. Keep spraying them... I mean keep talking... and I will be led to the truth of God.

== If a child of God does not love God from the heart, from where in man or woman does the child of God love God? ==
## Your rhetorical question seems to indicate that you have missed what I said. Have I said that a child of God does not love God from the heart? I have made no such statement. Now I would make one so that there may be no misunderstanding. I do believe a child of God OUGHT to love God from his heart, and not just from his heart also, but also "with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind." That would be better than just loving from his heart, especially if he has a weak heart .

I have inquired, and am inquiring again, does EVERY child of God love God, and from the heart? Could you please affirm or deny whether EVERY CHILD of God loves God from the heart? The question is not, "FROM WHERE a child of God loves God."
The question IS, "does EVERY child of God loves God, and from the heart?

If EVERY child of God does loves God and from the heart, then that 'haters of God' in Romans 1:30 definitely and exhaustively exclude EVERY child of God.

Now, please make a plain statement that EVERY child of God, without exception, loves God and does so from the heart, and I would conclude that the 'haters of God' in Romans 1:30 definitely and exhaustively exclude every child of God.

Could you affirm or deny whether EVERY bunker bomb of the USAF will baptize its target in Iran? The General reported, "Sir, every bunker bomb bull eyed its target in Iran.' The Commander in Chief might announce, "Citizens, every bunker (target) in Iran is bull eyed by our sophisticated bunker bombs."

== In the new birth, God writes His love in the heart of the elect of God. This love of God is part of the righteousness of Christ applied to the heart of the elect at the point of regeneration. This in-wrought and applied love by the grace of God is one element of the new nature given to every elect in regeneration. An integral part of man's nature is definitely changed in regeneration, else there is no quickening of the heart. A man's hatred for God is removed at the point of regeneration and replaced with the love of God and, therefore, the regenerate person possesses a love for God. Such a person "born from above" cannot be a hater of God. ==
## A spiritual dead person is quickened with a new spiritual nature, not just a part of him, e.g. his heart. Your observation is right, the conclusion is a scooter [non-sequitur] without wheels.
Please tell us what constitute a man's hatred for God? May be that would help me to understand your point better.

== To allege that a child of God does not necessarily love God is part of the 'hollow log' doctrine--which doctrine is the claim that regeneration neither changes one's nature, nor has a lasting effect on an elect. In 1 John 4:19, the apostle gave no hint whatsoever that a regenerated person does not love God. John gave no exceptions (and no buts or oppositions) to this love of God that God hath wrought in the elect when regenerated. He merely stated that "We love Him because He first loved us." No exceptions in this whatsoever. ==
## Hollow logs is mighty useful for wifey's stove. I need plenty of them to economize.
I think regeneration gives a NEW nature, in addition to the old one, and not a CHANGED nature. There is the new man, and there is the old man, in one person. It wasn't a middle-aged man . And the new man manifests its effect to varying degrees.

"We love him because He first loved us" is a universal truth without exception for what it DOES say. One must make sure that he is not making it says what it does not. It does tell me the REASON why God's children love Him. It does not tell me the EXTENT or DEGREE of the children of God love Him. May be I am not seeing what you are drawing out from the wonderful statement. Please know that I cannot draw out what I cannot see. So, help me to see that the statement says that EVERY child of God, without exception, loves God.

== If a child of God does not necessarily love God as part of his/her nature change, which change actually occurs in regeneration, then please reveal to us what are the "old things that are passed away" as Paul records in 2 Corinthians 5:17? "Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new." ==
## Can you please affirm that EVERY child of GOD does necessarily love God from the heart as a result of the change that actually occurred at regeneration. Please say so, and I will safely conclude that the 'haters of God' in Romans 1 cannot possibly be God's children.

Amen and amen about the passing away of old things, and all things are become new.
I am certain that the OLD MAN is not passed away. How very wonderful is that's true!
However exhaustive the all things that are become new, they can't possibly include the old man become a new man! The body of this death remains.

== Please inform us "what are the old things that are passed away?" Please also name what are the "all things that are become new?" ==
## May be the pathetic old fig-leaves covering? Our old condemned state? Our old state of death? Our old alienation from God? Old covenant ways of worship? Just guessing. I am certain that the OLD MAN is not passed away.
"All things that are become new" DO not include any of the old things - old things didn't become new, old things are passed away, DONE AWAY, abolished. Let me guess - "all things" that pertain unto life and godliness" are become new? But there are God's children, e.g. the Jews of Jesus' generation who hated all things that are become new in the Lord Jesus Christ.

Keep on teaching. I will listen with care, and weigh your instruction carefully.

Thank you most kindly

sing
=======

On Nov 6, 2007 4:09 AM Far-east wrote:

My Dear Brother Sing,

My heart goes out to you and I am so thankful for your sustained interest in God and His Holy Word, you love of truth, your humility, and patience.

I am fully aware that all of these blessing in your life are your by the grace and love of Almighty God through the merits of the finished work of His Son Jesus Christ.

I believe such privileges of groweth in grace and knowledge of the truth are available to each of God's little childrren according to their listening to the still voice of God leading them gently and continually within to will and to do of His good pleasure; but I am thankful to see the manifestation of love in you.

May the God of all grace sustain you and keep you near Himself. Isa. 57:15. To those who are of an humble and contrite spirit, they have the promise of God that He is and will be with them in the high and holy place.
I am of the opinion that anything in our lives that is like Jesus is a blessing of God and that anything in our live contrary to Jesus is sin.

What I believe about Romans 1, and whether you agree with me or not; does not affect how I feel about what I see manifest in you.

The heart of the old man and the heart of the new man are not the same heart. A child of God loves God from his new man. The heart is an expression of the innermost recesses of our being, sometimes used in the Bible as bowels. How could God write His love in a corrupt heart. That would be confusion.

The word 'regeneration' means - the act of generating again. We were generated in the family of Adam by pro-creation and now in the family of God by a new creation.

The word 'quicken' does not mean to remodel or overhaul, or repair. The word quicken means simply 'to give life, to make alive'. We were dead in sin before God and now after we are quickened, that is, we are alive to God by being generated by God our Father as a part of His family.

If there was a change in the heart of our Adam nature, that would only make us hate God less. The warfare of the flesh lusting against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh is not an indication of a change in the integral part of the nature of a human.

I do not question a born-again person loving God in their heart and it will always be because God first loved that person; but that love of God by the new creature will not always be made manifest before men and "manifest sons' is what I John is talking about. A baby that is born of God would have difficulty manifesting sonship.

In II Cor. 5:17, the all things that are become new are of God, verse 18. The new creature is of God, and is the all things that are become new. That new creature is made up of a spirit (Rom. 8:16, Acts 7:59, I Cor. 6:20, Gal. 6:18, I Thess. 5:23, II Tim. 4:22, James 2:26) and a mind (I Cor. 2:16, Rom. 7:25, 12:2, Phil. 2:5, I Pet. 1;13, 3:8) which are both new because they are of God. This work of God being done in one of the objects of His love is what makes the old man, the old nature, no longer in power. The power of our old nature is 'legally' passed away, but not vitally. Romans 6 says we are dead to sin, we were dead in sin before being born of God. Everything, in reference to our old man, our old nature, is legally finished, passed away, condemned, judgment is passed on it. It has no legal, rightful, ruling power anymore.

Bro. Bernardo, I love the man, he is a dear friend of mine, but he and I have had this discussion before and could not come to an agreement because he believes that in regeneration the old nature is changed, and I do not.

I would like to hear his answers to his last two questions as of 11/04/07 10:00PM post.

I have an old nature described in Romans 3, and the reason Romans 1:29 - 31 is so parallel is because it describes the same nature being lived out in children of God.

That which is born of God cannot be partaker in or guilty of these things because his seed remaineth in him and he cannot sin, because he is born of God. Therefore any sin must be attributed to our Adam nature. That which is born of the Spirit is spirit and that which is born of the flesh (Admic sinful nature) is flesh. Light and darkness, in the spiritual realm, have two completely different root sources. There is no merging of the two, nor any agreement. Therefore our old nature will always hate God and our new nature, new creature, that which is born of God, cannot hate God. If the two are made one in the same, then God has joined forces with sin. Now that would be confusion.

These are a few thoughts of mine at no cost to you.
God Bless You.
far-east USA.
=======

Sat Nov 10, 2007 12:40 pm

Brother Sing,

You ask "does EVERY child of God love God, and from the heart? Could you please affirm or deny whether EVERY CHILD of God loves God from the heart?"

Yes, Br. Sing, every child of God loves God from the heart. In the new birth, God implants (imparts) that love in every elected object of His redeeming love, and in intrinsic response to this implanting, EVERY ELECT REGENERATED CHILD is made to innately love God from the heart. You must consider that this aspect of Scriptural truth does not refer at all to the physical heart muscle in a human being, but rather to the principle of one's "SEAT OF AFFECTION."

Jeremiah 17:9 reads "The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?" This passage does not refer to the human heart muscle. Before the quickening power is vested in regeneration, every heart (the very seat of human emotions/affections) is depraved, desperately wicked. But, as a result of regeneration, this is no longer the case. The born-again (from above) heart (seat of affection/emotion) of an elect of God is "quickened" into divine life, eternal life, spiritual life, enveloped with love of God and love for God, and having had the righteousness of Christ Jesus vitally applied, all as a result of the new birth (regeneration). Thus, the seat of affection (referred to as the heart) of the regenerate person, without exception, is no longer desperately wicked, for it has been made holy and righteous and intrinsically LOVES GOD. Can you locate any Scripture anywhere that states or proves that a regenerated person DOES NOT LOVE God from the newly-born heart?

Many regenerated persons may not show that love externally, but that is not the point here under consideration. The present point is that intrinsic love, given and applied to an object of God's love, becomes spiritually innate with the child of God. This love is not something for which a person works to obtain; rather, a child of God is commanded to work "works of righteousness" in exercising faith in Christ because such an one has already been made to love God by His sovereign and irresistible grace.

Therefore, Romans 1:30 cannot apply to a regenerated person, but only to the unregenerate whose heart is desperately wicked. You said if I would "make a plain statement that EVERY child of God, without exception, loves God and does so from the heart, and I would conclude that the 'haters of God' in Romans 1:30 definitely and exhaustively exclude every child of God." Brother Sing, I have now plainly made that statement, so do you now make this your conclusion?

You made the request "Please tell us what constitute a man's hatred for God? May be that would help me to understand your point better." Depravity is that what constitutes a man's hatred for God. In a depraved person's total seat of affection, "The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?" (Jer. 17:9). The depraved (unregenerate) person is carnally minded and is, therefore, hostile (at enmity with hatred) against God (Rom. 8:6-7). Such a depraved person is dead in trespasses and sins, wherein in time past he walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that now worketh in the children of disobedience: Among whom also we all had our conversation in times past in the lusts of our flesh, fulfilling the desires of the flesh and of the mind; and were by nature the children of wrath, even as others" (Eph. 2:1-3).

Regeneration not only ADDS the Spirit of God and the intrinsic graces of that Spirit to an elect person, but actually gives a CHANGE OF NATURE to one. So God's act of regenerating an object of His love, in theological terms, is referred to as the washing of regeneration, renewing of the Holy Ghost, a new creation, a new birth, born-again (from above), a quickening, a translation, a raising up (resurrection), an effectual calling, and as irresistible grace. These are synonymous theological terms referring to the work of the Holy Spirit in the radical transformation of the soul whereby the elect receives a CHANGE OF NATURE. The Spirit of God, Who is an ADDITION to the elect being regenerated, needs no quickening, or new birth, or new creation, or translation, or resurrection, or effectual calling. The Holy Spirit is eternally and always perfect and needs no quickening or rebirthing. These special terms refer to principles that God applies to the elect person in regeneration, principles which establish and implant a NEW NATURE, even a CHANGE OF NATURE in the elect. So, the point is, that in regeneration there is both an ADDITION and a CHANGE OF NATURE which occurs within the elect.

Hope these thoughts help from a dyed-in-the-wool WT,
Bernardo
=======


Sat Nov 10, 2007 7:24 pm

Brother Bernardo,

That's overwhelming kind of response.
I do appreciate very much your seraphic response.

I just have a feeling that your response proves TOO,OOO much.
May be I am too obtuse to evaluate what have been said.
The mind of a not-yet PB is never that precisely calibrated yet!

Do 'haters of God' in Romans 1:30 necessarily mean hating God from the heart? If it is, then I must conclude that you have indeed proven your point. If it isn't, then your proof DOES NOT exclude God's children as 'haters of God.'

I do agree that "whosoever is born of God does not commit sin; for His seed remains in Him, and he cannot sin, because he is born of God." If he does not sin, and cannot sin, surely he is incapable of hating God in the SAME SENSE. That I agree with you.

I do believe a child of God does hate God in so many ways... e.g. God's children among the Jews in the Lord Jesus' generation manifest their hatred against God in various ways.

I do read of the Lord's complaint against His people:
"Wherefore the Lord said, forasmuch as this people draw near me with their lips do honor me, but have removed their heart far from me, and their fear toward me is taught by the precept of men." Is 29:13.

May be the Lord is complaining against reprobates. I am not sure. But would reprobates draw near to the Lord and honor Him, even though only with their lips? The reprobates' heart is already very far away from the Lord, why is there further need for them to remove it far from the Lord? May be the Lord is complaining against His heartless people

I have a feeling that often many of God's children love their Father from their lips only, and hate God by their actions and thoughts and beliefs, even though as you say, "every child of God loves God from their heart - the born-again (from above) heart (seat of affection/emotion)..."


keep dyeing the cotton wool,

your grateful student,
sing
=======

Monday, February 4, 2008

Regeneration - Elongated?


Apr 19, 2003 5:35 pm sing wrote:

Dear brethren,

Below is a series of questions asked by Karl, and the responses from Allon (both are pastors) on another discussion list, (a group of believers also holding to the 1689 CoF.)

I believe Regeneration is an interesting subject. You may find the Q&A very useful. Asking the right questions is an essential manner of learning sound doctrine.
-----------

Dear Brother Karl,

I am running about a week behind in reading my e-mail, but I think I am about to get caught up (as you can see, I am now reading two day old mail). I have enjoyed ALL of your good posts. If I am not too late, I would like to respond to your questions. I will try to answer them in the order given.

Question: “Now, lest you grow tired of my little analogy, in the person, the covenant child of God, the elect, unregenerate by nature, what takes place in regeneration?”

Answer: He is made a new creature.

Question: “Let me ask it like this, what part of the old man, {body, soul, spirit}, does God use to make the new man? Does God waste time on the old battery or install a new one?”

Answer: No part of the old man is used by God to make the new man. The old man (soul and spirit) remains totally functional and remains at enmity against God.


Question: “Does God just take up his abode in the old man and attempt to lead the old mind, heart, body in a new direction and make you miserable in the doing?”

Answer: No. God does NOT take up His abode in the carnal mind or heart, neither is the body changed at regeneration.

Question: “Does the Holy Ghost just come from time to time and charge you up, you have a feeling of power and excitement, or does He do a more drastic work?”

Answer: He does a more drastic work than just going in and out of the "old man". The new birth is a lot more than just a "warm fuzzy feeling" or an emotional high.

Question: “Does God just rebuild the old man, take of the same materials and restore what was?”

Answer: “No, regeneration is not just an over haul of the "old man" , but he creates a "new man" and puts it into the old body. This was answered by your battery analogy.”

You wrote: “If we think that the Holy Ghost just passes through on occasion to charge us up, then our battery was not really dead, just run down. But, if dead, had to be replaced. He does not just come and add acid or fire, but replaces the entire battery.”

Question: “Does God create in the same body a new creation, new man, totally separate from the old man in spirit-soul, heart-mind and house him in the same body of death?”

Answer: YES! Exactly that.

Question: “Is the old man, spirit-soul, heart-mind, still in the same body with the new man?”

Answer: Yes. The old man remains functional in spirit-soul, heart-mind until the death of the body.

Question: “Would this not really create a warfare between the two men in the same body?”

Answer: Yes indeed. This warfare is what Paul is describing in Romans Chapter 7
Let us notice a portion of this chapter:
14) For we know that the law is spiritual: but I am carnal, sold under sin.
15) For that which I do I allow not: for what I would, that do I not; but what I hate, that do I.
16) If then I do that which I would not, I consent unto the law that it is good.
17) Now then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.

In these verses and those that follow, Paul is describing TWO men in the SAME body: "I am carnal, sold under sin"; "it is no more I that do it".

Paul continues:
21) I find then a law, that, when I would do good, evil is present with me.
22) For I delight in the law of God after the inward man:
23) But I see another law in my members, warring against the law of my mind, and bringing me into captivity to the law of sin which is in my members.
24) O wretched man that I am! who shall deliver me from the body of this death?

The "old man" cannot please God, therefore, it continues to sin, but the "new man" delights to do the will of God and keep His commandments. The "new man" feels this conviction and is made to realize that there is a warfare going on inside of the body and it brings him into captivity to the law of sin. The "new man" groans and is in travail to be delivered from this captivity. The warfare and struggle becomes so intense that the "new man" is made to cry out, "O wretched man that I am! who shall deliver me from the body of this death?"

Question: “With which of these men in the same body does the Holy Ghost abide?”

Answer: The Holy Ghost abides in the "new creature" which abides (lives) in the carnal dying body.

Question: “If God uses the old man, in any part to make the new, would this not be a process rather than a creation?”

Answer:
Yes, but the new birth (regeneration) is not a process, but an instantaneous immediate act of God when He implants the "new creature" into the man (body).

Question: “If God uses means, (such as the gospel, faith, obedience, perseverance, etc.), then to what end? To just recharge the old or make the new?”

Answer: God does not use human means in the new birth, but He uses "means" (the gospel, prayer, reading and meditation of the Scriptures) to make manifest eternal life to the "new creature", thus, bring him hope and blessed assurance by giving him knowledge of the finished work of his Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. God also uses the a fore mentioned means to bring the born again child from babyhood to adulthood (maturity).

Question: “How much good would these means affect in the old, dead, battery, man?”

Answer: Means (the gospel, prayer, faith, obedience, perseverance, reading Scripture, etc) has absolutely NO effect on the "old man", because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God. (Romans 8:7-8)

Question: “Would these means not be more useful to the new man for life and not to give life?

Answer: YES! Means does not give life, but makes life manifest to the "new creature".

You wrote: “If these are not enough questions to make you think, I assure you I have more. I sure would like to hear some of your responses to these.

Brother Karl, I appreciate these GOOD questions. If I have answered them correctly, then I am ready for the next set. Maybe, we could put them all together in a book and call them "Karl-Stat Catechism".

I love this method of study (learning by questions).

In closing let us consider these verses:

1 Timothy 4:6 "If thou put the brethren in remembrance of these things, thou shalt be a good minister of Jesus Christ, nourished up in the words of faith and of good doctrine, whereunto thou hast attained."

2 Timothy 1:6 "Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands."

2 Timothy 2:14 "Of these things put them in remembrance, charging them before the Lord that they strive not about words to no profit, but to the subverting of the hearers."

2 Peter 1:12 "Wherefore I will not be negligent to put you always in remembrance of these things, though ye know them, and be established in the present truth. (13) Yea, I think it meet, as long as I am in this tabernacle, to stir you up by putting you in remembrance;"

God bless.

Allon

============


Sat Apr 19, 2003 5:35 pm Geek wrote:

Dear Sing,
I have been musing about Carl’s and Allen’s discussion on regeneration. I have one question to ask about your opinion. My question in ## .

Karl’s Question: “Does God create in the same body a new creation, new man, totally separate from the old man in spirit-soul, heart-mind and house him in the same body of death?

Allon’s Answer: YES! Exactly that.

My question: If this is true, wouldn’t that mean that a believer has two souls? The old and the new? Can this be possible? Or have I misunderstood Allen’s answer?

Geek
=======

Brother Geek,

If you have understood and agree with some of the thing Karl is conveying in his questions, you would realize that regeneration is the birth of a new spiritual man in an elect. A believer has two natures: the old sinful nature, and the new nature born from above. A believer is made up of two men - the old man and the new man. So there is the new man as the result of the regeneration. This new man is spiritual in nature. Regeneration is not renovating the old man. What is the constitution of the new man - that's is a question that need to be considered first. What do you think?

sing
=======

Sun Apr 27, 2003 6:39 pm, Kay-U

Dear brethren,

Have you all gone through the book 'Physicians of souls' by Dr Peter Masters? If you have, and have also read 'Redemption Accomplished & Applied' by Prof John Murray, you would have realized that Reformed people have held various views about the doctrine of REGENERATION.

In his book, Dr Peter Masters has stated that how we preach the gospel is determined by how we understand the doctrine of regeneration. According to Peter Masters, majority of Reformed people today hold to the once-for-all view of regeneration that was held by the late prof Murray. He states that most Reformed preachers today have embraced it through reading of Prof Murray's book 'Redemption Accomplished & Applied.

John Murray essentially presents the doctrine of regeneration as that regeneration is an instantaneous act of God in which He sovereignly does in the sinner, causing him to become a new creature and thus inevitably able to exercise faith and repentance.
Peter Masters argument is as follows:

Regeneration is an elongated process rather than an instantaneous act. He is in perfect agreement with John murray that regeneration is necessary before a sinner can consciously exercise faith and repentance. However, he differs in that he says that when God first begins to work in the sinner, this is what he calls initial regeneration, which is God's sovereign work in which sinners begin to see their spiritual lostness /danger. This is followed by awakening & conviction. This is then only followed by faith and repentance. Here, Peter Masters states that the stage of awakening and conviction is the protracted stage, which could take time depending on individual to individual- eg some instantly renounce their sins and embrace Christ while some may wrestle or be under deep soul searching etc for a long period before they reach the stage of faith and repentance.

Now, Peter Masters argues that how we present the gospel depends on how we understand regeneration. He says that it is only in the elongated view, in which preachers will plead and persuade sinners with zeal the way Whitefield, Spurgeon did. He says that John Murray's view, not only does it detract from the biblical proofs, it also is different from the view of the historic Calvinistics and Puritans and the framers of the Westminster Confession and Baptist Confession. He claims that because of this view, most of our contemporary evangelistic preaching by Reformed people lacks the element of the preacher urging and persuading people to come to Christ.

This whole thing seems confusing. Your insights to this would be most helpful.

Kay-U
============

Mon Apr 28, 2003 10:55 am sing wrote:

Dear brethren,

Brother Kay-U has raised a very interesting subject. I remember that the subject was dealt with by both Pastor Olyott and Pastor Masters at different conferences in the past. I believe it is mainly a matter of definition.

Perhaps the first matter is to consider the expressing 'once-for-all' as 'instantaneous' - since that is what is meant. Whether it is 'instantaneous' or 'elongated' they are both saying that regeneration is a once for all event, not to be repeated.

I believe that regeneration is instantaneous but the conversion (coming to repentance towards God and faith in Jesus Christ through the gospel preaching) is elongated. The part which Dr Masters would group together with regeneration - such as awakening and conviction and repentance and faith - are distinct from, and consequent to regeneration. They should be considered under the process of conversion - through the process of reasoning, explaining, demonstrating and persuading in the gospel preaching (Acts 17:1-4). Without the prior regeneration, it is utter futility to try to reason, explain, demonstrate and persuade - since 'the natural man does not receive the things of Spirit of God, for they are FOOLISHNESS to him, nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned' (1Cor 2:14).

Regeneration is instantaneous, and without means. Conversion is a process and requires gospel preaching to bring it about – it is clearly stated 'faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.' It is important not to confuse conversion with regeneration. Remembering that conversion is a process, a preacher would preach like apostle Paul did - wrestling with the hearers through reasoning, explaining, demonstrating and persuading. God’s children alone (regenerated elect) can be persuaded to believe the truth of their salvation by grace.

I quite doubt the connection construed by Dr Masters between one's view on regeneration and the manner one preaches.

just a quick thought written in sand,
sing
------

Mon Apr 28, 2003 4:11 pm

Dear sing,

Thanks for your thoughts on the issue of regeneration. I was going through Prof Murray's book on the chapter on regeneration. In pages 103 and 104 of his book (the Banner of Truth one), it leaves no doubt that faith & repentance result only after regeneration has taken place. But it also gives the impression that the moment one is regenerated, he then immediately is converted, that is, he exercises repentance & faith. In page 103,, paragraph 3, Prof Murray quotes 1 John 3:9, 5:4 and 5:18. He then states:

"When we put these texts together they expressly state that every regenerate person has been delivered from the power of sin, overcomes the world by the faith of Christ, and exercises that self-control by which he is no longer the slave of sin and of the evil one. That means, when reduced to simplest terms, that the regenerate person is converted and exercises faith and repentance....."

going then to page 104 of his book, the professor then states:

" ....If it is true that no one enters the kingdom of God except by regeneration (John 3:3-5), it is also just as true that everyone who is born again has entered into the kingdom of God..."

In other words, Prof Murray is saying that the moment regeneration has taken place, conversion takes place and the person is justified and adopted and made a child of God instantaneously.

Prof Murray correctly shows that regeneration must occur before one can believe the gospel. The question is, is the Professor also telling that the subsequent faith and repentance occurs immediately?

Of course, how the whole panorama of salvation occurs is only for God to know. Our finite minds are only allowed to grasp what he has revealed to us in scriptures. I will now humbly try to conclude what the two views of regeneration will imply in the salvation of individuals. Do correct me if I am wrong, as this is not something straightforward:

A man is unconverted, who hears the gospel preached. His heart is stirred and he sees that he is sinful against God. He struggles and wrestles and undergoes deep anxiety for months before he finally savingly turns from sin and embraces the Saviour.

Let us take a more classic case:

The Phillipian jailor. We don't know for certain when he heard the facts of the gospel. But up to the point just before the great earthquake in the jail, he is still dead in trespasses and sin and I would safely say that he was still unregenerate. Then suddenly, the earthquake comes, then he falls down before Paul and Silas and cries out "Sirs what must I do to be saved?" The apostle and Silas direct the jailor to Christ and the jailor believes and is converted!

CH Spurgeon's conversion:
For many years, Spurgeon knew all the facts of the gospel and even experienced deep conviction of sin. But it was only one particular day that the light suddenly dawned on him and he looked to Christ and was converted.

The question now is, if we apply either John Murray's (JM) view or Peter Master's (PM) view to the above 3 cases, we will get something like this:

case 1:
JM: The man was simply awakened at first. The Spirit of God can externally make the preached gospel cause deep anxiety about one's soul without actually effectually calling him and regenerating him. Then, at God's own appointed time, he effectually calls the person, regenerates him and he then believes the gospel, in an instant. Thus, those many months before that, the man was not yet regenerated.

PM: The man initially underwent initial regeneration or conception due to the sovereign work of God's Spirit who has begun effectually calling him. He is then brought to the stage of awakening and conviction which lasts for months before finally being brought to faith & repentance.

case 2:
JM: The jailor remained unregenerate. The earthquake awakens him and he begins to fall under a deep conviction of sin ( of course, he must have had some exposure to the gospel before that in terms of the facts, but now it grips him) He asks Paul how to be saved. Up to this point, no regeneration has taken place. Then, by the mighty work of the Spirit, effectual calling and regeneration take place and he 'believes on the Lord Jesus and is saved'

PM: The jailor underwent initial regeneration simultaneous to the earthquake. Awakening and conviction followed and he asks Paul how to be saved. Paul gave the answer. He is brought to faith. Here, the conversion experience is elongated , although faster compared to case 1

case 3:

JM: Spurgeon was unregenerate all those years, even during the time when he underwent deep conviction of sin. It was only when the light dawned on him during a preaching session that God sovereignly effectually called him, regenerated him and brought him to faith in an instant that he then was truly saved.

PM: Spurgeon underwent initial regeneration during the days when he was under conviction of sin, which was followed by a long period of awakening and conviction until finally one day, he was brought to saving faith and repentance.

As we can see above, the implications of both views on the application of salvation.

I agree with Pastor Lau that either view should not affect how the preacher preaches. I think the lack of persuasion and urging to repentance and faith might be due more to the fault of some preachers rather than due to his view of regeneration. You see, for Peter Master's view, his model may fit nicely with the idea that preaching should be more persuasive because when we evangelisticly urge sinners to come to Christ, we are working on the awakening/conviction phase. But then, why should'nt someone holding to John Murray's view also be equally fired up to call sinners to repentance? After all, he knows that although regeneration and conversion is God's work of sovereign grace, but God uses the instrumentality of preaching the gospel to cause the sinner to willingly respond with faith and repentance.

I think, correct me if I am wrong, the preacher who holds to Prof Murray's view does not try to figure out at what stage of the order salutis is his hearer. He is content to be sure that so long as that person gives no public and credible profession of repentance and faith, the person is to still be treated as unsaved or unregenerate and thus to be continually dealt huge doses of the gospel with plenty of urging and calling of the person to trust in Christ.

But if one holds to Peter Master's view, one might start to form an idea of what state of the order salutis the hearer is in based on how the hearer understands or responds to the word. In the case of outright unbeliever, it is no problem. But what of the seeker who seems to show interest and even some degree of conviction? But of course, to be fair, Peter Masters will not assure any hearer that he is converted until that hearer also gives a credible profession of faith.

I think the point to make here is that whichever view one holds to, it should not affect how we preach the gospel or how we deal with sinners or professing believers. I think that at the end of the day, God's word tells us enough to know that the order of salvation is regeneration, followed by repentance and faith so that we know that the new birth is necessary for a depraved and dead sinner to embrace the gospel and enter the kingdom. This is also so that we know that God is the author of regeneration and even faith and repentance and not man. But I think God has not given us the privilege of seeing the process of salvation unfold like the way embryologists talk about the stages of development of an embryo to become a fetus and then a newborn baby, We are only supposed to preach the gospel and recognise that regeneration and conversion has taken place by seeing the credible profession of repentance and faith in a person.

It can all be summed up as the underlying principle of historic Calvinism, that DIVINE SOVEREIGNTY IN SALVATION goes hand in hand with HUMAN RESPONSIBILITY TO GIVE ALL OF ONE'S EFFORT INTO THE PREACHING OF THE GOSPEL AND THE PLEADING TO SINNERS TO EMBRACE THE SAVIOUR.

Anyway, just for the sake of doctrinal clarity, which view is the correct one, or maybe both views are reconcilable?

In Christ,

Kay-U
=====

Tue Apr 29, 2003 11:25 am, sing wrote:

Dear brother Paul,

My comments within in your post in bracket ## … ##

Thanks for your thoughts on the issue of regeneration. I was going through Prof Murray's book on the chapter on regeneration. In pages 103 and 104 of his book (the Banner of Truth one), it leaves no doubt that faith & repentance result only after regeneration has taken place. But it also gives the impression that the moment one is regenerated, he then immediately is converted , that is he exercises repentance & faith. In page 103,, paragraph 3, Prof Murray quotes 1 John 3:9, 5:4 and 5:18. He then states:

## I believe when there is agreement about the absolute necessity and the priority of regeneration to and for conversion. There may be different opinions on the outworking of these two principles. ##

"When we put these texts together they expressly state that every regenerate person has been delivered from the power of sin, overcomes the world by the faith of Christ, and exercises that self-control by which he is no longer the slave of sin and of the evil one. That means, when reduced to simplest terms, that the regenerate person is converted and exercises faith and repentance....."

going then to page 104 of his book, the professor then states:

" ....If it is true that no one enters the kingdom of God except by regeneration (John 3:3-5), it is also just as true that everyone who is born again has entered into the kingdom of God..."
In other words, Prof Murray is saying that the moment regeneration has taken place, conversion takes place and the person is justified and adopted and made a child of God instantaneously.

## Regeneration is instantaneous but conversion is a process, sometimes may be quite elongated. Though conversion is chronologically after regeneration, it is not necessary that it follows immediately after conversion. It is regeneration that puts a sinner to the road of seeking and searching for the truth. [I am NOT saying that any who gives an appearance of seeking is regenerated. Many are seeking after carnal things! and not the things of the Spirit of God.]##

Prof Murray correctly shows that regeneration must occur before one can believe the gospel. The question is, is the Professor also telling that the subsequent faith and repentance occurs immediately?

## Conversion - faith and repentance - may occur immediately after regeneration... or a much longer period may also intervene. The many cases of the proselytes - Ethiopian eunuch, Cornelius, Lydia, etc - described as 'fearer of God', I believe they were regenerated long before their conversion to Christ through the preaching of the gospel to them. [Abraham’s regeneration at Ur preceded his conversion at Gen 15:1-6 by many years.]

[Simultaneous regeneration and conversion is logically IMPOSSIBLE. Preaching takes time, hearing the preached word takes time. The regenerate elect takes time to hear, wrestle, and understand – and these many take a long time =- before he can be brought to faith in Jesus Christ. ##

Of course, how the whole panorama of salvation occurs is only for God to know. Our finite minds are only allowed to grasp what he has revealed to us in scriptures. I will now humbly try to conclude what the two views of regeneration will imply in the salvation of individuals. Do correct me if I am wrong, as this is not something straightforward:

A man is unconverted, who hears the gospel preached. His heart is stirred and he sees that he is sinful against God. He struggles and wrestles and undergoes deep anxiety for months before he finally savingly turns from sin and embraces the Saviour.

## Regeneration must have taken place (at least logically) before the gospel is preached, otherwise the man would consider the gospel 'foolishness! (1Cor 2:14.) ##

Let us take a more classic case:

The Phillipian jailor. We don't know for certain when he heard the facts of the gospel. But up to the point just before the great earthquake in the jail, he is still dead in trespasses and sin and I would safely say that he was still unregenerate. Then suddenly, the earthquake comes, then he falls down before Paul and Silas and cries out "Sirs what must I do to be saved?" The apostle and Silas directs the jailor to Christ and the jailor believes and is converted!

## We can't say for certain whether he is regenerated before or after the earthquake. It is certain that he must have been regenerated before he could utter the words, 'what must I do to be saved?' To ask that question implies that he is aware of spiritual realities of being lost... the need to be saved... that there is salvation, etc. even though he may not have heard the gospel before. Regeneration is always without means – the Spirit of God acts directly and immediately upon an elect sinner. Conversion is always with gospel means. ##

CH Spurgeon's conversion:
For many years, Spurgeon knew all the facts of the gospel and even experienced deep conviction of sin. But it was only one particular day that the light suddenly dawned on him and he looked to Christ and was converted.

## People say that he was a theologian before he was a Christian. His unique background made this a very high possibility.##

The question now is, if we apply either John Murray's (JM) view or Peter Master's (PM) view to the above 3 cases, we will get something like this:

## I think JM deals more with the logical order of regeneration and conversion, and not so much period that elapse between the two. PM is dealing more with what happens between regeneration and conversion. So it is a little difficult to compare the two, I would think. ##

case 1:
JM: The man was simply awakened at first. The Spirit of God can externally make the preached gospel cause deep anxiety about one's soul without actually effectually calling him and regenerating him . Then, at God's own appointed time, he effectually calls the person, regenerates him and he then believes the gospel, in an instant. Thus, those many months before that, the man was not yet regenerated.

PM: The man initially underwent initial regeneration or conception due to the sovereign work of God's Spirit who has begun effectually calling him. He is then brought to the stage of awakening and conviction which lasts for months before finally being brought to faith & repentance.

## Would JM consider the 'awakened at first' to be different from regeneration? PM would call that as 'initial regeneration.' I could hardly believe that the 'awakened at first' is not regeneraion itself or that initial regeneration is not a full regeneration! A new birth is a new birth... not a birth in measures or stages!!! ##


just some thoughts,

sing
======

Mon Apr 28, 2003 3:11 pm tomy wrote:

Yes I remember Pastor Olyott speaking on that in an earlier conference, and it also appears to be one of Peter Masters' favourite. Why can't regeneration be instantaneous or elongated? After all it is the Spirit's work.

One's view on the regeneration process (in this context) and the manner of preaching are mutually exclusive. Are we splitting hairs here?

In my quick flipping through of Pink and Charnock I don't see them making this an important issue. If anything (i could be wrong) Charnock seems to say that regeneration is instant! Perhaps this may be an interesting M.Div thesis - The Puritan's view on the duration of regeneration!

tomy
======

Tue Apr 29, 2003 12:27 pm tomy wrote:

Dear Kay-U,

I think no Christian worth the name 'reformed' will doubt that regeneration precedes conversion - so that's taken care of.

The late EF Kevan seemed to distinguish two elements of regeneration 1) The impartation spiritual life and 2) the birth process- implying the possibly that regeneration could be a process (elongated). No mention of how prolonged that process can be.

The second issue is the interpretation of human response to the gospel. The apostle Paul also warned us that there are those who sorrow without biblical repentance (2 Cor.7:10). Perhaps Bunyan is a classic case of being sorrowful on and off for long periods of time before actual repentance and faith. Was he a case of elongated regeneration or was he just sorrowing after the manner of the world?

A person needs to repent, profess faith and walks the path of righteousness, before I am 100% comfortable (humanly speaking) that his sorrowing after sin was a work of grace.

thinking out loud (and can still be wrong!)

tomy
========

Wed Apr 30, 2003 8:09 am Kirk wrote:

Dear Kay-U & other brethren,

Sing seems to hold to an elongated conversion. He added that instantaneous regeneration is without means.

I personally hold to Dr Masters' view of an elongated regeneration. Though we do not know the actual mechanism in the regenerating process, I believe that means are involved - 1 Peter 1:23 "being born again...through the living and enduring word of God".

So it appears to me that the Holy Spirit uses the Word (i.e., our preaching) to bring about regeneration. How does He do that? Would it be that during our preaching, the Holy Spirit suddenly jerks the sinner and awakens him?

I think not - at least, not normally. I believe the Spirit uses our reasoning and persuasion and pleading to bring about conviction. This may happen in one preaching session or in many sessions over a period of time. Then one day, the birth takes place & the sinner cries out in repentance and faith.

I liken this regenerating process to child-birth. Once the seed is planted, the process has begun. Initially, it is not so obvious. After a period of gestation the baby is finally born & she makes the first cry.

by no means got all the answers,

Kirk
=========


Wed Apr 30, 2003 1:19 am

Dear Kirk and brethren,

Here comes the bride in beautiful black, with two red carnations.

Distinction is the essence of sound theology!
Regeneration is the sovereign work of the Spirit of God and it is without means - John 3:3-8. In regeneration man is entirely passive because he is spiritually dead. In his state of spiritual deadness, all the means would have no effects upon him in any case. All the means - even 'the things of the Spirit of God' - would be 'foolishness' to an un-regenerated man, dead in sins and trespasses, 1Cor 2:14. So, really, no amount of means can regenerated a man!!! Without the prior new birth, there is NO seeing the kingdom of God, and there is NO entering the kingdom of God.

I have not said that conversion is without means. Conversion is the active response of sinners to the preaching of the word of God - which involves reasoning, explaining, demonstrating, persuading, etc. Yes, the Holy Spirit is pleased to use all these to bring about conviction of sin, of judgement, of righteousness... and repentance and faith – conversion to the truth. 'So then faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.' They is an active and dynamic interaction between the preacher and the regenerated person. We are to preach in such a way as to secure conversion to the truth of the gospel... but no amount of preaching can bring about regeneration.

Often John 3:3-8 is misused, and hearers are commanded to be born again - as though the hearers are called upon to do something to bring about their new birth. 'Ye must be born from above' is a statement of fact, in the indicative mood, and not imperative mood. It speaks of the absolute necessity of the new birth - literally 'from above,' anothen

You quoted: 1Pet 1:23 says, 'having been born again, not of corruptible seed but incorruptible, through the word of God which lives and abides forever.... but the word of the LORD endures forever.'

Please consider very carefully whether 'the word of God which lives and abides forever' here refer to the preached word. The adjectives 'incorruptible' and the adverbs 'lives and abides forever' would point us away from the preached word by even the most eloquent preachers. But as in 'so then faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God,' it is clear from the context that 'the word of God' is the preached word because preacher is mentioned in verse 10:14.

Another similar passage like 1Pet 1:23 is Heb 4:12, 'For the word of God is living and powerful, and sharper than any double-edged sword, piercing even to the division of soul and spirit, and of joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart.' The next verse tells us that 'the word of God' here is a person. 'And there is no creature hidden from His sight, but all things are naked and open to the eyes of Him to whom we must give account.' [The knee-jerk reaction is to say that ‘the word of God’ refers to the Scriptures or the preached word. I say it refers to the second person of the Trinity, John 1:1.

The illustration of childbirth is useful only if we define the various terms in the process. To me, the instantaneous conception speaks of the instantaneous regeneration, instantaneous begetting of life... the gestation period is the interval between regeneration and conversion. [However, I don't think the child-birth is a suitable illustration for regeneration.] The spiritual gestation period may vary from being negligible to considerable lengthy period, but in physical birth, it is fairly fixed by nature.

good to discuss and search for clarity of thought,
sing
-----

Wed Apr 30, 2003 1:38 am

Dear Kirk and brethren,

Just one more thought to clarify:

Regeneration can happen BEFORE, DURING or AFTER the hearing of the preached word. However it is not because of the preached word or any human means that brings about regeneration, that's is, regeneration is without means, but directly and immediately (no human means) the work of the Holy Spirit upon a sinner.

keep on talking to sharpen our ploughshares
sing
=========

Tue Apr 29, 2003 7:24 pm Kay-U wrote:

Dear Kirk,

Thanks for your contribution. Just wanted to clarify. The part you mentioned:
== I think not - at least, not normally. I believe the Spirit uses our reasoning and persuasion and pleading to bring about conviction. This may happen in one preaching session or in many sessions over a period of time. Then one day, the birth takes place & the sinner cries out in repentance and faith. ==

When you mentioned birth taking place and the sinner cries out in repentance and faith, is this birth synonymous with regeneration or new birth? Because you mean that to be regeneration, then it means that regeneration occurs instantly and conversion follows at once. This will then mean that when the hearer over a period of time falls under conviction, he was still not yet regenerated. Just wanted to clarify.

I personally, though I must myself pour over more texts of scripture to strengthen my understanding, I personally agree with sing (… ), in that Peter Masters and John Murray actually do not contradict each other. I think both of these great men, and also all of us agree beyond any doubt that regeneration MUST take place, before a sinner can see the kingdom of God and enter in via repentance and faith. Sing mentioned that conversion may take place immediately or sometimes after a prolonged period, and this actually explains why the ways in which God's elect are saved (converted) differ. Some, during periods of powerful revival, eg the Edwards-Whitefield awakening, are regenerated and converted instantaneously as the Spirit of God mightily attended the gospel preaching of Edwards and Whitefield. We have to agree that most conversions don't occur so dramatically, but nevertheless, they do occur; such that the seeker first undergoes regeneration and is made anxious about his soul and seeks hard to find the Saviour through hearing sermons and reading the scriptures until conversion occurs. Most of these conversions are such that the conversion process is so gradual that the convert cannot pinpoint exactly when he got truly converted.

I think John Murray was attempting more to give the order of regeneration and conversion, and to establish that:
In every regeneration, there will be conversion.
In every conversion, there was preceding regeneration.

Prof Murray was so determined to emphasize this truth that people might have even misconstrued the professor's writings to suggest that conversion always immediately takes the place the moment regeneration has occurred, without even entertaining the possibility that conversion might take place later after a prolonged period of Spirit led awakening and conviction.

Much as we respect and value Dr Master's works and contributions to the Reformed faith, I personally feel that he should not have criticized Prof Murray's writings in his book 'Physicians of souls', but rather should have given the late professor the benefit of the doubt. I have personally listened to Al Martin's sermons on tape, who is a man who greatly admires John Murray and has been greatly influenced by his writings; and find that Al Martin actually pleads and persuades with fervour and passion to call sinners or false professing church goers to repent and come to Christ.

glad to be able to discuss biblical issues over the email. good for learning.

Kay-U
==========

Wed Apr 30, 2003 8:45 am, Geek wrote:

Dear brethren,
If a man is regenerated and converted later, what is his status before God when he was regenerated? Is he in the kingdom of God or still outside?
just trying to clear my confused mind,
Eng Ghee
=======

Wed Apr 30, 2003 9:09 am

Dear Geek,

You would be referring to that period of time which ranges from a microsecond and several months? Never thought of that before! But if salvation has a forensic element then drawing upon the OT saints' status the person would be in the kingdom of God.
That is perhaps just a theoretical consideration because surely a man will be converted if he is regenerated.

getting more confused by the moment, waiting to hear more

tomy
=======

Wed Apr 30, 2003 12:43 pm sing wrote:

Dear Tomy and Geek,

You have got the bull's eye by saying, 'salvation has a forensic element.' That is really the answer to Geek’s good question. [A forensic element' implies a non-forensic, i.e. experiential/practical element.]

Let me illustrate by a passage of what I mean - Titus 1:1-3
"Paul, a bondservant of God and an apostle of Jesus Christ, according to the faith of God's elect and the acknowledgement of the truth which accords with godliness, in hope of eternal life which God, who cannot lie, promised before time began, but has in due time manifested His word through preaching, which was committed to me..."

Note the phrases 'promised before time began' and 'in due time manifested.'

Eternal life is promised to God's elect before time began. Forensically, eternal life is already the portion of God's elect - secured by the finished work of Jesus Christ at the cross. So also the eternal life is the portion of God's elect who are not yet born! It is theirs... why? It was promised to, and secured for them. God cannot lie.

But in due time that eternal life applied to an elect personally, and that eternal life became manifested... brought to light... such that an elect child of God come into a conscious and experiential knowledge and enjoyment of this eternal life that was promised him before time began. This began with the application of that eternal life through regeneration (through the direct and immediate activity of the Holy Spirit without means) and conversion (through gospel means of preaching, etc).

This point is brought out beautifully in 2Tim 1:8-11 "Therefore do not be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me His prisoner, but share with me in the sufferings for the gospel according to the power of God, who has saved us and called us with a holy calling, not according to works, but according to His own purpose and grace which was given to us in Christ Jesus before time began, but has now been revealed by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who has abolished death and brought life and immortality to light through the gospel, to which I was appointed a preacher, an apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles."

All the blessings of election were already given to the elect in Christ before time began! And these blessings of life and immortality given to the elect before time began is brought to light, made manifest through the gospel preached. The preaching of the gospel does not create salvation but make manifest the salvation which God has promised before time began and bringing it to pass in time. Therefore apostle Paul laboured and suffered in preaching the gospel to all, knowing that the regenerated elect among his hearers will be made manifest through the gospel preached.

Similarly the elect were already Christ's sheep before they hear and follow him. It is not their hearing and following of Christ that makes them sheep. If they were not sheep, they won't hear and follow.

To answer your question, "If a man is regenerated and converted later, what is his status before God when he was regenerated? Is he in the kingdom of God or still outside?"

His legal status before God has always been and will ever be God's beloved in Christ from before the foundation of the world, even before he was conceived or born. Forensically, he is in the kingdom of God. Experientially, he is not in the kingdom of God - he is just like any other unbelieving sinners. Experientially, he would be in the kingdom of God only when he enters it through repentance and faith, conversion. At conversion he enters into an experiential knowledge of God as his Father - crying out 'Abba Father - because the gift of the Spirit of adoption is given (Romans 8:15)... the right to become children of God is given/experienced (John 1:12). It is the Spirit of adoption Himself who bears witness with our regenerated spirit that we are children of God... through repentance and faith.

sorry for my rambling,
sing

p/s there are regenerated elect (sentient) of God who are not converted at all. Read 1689.10.3 please. But a person who hears the gospel and does not repent and believe has ABSOLUTELY NO GROUND WHATSOEVER to think that he is an elect of God (note the simple present tense please).
===========

Wed Apr 30, 2003 12:31 pm, Kay-U wrote:

Dear Pastors and brethren,

Regarding the thought about where is the person in between the time he is regenerated and the time he is converted, I also never thought of it. If we look from a temporal or human standpoint, then it is true that we have a question here. One thing is, the pronouncement of justification would take place only upon saving faith. So then, before that, the sinner is not yet justified, therefore still in emnity against God. I think that until the seeker has truly turned from sin and embraced the Saviour, they would still be considered dead in sin and under the condemnation of God. It would be the worst kind of seeking when the sinner tells God that he is regenerated, therefore now able to embrace the gospel (not totally depraved or unable) and then believe. It would be as crazy as a man who believes he is regenerated, therefore effectually called, therefore elected from eternity, before he responds in faith and repentance.

I agree with Al Martin in one of his sermons that he said that a preacher must systematically present the truths in the bible, but yet we must not imagine that we can compartmentalise all the doctrines so neatly like an engineering flowchart until a man's experience of salvation becomes so 'mechanical'. Thank God that he has made it clear in his word that regeneration precedes conversion, and that He will see to it that these two acts will take place in every convert. For the seeker, his/her duty is to seek the Savior as what the bible says he/ she is- a guilty, dead, sinner who is impotent to save himself. Thus, until he has experienced in his heart the forgiveness of his sins, he is to be clear in his mind that he is totally depraved, guilty, condemned ( even though God may have already worked initial regeneration in him). Even after we are converted, we are to be like Paul in Romans 7:
Rom 7:14 For we know that the law is spiritual: but I am carnal, sold under sin.Rom 7:15 For that which I do I allow not: for what I would, that do I not; but what I hate, that do I.Rom 7:16 If then I do that which I would not, I consent unto the law that it is good.Rom 7:17 Now then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.Rom 7:18 For I know that in me (that is, in my flesh,) dwelleth no good thing: for to will is present with me; but how to perform that which is good I find not.Rom 7:19 For the good that I would I do not: but the evil which I would not, that I do.Rom 7:20 Now if I do that I would not, it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.Rom 7:21 I find then a law, that, when I would do good, evil is present with me.Rom 7:22 For I delight in the law of God after the inward man:Rom 7:23 But I see another law in my members, warring against the law of my mind, and bringing me into captivity to the law of sin which is in my members.Rom 7:24 O wretched man that I am! who shall deliver me from the body of this death?Rom 7:25 I thank God through Jesus Christ our Lord. So then with the mind I myself serve the law of God; but with the flesh the law of sin.

I have come to realise that it is really not important for a person to be able to pin-point precisely at which point in his life that he got converted, even more so that he need not be able to tell precisely the date in which he got regenerated. The most important thing is, for the person to ask himself, even after all his dramatic or non-dramatic experience of repentance and faith; is he today, at present converted? Is he today, still having continual repentance from sin and faith in his Savior? Is he today, still trusting fully on Christ's propitiatory death and justifying righteousness as the ONLY ground for his justification? Does his lifestyle today reflect growth in grace and godliness and greater dying to self?

Those who embrace dispensational and Arminian teachings today will find the above very hard to swallow. To them, they are always looking back at a certain time and place where their so called converts prayed a prayer of salvation or 'invited Jesus into my heart' or 'decided for Jesus' or went forward to an 'altar call'. As long as they can be satisfied at these past experiences, they don't care even if the convert today is living worldly and being a reproach to Christ's name.

Just some further thoughts on the profound doctrine of regeneration.

Kay-U
=======

Wed Apr 30, 2003 1:17 pm sing wrote

Dear Kay-U,

You wrote: I have come to realise that it is really not important for a person to be able to pin-point precisely at which point in his life that he got converted, even more so that he need not be able to tell precisely the date in which he got regenerated. The most important thing is, for the person to ask himself, even after all his dramatic or non-dramatic experience of repentance and faith; is he today, at present converted? Is he today, still having continual repentance from sin and faith in his Savior? Is he today, still trusting fully on Christ's propitiatory death and justifying righteousness as the ONLY ground for his justification? Does his lifestyle today reflect growth in grace and godliness and greater dying to self?

Experientially, you have stated the bottom line!! A converted man is now a converting, repenting and believing man. [Conversion is a life long process – very elongated, beginning with initial conversion to faith in Jesus.]

sing

Keach is Bleached!


Keach or Quiche?

A leader of a Reformed Baptist church quoted Benjamin Keach, a prominent early Particular Baptist and a signer of the 1689 London CoF, and insisted that Keach taught that faith, the act of believing, is a condition for actual (legal and personal) justification before God as well as eternal life, i.e. justification and eternal life is conditioned upon faith, the act of believing.

Let the reader judge for himself. Below is the quote from Keach, followed with some observations and comments.

Question:
But doth not the gospel require faith as a condition of justification and eternal life?
Answer:
1. Yea as a condition of connexion by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another (as our author observes) in logic, if a creature be a man, he is a rational creature; or if God be the first cause, he is the Creator of all things. and in this sense (saith he) creation is a condition of salvation, if a man be saved, he must be created; so if a man believe, he shall be saved; believing is a condition of connexion, a state of grace, is thus a condition of a state of glory, by way of connexion in the promise, but one is not the federal condition of another, but both come in as the gift of grace. In this sense the covenant contains all the conditions of order and dependence in the exhibition and performance; the hearing the word is the condition of faith, but hearing is not a federal condition; so the giving the Spirit is the condition of our union with Christ and of faith, and faith the condition of our receiving of pardon, and living a holy life - and holiness the condition of seeing God, and of having eternal life; but these kinds of conditions are federal entitling conditions to the promise, but are contained in the promise, and denote the connexion and dependence of one promise benefit with another.

2. Though faith be required of them that are saved, yea, and repentance, regeneration, holiness, and a new heart also; yet these blessings are all promised in the covenant, as part thereof. but faith itself is no federal condition, but only serves to show what God will do for, and work in such that he as an act of free grace will save.

From hence we may see how woefully blind they are, who assert faith, repentance, and sincere obedience are not only federal conditions of justification, but also are the matter or material cause thereof. And this is to buy the pearl indeed with our own money.

[emphasis bold is mine, sing]
------------

First, let me say that I don't claim to understand everything Keach said in the quote above. However, certain things are quite plain and without controversy.

Let me make one final attempt to reason with you and your church concerning what Keach said is the biblical relationship between faith on the one hand, and justification AND eternal life on the other.

A. Some preliminary observations:

1. Please note that in the question, the justification and eternal life are considered together in relation to faith, the act of believing. The coupling of justification with eternal life clearly determines which aspect of justification is spoken of… not the legal justification (virtual) at the cross, not the experiential justification (declarative) at initial conversion… BUT the vital/personal (actual) justification at effectual calling to grace and salvation. [Most RBs are ignorant that there are several aspects of justification spoken of in the Scriptures, see 1689.11.4). At effectual calling by God’s appointed and approved time, vital/personal justification, regeneration and adoption occur – in that logical order, though chronologically, it is instantaneous.

2. Please note very carefully that Keach said, “Yea as a condition of connection by way of order." He DID NOT just say, ‘Yea as a condition.’ If he has said the latter, then there might be just enough ground to construe that faith, the act of believing, is a condition to vital justification and eternal life. What’s the different between the two?

3. Keach further said, ‘Yea as a condition of connection by way of order, as one thing dependeth on another in logic.’

So what is the logic spoken of? What is the logic by way of order? In which order is logic exhibited? Does the logic of order consist in ‘the act of believing as a condition IN ORDER to obtain actual justification before God and eternal life? Or does the logic of order consist in ‘the act of believing gives evidence of the justified state and possession of eternal life by God’s free grace’? In which is there logic - the former or the latter?

Is there logic in the view that a condemned [i.e. un-justified] man and dead in trespasses and sins [i.e. devoid of eternal life] is able to believe [a spiritual activity] IN ORDER to obtain justification and eternal life?

Is there logic in the view that a justified man [i.e. no longer condemned] with eternal life [i.e. no longer dead in trespasses and sins] believes to manifest and evidence his justified state and eternal life?

4. Keach illustrated the logic spoken of with various examples:
a. “If a creature be a man, he IS a rational creature; [semi colon]”
- ‘If a man believes, he IS a spiritual creature.’ If a man believes, he does so because he IS a spiritual creature, he possesses eternal life, and only a justified man (with condemnation of death removed and imputed with the righteousness of life) is able to believe. There is plain logic in this. Also, it is perfectly Scriptural, "The just shall live by faith." It is the justified ones that shall live by faith. It is not 'the condemned shall believe and be justified'!
- ‘If an un-justified man, dead in trespasses and sins, shall believe, then he will become a spiritual being’ is not only anti-scriptural but also plain irrational nonsense.

b. “if God be the first cause, he is the Creator of all things, and in this sense (saith he) creation is a condition of salvation, if a man be saved, he must be created; [semi colon]”
- ‘If a man be saved, he must be created.’ It is claimed and insisted that ‘created’ here means physical creation. What logic or connection has physical creation to do with salvation (justification and eternal life)?
- ‘Creation is a condition of salvation’: Spiritual creation by the sovereign and free grace act of God applies personally to an elect the eternal salvation purchased by Jesus Christ is a condition - of connection by way of order – of salvation. With the new creation, there is evidence or manifestation that the salvation secured by Jesus Christ is applied personally.
– ‘If a man be saved, he must be created.’ The Scriptures plainly declare that spiritual creation, i.e. regeneration or the new birth from heaven is prerequisite to salvation. Except a man be born again, he CANNOT see… CANNOT enter…’ His seeing and entering is a condition of connection by way of order that salvation HAS BEEN applied personally by God’s free grace.
- The logic of ‘If a man be saved, he must be created’ is simply this: spiritual creation precedes believing in order to evidence and manifest that eternal salvation brought about by the free and sovereign work of the new creation by the Triune God.

c. ‘… so if a man believe, he shall be saved; [semi colon] …’
- ‘He shall be saved’ speak of a salvation that shall be experienced, in distinction from the eternal salvation already bestowed by God’s free and sovereign grace that enables a man to believe. So, don’t latch on to the SOUND of the words and miss the SENSE of what is said. There is an eternal salvation bestowed upon an elect once for all at effectual calling to grace and eternal salvation that enables a child of God to work out his own salvation with fear and trembling. If a man believe, he shall be saved from the evil consequences and chastisement of unbelief in this life as God’s child. Apostle Paul said to Timothy, “Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee.” 1Ti 4:16

d. “believing is a condition of connexion, a state of grace, is thus a condition of a state of glory, by way of connexion in the promise, but one is not the federal condition of another, but both come in as the gift of grace. [period]
- Believing is a condition (of connection by way order) that demonstrates a state of grace and salvation; it is thus a condition of connection by way order of a state of glory. A state of grace and salvation is a state of glory, no longer a state of condemnation. Unbelief is a condition of connection by way order of a state of condemnation.
- ‘Both come in as the gift of grace’ Effectual call to grace and salvation is a gift of grace. The ability to believe is also a work of grace by the Holy Spirit dwelling in the heart.
- ‘The federal condition of one another’ would be making believing as the condition for a condemned and spiritually dead man to comply in order to obtain justification and eternal life.


B. Some Comments:

Keach mentioned at least THREE different ways in which faith is seen as related to Justification and Eternal Life.

1. Faith is understood by some as the "matter or material cause" of Justification and eternal life. Simply stated, this view elevates faith to the same level with the righteousness of Jesus Christ. Justification before God requires righteousness; sin brought condemnation. Righteousness is the matter required if the condemnation is to be undone. Faith plays no role whatsoever in the reversal of the condemnation of death! But so many see faith as the material cause of justification and life. Of course, you know enough to reject this as error. Those who see faith in this manner is described by Keach as 'woefully blind' concerning the gospel truth of Justification and Eternal life.
This view may be represented as: Faith/Believing => Justification and Eternal life.


2. Faith is seen by others as the "federal condition" of Justification and eternal life. Faith is a necessary condition that the unjustified condemned dead sinner must have in order to be Justified by the righteousness of Christ. They also trumpet loud and clear that 'faith is a gift of God.' They fail to see the insanity and vanity of the gift of faith to one still dead in trespasses and sins! What good is such a gift to a dead man who is utterly incapable of making use of the gift? This view does distinguish faith of a man from the righteousness of Christ, but this view insists that there must be faith first before the righteousness of Christ is imputed or applied to the condemned. From all that you have written, I understand that you hold to this view.

Keach plainly declares, "faith itself is no federal condition." Those who see faith in this manner is described by Keach as 'woefully blind' concerning the gospel truth of Justification and Eternal life. How woefully blind they are who assert that faith is a federal condition of justification - only the woefully blind believe that the unjustified condemned can meet this federal condition.
This view may be represented as:
Faith => Righteousness of Christ imputed => Justification and Eternal life

All your reading of Keach has not led you to the truth. Instead, you have misrepresented Keach in many ways.

3. Faith is seen by Keach as the "condition of connexion by way of order" of Justification and Eternal life. Put simply, faith is a condition, but a condition of connection by way of order to declare and attest the Justification that has taken place by God's free grace. In exactly the same SENSE, faith is the condition of connection by way of order to declare and attest the eternal life that has been born by God's free grace.

This view may be represented as:
Righteousness of Christ APPLIED personally => Justification + Eternal Life => Faith (the instrument to declare and attest the Justification and Eternal life already bestowed by God's free grace.)

SDC holds to this third view.

God, by His grace, freely justifying and regenerating an elect when in state of condemnation and death IS THE CAUSE.
They, the justified regenerated ones, receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness by faith IS THE EFFECT.
The CAUSE is distinct and separate and prior to the EFFECT. Read 1689.11.1 and it is abundantly clear.

Brother, unless and until you get these basic and fundamental points into your head, you will keep going on in your confusion.
1. God APPLYING the righteousness of Christ to a person under the condemnation of death is Vital/Persona/Actual Justification. An elect under the condemnation of death, i.e. unjustified, is dead and cannot possibly believe.
2. God imputing the faith of a believer to him for righteousness is Declarative/Experiential Justification. An elect person who believes Declares and Experiences that he is already in the state of grace and salvation - justified, regenerated and adopted. Faith declares and attests to that fact. That's what happened in Gen 15.

If your faith is before justification (Actual), you have made faith a federal condition of justification (Actual), the error of which is roundly condemned and censured by Keach.

A representative of the early Particular Baptist and respected by Calvinistic men of other denominations declared, "... no man is evidentially and declaratively justified until he believes." And this is nothing about Vital/Personal/Actual Justification by grace at effectual calling. This is all about Declarative Justification by faith.

Thanks for listening. I have discharged my duty.

sing
"And some believed the things which were spoken,
and some believed not" Acts 28:24